Celtic's Next Permanent Manager

[velo army]

Not that I want Clarke to leave the Scotland job, but I think it's possible that he isn't wedded to a particular type of football, rather that he had his teams playing the football that got the most out of the teams he managed.

[RandomGuy.]

48 minutes ago, Jinky67 said:

Chased out is a bit harsh, i dont doubt he would get us organised however it certainly would be a brand of football that wouldn't excite anyone. 

For me it has to be someone with a clear idea of how they want to play football. That are some cracking coaches out there who play really exciting football that we could go after and break away from our usual mo of either scottish/irish ex player or someone Celtic minded.

Naglesmann and Rose are the standouts and beyond us for sure, Howe and Marco Silva could both also do a good job i reckon. De Zerbi i really like. Of those realistically Eddie Howe would be the more likely. 

 

Yes, turn your nose up at a manager who had West Brom 7th in the EPL and battering 5 past Sir Alex's Man U side, but accept a manager who got Bournemouth relegated and who's pointless style of play completely stunted all attacking threat and who wasted incredible playmakers like Brooks, presumably because one is old and one is young.

Clarke adapts to what he's got and makes the most of it. He'd set Celtic up to allow their best players attacking freedom. Howe would you have you spending 90 minutes passing the ball about your own half and hoping you can create something from nothing. 

I'd know who I'd prefer.

[gannonball]

It wont be Clarke or Martinez. If its Malky Mackay I think a heads gone thread will be kicked off again in my honour. 

[Leith Green]

13 minutes ago, gannonball said:

It wont be Clarke or Martinez

Agree 100%.

Clarke is not that daft, and even if Martinez is tempted, I am sure Maloney will tell him to back away from it sharpish.

[G51]

Mark Guidi coming out with some interesting stuff on Superscoreboard.

Saying that Lambert and Malky Mackay were finalists when Rodgers was hired, and Michael O'Neill is thought of very highly among some on the Celtic board.

Sounds as if the board will be making the appointment.

[D Angelo Barksdale]

Roy Keane for me Clive.

'Big name' and Celtic minded.

Whether he'd be a good choice is another question.

[Jinky67]

44 minutes ago, RandomGuy. said:

Yes, turn your nose up at a manager who had West Brom 7th in the EPL and battering 5 past Sir Alex's Man U side, but accept a manager who got Bournemouth relegated and who's pointless style of play completely stunted all attacking threat and who wasted incredible playmakers like Brooks, presumably because one is old and one is young.

Clarke adapts to what he's got and makes the most of it. He'd set Celtic up to allow their best players attacking freedom. Howe would you have you spending 90 minutes passing the ball about your own half and hoping you can create something from nothing. 

I'd know who I'd prefer.

This the same Steve Clarke that was sacked by West Brom the very next season leaving them just above the relegation zone to take a job at Reading only to be sacked after a year? That Steve Clarke?

And yet you turn your nose up at a coach who took a team from the 4th tier of English football into the Premier League and kept them there for 5 seasons?

I do know who i'd prefer and its not Clarke, Howe isnt my 1st choice either but if given the choice of just those 2 i am taking Howe

 

Edited February 24, 2021 by Jinky67

[Newbornbairn]

[ConcernedReferee]

Frank Lampard would be great, Roy Keane similarly, anything else is a disappointment now I've considered those 

[HTG]

1 hour ago, velo army said:

Not that I want Clarke to leave the Scotland job, but I think it's possible that he isn't wedded to a particular type of football, rather that he had his teams playing the football that got the most out of the teams he managed.

Clarke won't go anywhere until after the Euros. If he's the choice they'll give Kennedy the job to the end of the season. Ferguson has done a decent job at Kelty ...

[yoda]

1 hour ago, Jinky67 said:

Naglesmann and Rose are the standouts and beyond us for sure

 

 @ the thought that somewhere, be it on Twitter or a Celtic forum, that someone suggested these names as plausible candidates.

 

[RandomGuy.]

Scenes when Scott Brown is announced, with Neil Lennon as DOF.

[true fan]

Wouldn’t roy Keane just bully people, fall out, then leave? Sensational player but poor record as a manager.

[Lofarl]

6 minutes ago, true fan said:

Wouldn’t roy Keane just bully people, fall out, then leave? Sensational player but poor record as a manager.

I'm all for some of that.  

[lithgierose]

22 minutes ago, HTG said:

Clarke won't go anywhere until after the Euros. If he's the choice they'll give Kennedy the job to the end of the season. Ferguson has done a decent job at Kelty ...

 

[Ira Gaines]

Roy Keane would be hilarious in numerous ways. I'd very much want to see that. 

[Crawford]

15 minutes ago, RandomGuy. said:

Scenes when Scott Brown is announced, with Neil Lennon as DOF.

Scenes when it's Arlene Foster.

[Miguel Sanchez]

46 minutes ago, true fan said:

Wouldn’t roy Keane just bully people, fall out, then leave? Sensational player but poor record as a manager.

We can only hope.

[Flybhoy]

36 minutes ago, Crawford said:

Scenes when it's Arlene Foster.

Can't see it being Arlene Foster truth be told. 

[Jinky67]

1 hour ago, yoda said:

 @ the thought that somewhere, be it on Twitter or a Celtic forum, that someone suggested these names as plausible candidates.

 

I wanted us to go for Rose when he was at Salzburg as replacement tor Rodgers.

Hes way beyond our reach now