Keep/Punt/Undecided

[Pull My Strings]

1 hour ago, yoda said:

I didn't realise Safranko was on-loan at United. Hopefully Uncle Roy's millions can lure him to Dingwall (and Premiership football) over the summer. He'd be useful back-up to Billy Mckay.

Pffft.

[CaleyStan]

I'd like to think we'd be trying to upgrade on McKay, Trafford, White  and Rooney, even on a reduced budget. No idea what kind of contracts they're on. 

As others have said, we can judge McCauley after the summer but so far it looks like he's a complete dud.

I'd like to keep the rest - Ridgers, McCart, Donaldson, Chalmers, Welsh and Walsh have all been decent signings. 

[NEFarab]

42 minutes ago, TheScarf said:

Fucking mental.  How long is his contract?  We've been trying to get rid of him for years.

f**k me I thought you had gotten rid of him years ago haha.

[TheScarf]

He's on the bench tonight, 

[Bairney The Dinosaur]

 

Fasan- Punt

Burgoyne- Keep

Mitchell- Punt

McGhee- Undecided

Edge- Undecided

McKenna- Keep

Dixon- Undecided

Robson- Keep

Brough- Punt

Paton- Punt

Osman- Undecided

Petra- Undecided

McShane-Keep

McLean- Undecided

Rudden- Keep

Jarvis- Undecided

Lavery- Undecided

Todorov- Undecided

Waddington- Undecided

Keillor-Dunn- Keep

Kidd- Punt

O’Hara- Punt

McKee- Punt

 

I’m pretty undecided.

 

[dundeeunited83]

1. Benji - punt, absolutely bang average, gets smaller when he jumps
2. Murdoch- punt, goodbye
3. Booth- punt, average can be easily upgraded
4. Frans- keep, decent enough, interested to see him partner Reynolds
5. Barton- punt, honking stinking attitude, awful
6. Toshney- punt the injury man
7. Mcmullan- keep, dangerous, gets the crossing sorted he’ll be a gem
8. Fyvie- keep, get a good preseason and pray he gets back to his best
9. Sow- keep, showed flashes on Friday night, get him fit, before end of season we go up
10. Clark- keep, poacher
11. King - PUNT
12. Stanton- punt, not up to the challenge
13. Gomis- punt, love u Jimmy
14. Safranko- KEEP, work rate, aggression, passion, must keep the Slovakian international
15. Nesbitt- punt lightweight
16. Matty smith- punt on loan
17. Robson- keep, changed my mind on him last few months, improved
18. Butcher- keep, hard c**t, one of the first names on team sheet
19. Bouhenna- punt, decent enough, decent on ball, not great defender
20. Rabitsch- punt, worst player I’ve ever seen
22. Wardrop- keep, bad injury, think there’s a player there
23. Scobbie-punt, fear
24. Edge- punt see above
25. Cammy smith-keep, good player
30. Reynolds- keep, captain next season
34. Laidlaw-punt if u can replace benji in goal, you must be honking
44. Watson-punt, decent championship player, will no doubt score winner against us never season if he leaves
47. Harkes-keep, bags of potential
49. Seaman-punt, got our man smith, no need for him
50. Pawlett- drifts in and out games, but MASSIVE player for us, when he turns it on, he turns it on, see Dunfermline goal
55. Connolly-keep, battler, fighter, would header a rock

[Rovers1992/1993]

If we stay up
Keep: Chris Millar
Punt: The rest
If we go down
Keep: Chris Millar, Jim McAlister, Gregor Buchanan (he'd be fine in League 1), Reghan Tumilty, Bob McHugh
Punt: The rest

Punt McKeown our way if he’s out of contract. Would be much appreciated! [emoji1360]

[yoda]

4 hours ago, NEFarab said:

I’ve seen some shit posts on here but I think this tops the lot. 

Yes, but enough about your posts.

[D.A.F.C]

 

Dundee United training session.

[DA Baracus]

4 hours ago, Highland Capital said:

I’ve heard OFW is on £1,700 a week with a £700 appearance fee on top.

