Jump to content

Birth rates / Fertility


Recommended Posts

17 minutes ago, Left Back said:

Once they’ve left home it’s even better.  You have your freedom back as @ICTChris indicates you lose to a certain extent, but generally you have more disposable income than you had before they came along.  We were quite young when our son fucked off to uni (I was 41 I think) and has stayed down south since.

My mother was a hell of an emotional when I first left for college as I was moving quite far away and it was first time she had none of her children staying in the house. I can imagine myself being the same when my kids finally move out and there would be a massive void in my life.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Alert Mongoose said:

My point was more around if more and more people decide that children are too much hassle, then I fear they may get a shock years down the line when their is little support in their older age.

Well no, a Western economy with a temperature climate is not going to suffer from a lack of people in the rest of this century. There are thousands of mostly young and enterprising people risking their lives to get here on a monthly basis just to enjoy a better life.

We do not need to regurgitate nativist nonsense from the 1930s - we need a rational immigration policy. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, virginton said:

Well no, a Western economy with a temperature climate is not going to suffer from a lack of people in the rest of this century. There are thousands of mostly young and enterprising people risking their lives to get here on a monthly basis just to enjoy a better life.

We do not need to regurgitate nativist nonsense from the 1930s - we need a rational immigration policy. 

Immigration is the fall back certainly. Does it look to you like the Westminster government are keen on that?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NB: Childless single households and couples already subsidise childraising within society by paying more than their fair share for use of communal services through the council tax, by funding comprehensive systems of childcare and education, as well as through tax credits and other reductions. So the premise of the OP is nonsense anyway. 

Edited by vikingTON
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Left Back said:

Isn’t that normal though?  You realise through experience they aren’t made of glass and they get more freedom as a result.

Yeah, I'm probably bit hard on my kids as I have expectations, boundaries and standards, I'm their parent not their pal (prob why my teenager fucked off to his dad's) but she's the one thats most work.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Alert Mongoose said:

Immigration is the fall back certainly. Does it look to you like the Westminster government are keen on that?

We can vote for a different governing party and (in theory) to end Westminster rule as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, The Moonster said:

Have you had pressure from your family or society to have kids? 

I wouldn't say I encountered anything I'd call 'pressure', but certainly there was an unspoken expectation, and incredulity that it didn't happen or when I told these people it wasn't going to.

I was together with my Ex for over a decade before we actually got married. As soon as we came back from honeymoon the bullshit started. It basically ended when I'd finally had enough and told her old man to mind his own fucking business and stop with the sly digs and constantly havering on about all their own pals' grandkids.

The most ridiculous was when we met an old friend on a night out a couple of years after we got hitched. Most of our friends were having their first or second at this point, and she deliberately waited until my mrs had gone to the loo then accosted me with a 'you know you can get help if it's not happening for you?'. I was completely nonplussed to begin with, and then I realised what she was getting at. I'll never forget the look on her face and her total inability to process my response to her that far from 'not happening', we simply weren't trying because neither of us had the blindest bit of interest in being parents. It simply doesn't enter the heads of some folk that other people either do not want, or in my case, can't fucking stand children.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Alert Mongoose said:

I think most of us have regrets about lots of things but I'm not sure it would apply here.  Sometimes it just makes you think the grass is even greener when the reality is almost always different.

I think it's important to remember that some children are much easier to bring up than others.  My wife and I had about 6 attempts at IVF before giving up and going down the adoption route. We therefore had an idea that any child is more likely to need additional support from us as parents.  I'm sure there are others in a more unfortunate situation than us buts it's been a tough few years. 

Important to note that if I had the choice in hindsight I would still make the same decision. They can bring moments of sheer joy which will always overcome they days when you are tearing your hair out.

My point was more around if more and more people decide that children are too much hassle, then I fear they may get a shock years down the line when their is little support in their older age.

I don’t want support from my children in my old age. I will organise my life and affairs to make sure it is not required. 

Too often I have seen parents feeling that their adult children “owe” them in some way. My children owe me nothing and never will. It was not their choice to come into the world, it was mine and my wife’s.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Thorongil said:

I don’t want support from my children in my old age. I will organise my life and affairs to make sure it is not required. 

