St Mirren ⚫️⚪️ v Celtic 🟢⚪️ 05/03/23 1200 hours

[Drew Brees]

1 minute ago, Squonk said:

You implied that any exceptions whatsoever disprove a theory and invalidate an entire argument.......except when that doesn't suit the narrative you're promoting.

Not promoting anything, just pointing out that suggesting VAR benefitted Celtic yesterday over St Mirren is pretty dumb considering the VAR decisions in the game. 

[Jinky67]

1 hour ago, Bobby_F said:

Yeah, both correct decisions.

Or are you suggesting that they were wrong to do that?

And are you suggesting that the Celtic player didn't score with his arm for the second?

If that had been the case VAR would have ruled it out, it overturned the other decisions so absolutely zero reason to suggest it wouldn’t overturn that one other than the one you wish to tell yourself.

So aye not a lot to see here other than your defender not being strong enough

 

[Jinky67]

47 minutes ago, kennie makevin said:

Either, as Mr Postegoclu says on an almost weekly basis, VAR in Scotland is operated in such a way as to be institutionally, deliberately and regularly biased against Celtic, which is disgraceful and tawdry at best, racist at worst. Or, Mr Postegoclu makes these claims in order to put pressure on officials to try and ensure that any 50-50 calls alway go Celtic's way which is also disgraceful and tawdry. Either way it stinks. 

 

Hi Kennie, surprised to see you here 

Edited March 6, 2023 by Jinky67

[Drew Brees]

16 minutes ago, Jinky67 said:

Hi Kennie, surprised to see you here 

He only posts about Celtic, weird behaviour. 

[Jinky67]

17 minutes ago, Drew Brees said:

He only posts about Celtic, weird behaviour. 

Weirder still he thinks Ange commenting on VAR is racially motivated

 

[buddie06smfc]

Jota diving is the real issue, unfortunately as it’s not in the box the weak referee can be conned without any repercussions. I note the hard done by Postecoglou isn’t quick in highlighting that, I’m sure he would be if a Jota dive leads to a penalty award being overturned through VAR. 

[Drew Brees]

Anyone mentioned songs yet? 

[Arch Stanton]

1 minute ago, Drew Brees said:

Anyone mentioned songs yet? 

Potato!

[S7C]

1 minute ago, Drew Brees said:

Anyone mentioned songs yet? 

Don’t think so. Just more painful hypocrisy.

[kennie makevin]

1 hour ago, Drew Brees said:

He only posts about Celtic, weird behaviour. 

Celtic are the centre of the universe, weren't you told ?

[kennie makevin]

58 minutes ago, Jinky67 said:

Weirder still he thinks Ange commenting on VAR is racially motivated

 

Even weirder that you think that's what I said.   Read it again and read it correctly this time.

[Dons_1988]

I think Ange has reached the point that being at Celtic has infiltrated his brain. 

It seems to happen to all old firm affiliates, the sane ones tend to get out before it takes hold. 

[kennie makevin]

1 hour ago, Jinky67 said:

Hi Kennie, surprised to see you here 

Ah the meme or Gif, or whatever it's called.  Friend of those who struggle with cogent arguments using the written word.

[Jinky67]

2 hours ago, kennie makevin said:

Ah the meme or Gif, or whatever it's called.  Friend of those who struggle with cogent arguments using the written word.

It would help if you were capable of a cogent argument preferably written in some sort of coherent syntax.

I’d be less inclined to mock you with said gifs if you were however much can be said with such a simple gif. They can be wonderfully effective 

Edited March 6, 2023 by Jinky67

[Bobby_F]

4 hours ago, Jinky67 said:

If that had been the case VAR would have ruled it out, it overturned the other decisions so absolutely zero reason to suggest it wouldn’t overturn that one other than the one you wish to tell yourself.

So aye not a lot to see here other than your defender not being strong enough

 

Watch it again.  One of the arms the Celtic player uses to push O'Hara also happens to stick the ball into the net.

VAR - rightly - awarded Saints a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a freekick rather than a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a penalty after ref gave St Mirren benefit of the doubt.

VAR - wrongly - let Celtic's second goal stand when it should have been chopped off for a foul and/or knocking the ball in to the net with his arm.

Only wrong decision benefitted Celtic.

Edited March 6, 2023 by Bobby_F

[bennett]

4 minutes ago, Bobby_F said:

Watch it again.  One of the arms the Celtic player uses to push O'Hara also happens to stick the ball into the net.

VAR - rightly - awarded Saints a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a freekick rather than a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a penalty after ref gave St Mirren benefit of the doubt.

VAR - wrongly - let Celtic's second goal stand when it should have been chopped off for a foul and/or knocking the ball in to the net with his arm.

Only wrong decision benefitted Celtic.

 

Jinky will be diving into his gif folder right now...

[Henrik's tongue]

For what it’s worth I think Johnston’s goal could easily have been disallowed and probably should have been. Having said that I also think the foul on Kyogo could easily have been given as a pen.

[Jinky67]

34 minutes ago, Bobby_F said:

Watch it again.  One of the arms the Celtic player uses to push O'Hara also happens to stick the ball into the net.

VAR - rightly - awarded Saints a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a freekick rather than a penalty after ref gave Celtic benefit of the doubt.

VAR - rightly - awarded Celtic a penalty after ref gave St Mirren benefit of the doubt.

VAR - wrongly - let Celtic's second goal stand when it should have been chopped off for a foul and/or knocking the ball in to the net with his arm.

Only wrong decision benefitted Celtic.

Again I can’t see it hit his arm but I can see Kyogos foot on the 18 yard line with Dunne still making contact with him

 

Edited March 6, 2023 by Jinky67

[Jinky67]

28 minutes ago, bennett said:

 

Jinky will be diving into his gif folder right now...

Not really a conversation you should be diving into after Collums performance at the weekend

[Lex]

2 minutes ago, Jinky67 said:

Again I can’t see it hit his arm but I can see Kyogos foot on the 18 yard line with Dunne still making contact with him

 

Are you being serious here? The position of Kyogo's foot is not relevant. What is relevant is the contact by Dunne, which is quite clearly outside the box. This is fairly basic rules of the game