You can put any old shit online and folk will believe it, as seen by replies.

Where did you hear this?

[BottiBiabi]

 
Dixon- Undecided
 

What? He’s one of the first names on the team sheet regardless what league we’re in next season.

[D.A.F.C]

15 minutes ago, DA Baracus said:

You can put any old shit online and folk will believe it, as seen by replies.

Where did you hear this?

In the macdonalds in Livvy.

[itzdrk]

Ross Doohan - If allowed- KEEP. 

Ellis Hare-Reid - KEEP. 

David Ferguson - Under contract - KEEP. 

Daniel Harvie - Under contract - KEEP. 

Finn Ecrepont - Under contract - KEEP. 

Aaron Muirhead - Under contract - KEEP. 

Jamie Adams - KEEP. 

Stevie Bell - PUNT. 

Michael Rose - Leaving - PUNT. 

Liam Smith - Leaving - PUNT. 

Andy Murdoch - Under contract - KEEP. 

Ross Docherty - Under contract - KEEP.

Mark Kerr - PUNT.

Robbie Crawford - KEEP.

Andy Geggan - PUNT.

Declan McDaid - KEEP.

Nicky Cadden - Undecided.

Alan Forrest - KEEP.

Craig McGuffie - Under contract - KEEP. 

Michael Moffat - KEEP. 

Lawrence Shankland - PUNT. 

Craig Moore - PUNT.

Calvin Miller - If allowed- KEEP. 

Edited April 16, 2019 by itzdrk

[sophia]

5 hours ago, Granny Danger said:

 

Spot on.  

AlsoI’m not sure how many millions it would take to lure a rational person to Dingwall.

There are many that are now moribund in Milnafua that moved for modest amounts.

I can't think why anyone would want to join them.

 

[FBadgers]

Pars

Goalies

Scully - Keep, pretty dependable goalkeeper

Murdoch/Robinson/Gill- Would give Murdoch maybe a 6 month contract if he can be fit. Gill will likely stay. and I guess Robinson will leave. No strong urge to keep/let go for any of these. Def keep Murdoch if can get fit

 

Defenders/Full Backs

 

J Longridge - Keep - Pretty consistant good performer.

Ashcroft - Keep - Poor season, but has had two good ones before. With the right partner alongside perhaps he will come good.

Devine - Release (though contracted) Not very good is he. Too easily outmuscled and with Ashcroft struggling wasn't capable of leading the defence.

Durnan - Release - To be fair ive barely seen him play and some people state he did have a good spell. But never rated him and from what I have seen poorer than last seasons defenders

Martin - Keep - Not played all season due to injury, and was excellent final third of last season. No blame on him for this season at all. Think deserves another year. Also very versatile which is useful to have.

Williamson - Keep (Just) - This is controversial, and many will disagree. He's been poor. Very much a confidence player and when he  has none, he needs protected. On form, he was starting to show he could be very useful going forward, even getting some assists and first career goal at end of last season. Im a fan, though patience tested this season. Hope for one last year which he makes most of.

 

Midfield

Beadling - Keep - Very effective player, feel more to come from him. He has been poor at times

Thomson - Keep, has great drive and energy, only player with any of that this season. Can improve I think to

Craigen - Keep - Versatile and dependable

Blair -Keep - Only decent set piece taker

However, with Todd getting game time, I cant help but feel that keeping all 4 of the above will be a bad move. Afterall it means adding no new personnel to centre mid. Not many goals from centre mid in there. If I had to pick one to go, probably Blair. Bring in a player who  is likely to add goals from midfield.if possible

Vincent - Release - Been poor player for us, never really seen what he offers or seen him have a good game

Connolly - Release - Poor Cardle/Aird replacement.  Don't rate and doubt he will be retained anyway

Higginbotham - Release - Had 1 good game in 10 or so in previous seasons, and none this year.  Kinda fed up with him

L Longridge - Release - Started not too badly, but find him pretty frustrating.  Don't no best position.

