Keep/Punt/Undecided

[HoBNob]

45 minutes ago, DAFC. said:

Punt everyone except Joe Thomson, Tom Beadling, Jackson Longridge and Ryan Scully.

Get this season so far in to the sea. 

Add in Beadling for me and that's it. Argument to be made for Ashcroft, having Devine next to you would be mentally exhausting. 

[DAFC.]

13 minutes ago, Grant228 said:

Add in Beadling for me and that's it. Argument to be made for Ashcroft, having Devine next to you would be mentally exhausting. 

I included Beadling.

[D.A.F.C]

Is that fans of Danny Devine’s new team wanting him punted immediately?

Who could have possibly seen that coming...

Everyone except AJ

[Reid]

Keep: Sneddon, Saunders, Elliott, Penrice, Spittal, Slater, Bannigan, McDonald, Cardle, Fitzpatrick, O’Ware

 

Undecided: Hazard, Anderson, Doolan, Gordon, McGinty, Wilson

 

Punt: Lennox, Harkins, McCarthy, McMillan, Roy, Coulibaly, Mansell, Storey

 

[smpar]

51 minutes ago, Grant228 said:

Add in Beadling for me and that's it. Argument to be made for Ashcroft, having Devine next to you would be mentally exhausting. 

Aye I'd keep Ashcroft as well. Agree with DAFC.'s list. The young boys McCann and Todd might be worth golding on to, their wages won't be costing the club much at all so no harm in keeping them as backup. 

[smpar]

1 minute ago, Reid said:

Keep: Sneddon, Saunders, Elliott, Penrice, Spittal, Slater, Bannigan, McDonald, Cardle, Fitzpatrick, O’Ware

 

Undecided: Hazard, Anderson, Doolan, Gordon, McGinty, Wilson

 

Punt: Lennox, Harkins, McCarthy, McMillan, Roy, Coulibaly, Mansell, Storey

 

A Championship club is going to sign Storey in the summer and I'm really fucking scared it's going to be us. 

[MrDust]

Fasan- Punt
Burgoyne- Keep
Mitchell- Keep (Backup)
McGhee- Keep
Edge- Undecided
McKenna- Keep
Dixon- Keep
Robson- Keep (backup)
Brough- Punt
Paton- Punt
Osman- Keep
Petra- Keep
McShane-Keep
McLean- Punt
Rudden- Keep
Jarvis- Punt
Lavery- Punt
Todorov- Keep
Waddington- Undecided
Keillor-Dunn- Keep
Kidd- Punt
O’Hara- Punt
McKee- Punt

[Rob1885]

Wonder which falkirk cast offs we'll end up with.

[gav-ffc]

6 minutes ago, Rob1885 said:

Wonder which falkirk cast offs we'll end up with.

Lewis Kidd imo.

[Bairnardo]

Lewis Kidd imo.

He suits their MO perfectly

[Senor Bairn]

McKee to Dunfermline sounds realistic imo

[Bairnardo]

McKee to Dunfermline sounds realistic imo

Yeah him and Kidd.... It just sounds right. Destined almost.

Craigen and McKee together again....

[Marshmallo]

5 minutes ago, Bairnardo said:

Yeah him and Kidd.... It just sounds right. Destined almost.

Craigen and McKee together again....

You were advocating for all three over a number of years.

[Bairnardo]

You were advocating for all three over a number of years.

At various points, all three had put in a half decent effort. Advocating is a bit simplistic tho.

The only time I ever went over the top for any of the three was my disatrous POTY prediction for McKee.

Doesnt change the fact that I have since called Craigen and McKee shitebags on numerous occassions tho does it?

Kidd isnt a shitebag but I can readily acknowledge he isnt good enough

[jagfox]

I'll be genuinely upset when Miles Storey signs a three year deal with St Johnstone.

[NEFarab]

(1) Siegrist - PUNT

(2) Murdoch* - PUNT

(3) Booth - UNDECIDED 

(4) Frans - PUNT

(5) Barton** - PUNT 

(6)  Toshney*** - PUNT

(7) McMullan - KEEP

(8) Fyvie - PUNT

(9) Sow - KEEP

(10) Clark - KEEP

(11) King**** - PUNT 

(12) Stanton - PUNT

(13) Gomis - PUNT 

(14) Safranko (Loan) - KEEP KEEP KEEP 

(15) Nesbitt - PUNT

(16) M. Smith - UNDECIDED 

(17) Robson - KEEP

(18) Butcher - KEEP

(19) Bouhenna - KEEP

(20) Rabitsch - PUNT 

(22) Wardrop - UNDECIDED 

(23) Scobbie*** - PUNT 

(24) Edjenguele***** - PUNT

(25) C. Smith - KEEP

(30) Reynolds - KEEP (+ Captaincy) 

(33) Aird****** - PUNT 

(34) Laidlaw (Loan) - UNDECIDED 

(44) Watson - PUNT 

(47) Harkes - KEEP

(49) Seaman (Loan) - KEEP

(50) Pawlett - KEEP

(55) Connolly - KEEP

(90) Loemba - PUNT 

* On Loan at East Fife

** On Loan at Connah’s Quay Nomads

*** On Loan at Brechin City 

**** On Loan at Gillingham 

***** On Loan at Falkirk 

****** On Loan at Queen of the South 

 

 

 

[Poet of the Macabre]

I'd still have him on the keep list but Jackson Longridge has dipped a lot since the start of the season. Thomson (although he's crocked) Beadling, Craigen, Scully, Todd, McCann and Murdoch would also be shouts.

Kinda breaks my heart that Williamson isn't an automatic 'Keep' tbh. His career has stalled badly after that big injury.

[Poet of the Macabre]

2 hours ago, DAFC. said:

If Fanny Devine and Myles Offside can be moved on, that will genuinely be the happiest day of my life.

Love it.

[ayrmad]

5 hours ago, ayrunitedfw said:

Stolen from the premiership forum. With the season drawing to a close its time to start discussing who from your squad you’d Keep, Punt or in some cases fire into the sea and who your undecided on. 

For Ayr

Goalkeepers:

Ross Doohan- KEEP

Ellis Hare-Reid-  KEEP

Defenders:

Daniel Harvie-  KEEP

Liam Smith- PUNT

Michael Rose- PUNT

Andy Geggan- . PUNT

Stevie Bell- PUNT

Jamie Adams-  PUNT

Aaron Muirhead-KEEP

David Ferguson- Keep

Chris Higgins-PUNT

Midfielders:

Mark Kerr-  PUNT

Ross Docherty- PUNT

Declan McDaid- KEEP

Alan Forrest-  Keep

Robbie Crawford-  PUNT

Nicky Cadden- PUNT

Calvin Miller- PUNT

Craig McGuffie-PUNT

Andy Murdoch-Keep

Strikers: 

Lawrence Shankland-Punt

Craig Moore-PUNT

Michael Moffat- Keep

 

 

[Bairney The Dinosaur]

You were advocating for all three over a number of years.

At various points, all three had put in a half decent effort. Advocating is a bit simplistic tho.

The only time I ever went over the top for any of the three was my disatrous POTY prediction for McKee.

Doesnt change the fact that I have since called Craigen and McKee shitebags on numerous occassions tho does it?

Kidd isnt a shitebag but I can readily acknowledge he isnt good enough

When are you two finally going to shag each other?