Too often I have seen parents feeling that their adult children “owe” them in some way. My children owe me nothing and never will. It was not their choice to come into the world, it was mine and my wife’s.

This is why I have absolutely no guilt whatsoever about my decision to cut all contact with and have nothing to do with my mother. The things that have happened to get to this stage are not particularly relevant to this thread, but the fact is I don't in any way 'owe' her contact. My parents chose to have children, that decision was nothing to do with me. Am I supposed to feel a debt of gratitude purely because they did the absolute bare minimum to parent the children they chose to have?

To be honest, she could be dead for all I know. I couldn't care less, just like I couldn't care less about what care needs she might have, how that's paid for, or what it might mean for her estate. That's her lookout. I view the fact I'm related to her as nothing more than accident of birth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Boo Khaki said:

This is why I have absolutely no guilt whatsoever about my decision to cut all contact with and have nothing to do with my mother. The things that have happened to get to this stage are not particularly relevant to this thread, but the fact is I don't in any way 'owe' her contact. My parents chose to have children, that decision was nothing to do with me. Am I supposed to feel a debt of gratitude purely because they did the absolute bare minimum to parent the children they chose to have?

To be honest, she could be dead for all I know. I couldn't care less, just like I couldn't care less about what care needs she might have, how that's paid for, or what it might mean for her estate. That's her lookout. I view the fact I'm related to her as nothing more than accident of birth.

Have had similar experiences, not fun. But yes, you are right in your approach, no question.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Theroadlesstravelled said:

Why would you purposely plan to be a burden on your kids when you’re old?

It sounds like you’re bitter about having them and expect some repayment.

I don't think he personally is in this case but perhaps using it for the sake of example

Something very relevant to this thread however is that, in the pre -  welfare state days ( and still today in much of the developing world) people absolutely relied on family for anything they couldn't manage themselves. including care of sick or elderly parents & grandparents. There was simply no such thing as shipping auld granny off to the home or personal independence plans for those unable to work. people did and in some cases still do have children in order to give the family a lifeline. My parents are in their mid 60s and they both knew of school friends who were smart enough to progress in education but their folks wanted them out of the school to work and contribute money to the house. 

There is basically none of that anymore in first world countries 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think he personally is in this case but perhaps using it for the sake of example
Something very relevant to this thread however is that, in the pre -  welfare state days ( and still today in much of the developing world) people absolutely relied on family for anything they couldn't manage themselves. including care of sick or elderly parents & grandparents. There was simply no such thing as shipping auld granny off to the home or personal independence plans for those unable to work. people did and in some cases still do have children in order to give the family a lifeline. My parents are in their mid 60s and they both knew of school friends who were smart enough to progress in education but their folks wanted them out of the school to work and contribute money to the house. 
There is basically none of that anymore in first world countries 


A lot of people still rely on relatives for care - I have several friends and relatives who are carers, some full time, for parents or other family members.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Monkey Tennis said:

Some weirdly dogmatic posturing on this thread.

But unsurprising, considering who it's coming from.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, ICTChris said:

 


A lot of people still rely on relatives for care - I have several friends and relatives who are carers, some full time, for parents or other family members.

 

Yeah, my partner is basically an unpaid carer for her parents. They already get help from the LA, but it's insufficient to cater for all their needs, so mrs is up there 2-3 times a week picking up the shortfall. She hardly had a fantastic relationship with them either earlier in her life, but nothing like as toxic as my own parents, so I can understand why she does it even if she's not shy in admitting how difficult she finds it and is quite frank about how much it takes out of her.

To be honest, I think she does it because her parents are not equally as dependent as each other, and if she didn't bother the burden of looking after the most vulnerable one would fall entirely on the one she is actually really fond of, so she's caring for a parent that she genuinely isn't very fond of out of love for the one she is. It's a frustrating situation because she doesn't keep in the best of health herself, and she's working full time to support herself to boot. 

I know her parents didn't decide to procreate just for the sake of having someone to look after them in old age, but I have an enormous degree of admiration for her for doing it, because I certainly wouldn't have for mine. That's perhaps more a reflection on my parents own failings as anything else though, because I'm in no way deficient in compassion or unwilling to help other people that I do actually believe deserve it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...