 

Striker

Fais - Release - I realise of course he and some others are on loan. Not got the goals and seems his level is League 1

Hippolyte - Release (contracted) - Terrible

Anderson - Keep - Young and some games pass him by, but a good striker with great potential, cant see him coming back though.

Ryan  - Keep (Just) Controversial this one, not had a chance with Crawford yet.  Goalscoring record ain't great this year pre injury and that miss will always be with him. But cant see us getting rid of all strikers, and if one has to be kept on, id say its him. Did ok last year

Muirhead - release - Perhaps worst player of the season. Nothing positive can be said.

Smith -Release - with regret - just never built on his form on start of last season

 

 

 

 

[bridge of allan bairn]

using bairneys template on my phone...undecideds mostly depends on what we could or couldn't get in instead
 
Fasan- Punt
Burgoyne- Keep
Mitchell- Punt
McGhee- keep
Edge- Undecided
McKenna- Keep
Dixon- keep
Robson- Keep
Brough- Punt
Paton- undecided
Osman- Undecided
Petra- Undecided
McShane-Keep
McLean- punt
Rudden- Keep
Jarvis- Undecided
Lavery- Undecided
Todorov- Undecided
Waddington- Undecided
Keillor-Dunn- Keep
Kidd- Punt
O’Hara- Punt
McKee- Punt
 

[DAFC.]

37 minutes ago, FBadgers said:

Ryan  - Keep (Just) Controversial this one, not had a chance with Crawford yet.  Goalscoring record ain't great this year pre injury and that miss will always be with him. But cant see us getting rid of all strikers, and if one has to be kept on, id say its him. Did ok last year

Seriously?  League 1 is his level. The games pass him by without a hint of being effective in any way. 

[NEFarab]

16 hours ago, dundeeunited83 said:

1. Benji - punt, absolutely bang average, gets smaller when he jumps
2. Murdoch- punt, goodbye
3. Booth- punt, average can be easily upgraded
4. Frans- keep, decent enough, interested to see him partner Reynolds
5. Barton- punt, honking stinking attitude, awful
6. Toshney- punt the injury man
7. Mcmullan- keep, dangerous, gets the crossing sorted he’ll be a gem
8. Fyvie- keep, get a good preseason and pray he gets back to his best
9. Sow- keep, showed flashes on Friday night, get him fit, before end of season we go up
10. Clark- keep, poacher
11. King - PUNT
12. Stanton- punt, not up to the challenge
13. Gomis- punt, love u Jimmy
14. Safranko- KEEP, work rate, aggression, passion, must keep the Slovakian international
15. Nesbitt- punt lightweight
16. Matty smith- punt on loan
17. Robson- keep, changed my mind on him last few months, improved
18. Butcher- keep, hard c**t, one of the first names on team sheet
19. Bouhenna- punt, decent enough, decent on ball, not great defender
20. Rabitsch- punt, worst player I’ve ever seen
22. Wardrop- keep, bad injury, think there’s a player there
23. Scobbie-punt, fear
24. Edge- punt see above
25. Cammy smith-keep, good player
30. Reynolds- keep, captain next season
34. Laidlaw-punt if u can replace benji in goal, you must be honking
44. Watson-punt, decent championship player, will no doubt score winner against us never season if he leaves
47. Harkes-keep, bags of potential
49. Seaman-punt, got our man smith, no need for him
50. Pawlett- drifts in and out games, but MASSIVE player for us, when he turns it on, he turns it on, see Dunfermline goal
55. Connolly-keep, battler, fighter, would header a rock

I’d punt Frans, the rest I agree with. 

[Highland Capital]

19 hours ago, Central Belt Caley said:

That is crazy money for a guy who was fairly susceptible to a blunder or two

Would love to know the money that Boden, Mulraney etc were on 

Not sure about Mulraney other than his wages would've doubled had he stayed but Boden was apparently on £2,000 a week.

[PB1994]

Not sure about Mulraney other than his wages would've doubled had he stayed but Boden was apparently on £2,000 a week.

I believe Mulraney was on £700 a week which was due to become £1400 last summer, hence why we were so desperate to get rid.