Back to articles
    Scottish Premiership in FC 27: Which Player Ratings Has EA Got Wrong?

    19 November 2026

    Scottish Premiership in FC 27: Which Player Ratings Has EA Got Wrong?

    Falkirk are third, Hibs and Aberdeen are in the bottom three, and the league's joint top scorer has a 57-rated card. EA set the FC 27 ratings in the summer, before a ball was kicked in the Premiership. Three months in, how well do they hold up?

    EA SPORTS FC 27 rates the Premiership the way most people did in July. Rangers and Celtic have nearly all of the best cards: Nicolas Raskin is a 79, Alistair Johnston and Cameron Carter-Vickers are 78s, and Lawrence Shankland, Callum McGregor and Kieran Tierney sit at 77. Hearts' best card is Cláudio Braga on 76. Falkirk's highest-rated players, Scott Bain and Brad Spencer, are both 68.

    The table going into the international break looks different. Celtic lead on 31 points from 13 games, Rangers have 27 from 12, and Falkirk are third on 21, a point ahead of Hearts. Hibernian and Aberdeen, whose best cards are rated 72 and 73, are tied on 11 points in tenth and eleventh. Some of that is injuries, some is form, and some is simply that a rating fixed in the summer can't know what November will bring.

    Here is how the main cards compare with the season so far.

    Player

    Club

    Position

    FC 27 rating

    Premiership 2026/27 (apps / goals / assists)

    Nicolas Raskin

    Rangers

    CDM

    79

    10 / 1 / 0

    Alistair Johnston

    Celtic

    RB

    78

    3 / 0 / 0

    Lawrence Shankland

    Rangers

    ST

    77

    5 / 3 / 0

    Jota

    Celtic

    LW

    76

    5 / 0 / 1

    Cláudio Braga

    Hearts

    ST

    76

    12 / 6 / 2

    Benjamin Nygren

    Celtic

    CM

    75

    13 / 6 / 3

    Camilo Durán

    Celtic

    LW

    70

    13 / 7 / 6

    Josh McPake

    Hearts

    LM

    68

    11 / 3 / 6

    Ryan Naderi

    Rangers

    ST

    67

    11 / 6 / 3

    Ryan Strain

    Falkirk

    RB

    65

    12 / 0 / 5

    Jacob Murrell

    Falkirk

    ST

    57

    11 / 7 / 0

    Ratings: EA SPORTS FC 27 at launch. Stats: Scottish Premiership to 8 November (ESPN).

    The cards that flatter the season

    Lawrence Shankland (77). The problem isn't his finishing: three goals in five league games is the rate you'd expect from Rangers' captain. The problem is time on the pitch. He tore his hamstring in the 1-0 win over Motherwell at the start of September, and Derek McInnes said at the time that he'd be out for three to four months. In FC 27 he is still one of the best strikers in the league.

    Alistair Johnston (78). Johnston shares the highest rating at Celtic with Carter-Vickers, but he has made only three league appearances this season. Colby Donovan has played all 13 league games.

    Jota (76). Five league appearances, no goals and one assist. In the game he is one of the quickest and most direct wingers in the league. Durán, another left winger in the game, has played all 13 league games.

    Youssef Chermiti (74). Two league appearances and no goals so far. Rangers' goals have come from elsewhere: Ryan Naderi and Kevin Kelsy have ten between them.

    None of this changes how these cards play in Ultimate Team. A base card doesn't pick up injuries or lose its place, so the Shankland you open in FC 27 is the same 77 he was on release day. Building a Scottish side around Raskin, Shankland and the top Celtic cards takes a decent budget, and plenty of players pick up FC coins from specialist sites such as Futcoin instead of waiting weeks for Rivals and Champions rewards to add up.

    The players doing more than their rating

    Jacob Murrell (57). The most striking number in the league. Murrell has seven goals in 11 games, joint top of the scoring charts, and was named Premiership Player of the Month for October. In FC 27 his card is rated 57, one of the lowest in Falkirk's squad. Few players in Scotland are this far ahead of their card.

    Camilo Durán (70). Seven goals and six assists in 13 games. He is joint top scorer and joint top for assists, and he was Player of the Month in August. A 70-rated card is built for a squad player, and Durán has been the most productive attacker in the country.

    Josh McPake (68). Six assists and three goals in 11 games. No one in the league has more assists, yet nine Hearts players have higher-rated cards.

    Ryan Naderi (67). Six goals and three assists in 11 games make him Rangers' top scorer in the league. With Shankland injured, he has led the line, and his card is the lowest of any Rangers striker in the game's launch squad.

    Ryan Strain (65). Five assists from right-back, third-best in the league. Falkirk's run to third owes a lot to him and Murrell.

    Rangers centre-back Olwethu Makhanya deserves a mention too. He was Player of the Month in September, and his card is a 68.

    The fair ones

    Not every rating is off. Cláudio Braga (76) has six goals and two assists for Hearts and is their top-rated player in the game and one of their most important on the pitch. Benjamin Nygren (75) has played every league game for Celtic, with six goals and three assists. Nicolas Raskin (79) has played ten league games in Rangers' midfield. His numbers are modest, but goals and assists were never what made him the best-rated player at either Glasgow club.

    How FC 27 catches up with reality

    Base ratings barely move during the season. When a player is in form, EA reacts with special cards instead: Team of the Week items for standout performances and cards built around promo campaigns. Murrell, Durán and McPake are the obvious candidates from Scotland if their form holds.

    There is a chance to prove it soon. Rangers host Falkirk at Ibrox on 28 November, and a performance in a game like that is exactly what in-form cards are made from.

    What it means for your squad

    If you are building a Scottish Premiership team in FC 27, the gaps above suggest two simple approaches.

    • Don't judge a card by the injury list. Shankland, Johnston and Jota are just as effective in the game as they were in September. If you already own them, there is no reason to sell.

    • Keep an eye on in-form cards. Players like Murrell, McPake and Naderi are cheap as base cards and could get special versions if they keep this up. Those cards are only available for a limited time.

    The split is still months away, and the next few weeks will show whether EA's summer ratings were too generous to the Old Firm or simply early. Either way, FC 28 will have plenty of Falkirk evidence to work with.