Jump to content

Keep, Punt or Undecided


Recommended Posts

15 hours ago, C4mmy31 said:

You do realise Millen only signed a 18 month contract in January......

Sorry I didn't realise we were only talking about out of contract players.......I was just giving my opinion on the general squad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, JamieThomas said:

Keep: Smith, Souttar, Uche, Hairband Haring, C-Dog Dikamona, Burns, Keena, Cochrane (Naismith if possible)

Final warning: Clare, Bozanic

Retire: Berra

Get so far to f**k that the Hubble telescope sucks air through it's teeth and grimaces: if your name hasn't been called yet, then I've got bad news

Mulraney would be worth keeping. At least he has a go at teams. He might develop and is probably being paid shitepence anyway.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Falcor Roar said:

Mulraney would be worth keeping. At least he has a go at teams. He might develop and is probably being paid shitepence anyway.  

Maybe, aye. But I'd like to think we'll sign at least two new wingers in the summer of rather more quality.

I'd like to think.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe, aye. But I'd like to think we'll sign at least two new wingers in the summer of rather more quality.
I'd like to think.

I’m sure there’ll be two wingers amongst our 12 summer signings
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, NJ2 said:

I’m sure there’ll be two wingers amongst our 12 summer signings

Hopefully another two or three Ryan Edwards style signings because there are apparently still some parts of oblivion that our signing policy hasn't trolled me into.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hopefully another two or three Ryan Edwards style signings because there are apparently still some parts of oblivion that our signing policy hasn't trolled me into.

I’m holding out for a Danny Amankwaa return or maybe even the next Connor Sammon
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, D'Jaffo said:

Even Nicky Cadden? Or is he still under contract?

Played really well last couple of games so I'd happily have him next season. 

Still under contract, he's better than some of the wingers we have in now. We'll trade you Gregg Wylde and you can have him :D 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gary Woods - Unpopular opinion, made some crucial saves this season but unfortunately has had more than a few howlers - Punt

Ryan Fulton - Good enough back up, could make the step up to first team depending on what division we are in - Keep

Jacob Marsden -  1 appearance this season, won't be on big money - Keep 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Alex Penny - Howler against Rangers, tried to bicycle kick it out the box against motherwell - Punt

Ziggy Gordon - Good few MotM performances this season,  potential captain depending on how long he stays - Keep 

Scott McMann - Not good enough for the premiership, might do better in the lower leagues - Punt 

Shaun Want - Started a few games under Canning and looked good, not been near the team since Rice took over - Punt 

Matthew Kilgallon - Played at a good level. I reckon he has a couple more years in him - Keep 

Delphin Tshiembe - No explanation needed, gets called Tshambles - Punt 

Alex Gogic - Same as Scott McMann, although he's had a long term injury so will give him the benefit of doubt - Keep 

Aaron McGowan - Good enough player, there is a place for him in the team - Keep 

Lennard Sowah -  Splits opinion among accies fans, i think he is useful - Keep 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Darian MacKinnon - Captain, not a very good footballer, signed a new contract recently - Keep 

Dougie Imrie - retiring at the end of the season, staying on as a youth coach - Keep 

Lewis Smith - The first accies supporting player to come through in a long time, for that reason alone - Keep 

Reegan Mimnaugh - Built like a match stick, celtic daft with IRA supporting family. He can pass a ball well which earns him a place - Keep 

Ronan Hughes - He is out on loan just now, no idea how he is doing - undecided 

Ross Cunningham - Same as above - undecided 

Scott Martin - Bags of energy, good player in there somewhere - Keep 

Tom Tawio - Not good enough, likes a strong tackle which gets him booked every game - Punt 

Tony Andreu  - Not been as good since he came back, still a player in there. His cross for big Steve Davis on Saturday there just shows what he can do - Keep 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

David McMillian - He has been terrible, not intrested at all, no doubt back to Ireland after the season is finished - Punt 

George Oakley - Scored a good few goals since he came in - Keep 

James Keatings - Championship striker, if we go down - Keep if not Punt 

Marios Ogkmpoe - The big man, i heard he is always down the Hamilton Palace, not seen enough of him this season to decide - undecided 

Mikel Miller - Frustrating player, i would keep if possible. I think he has his eye on a move back to England - Keep 

Steve Davis - The big man wins everything, would love him to stay - Keep 

Steven Boyd - Another frustrating player, i think he could be useful - Keep 

Edited by Skondras
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No.                  Player

1          Václav Hladký                         Keep. Has been an absolute find.

2          Paul McGinn                           Punt. Not good enough

3          Mateo Mužek                          Keep. Solid enough fullback

4          Stephen McGinn (captain)     Punt. Been horrific all season

5          Josh Heaton (on loan at Kidderminster Harriers)      Punt. Preferably to the fucking moon.

6          Gary MacKenzie                     Punt. Done.

7          Kyle Magennis                        Keep. Our best youngster.

8          Ryan Flynn                              Keep. Solid midfield worker.

11        Simeon Jackson                     Punt. Shite.

15        Jack Baird                               Keep. Decent centre back

17        James Kellermann                  Punt. Horrific footballer

18        Danny Mullen                          Keep.

20        Cody Cooke                            Keep.

22        Greg Tansey                           Punt. Although I guess we're now lumbered with him for a while.

28        Cameron MacPherson           Punt. To be honest, not good enough

35        Anton Ferdinand                     Punt. Carthorse.

39        Ethan Erhahon                        Keep. But MUST play in the middle. Getting torn up for arse paper as a left back.

Loans;

9          Duckens Nazon (on loan from Sint-Truiden)                          Punt.

10        Anders Dreyer (on loan from Brighton & Hove Albion)          Punt.

14        Brad Lyons (on loan from Blackburn Rovers)                        Punt.

16        Mihai Popescu (on loan from Dinamo Bucharest)                 Keep. We need to do all we can to sign this guy. A superb player.

21        Lee Hodson (on loan from Rangers)                                      Keep. Hopefully offer him a deal at the end of the season. I believe his Rangers contract is up.

23        Kyle McAllister (on loan from Derby County)                         Punt.

25        Danny Rogers (on loan from Aberdeen)                                Punt.

26        Jordan Holmes (on loan from Bournemouth)                         Punt.

33        Laurențiu Corbu (on loan from Dinamo Bucharest)               Punt.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Spam_Valley said:

No.                  Player

1          Václav Hladký                         Keep. Has been an absolute find.

2          Paul McGinn                           Punt. Not good enough

3          Mateo Mužek                          Keep. Solid enough fullback

4          Stephen McGinn (captain)     Punt. Been horrific all season

5          Josh Heaton (on loan at Kidderminster Harriers)      Punt. Preferably to the fucking moon.

6          Gary MacKenzie                     Punt. Done.

7          Kyle Magennis                        Keep. Our best youngster.

8          Ryan Flynn                              Keep. Solid midfield worker.

11        Simeon Jackson                     Punt. Shite.

15        Jack Baird                               Keep. Decent centre back

17        James Kellermann                  Punt. Horrific footballer

18        Danny Mullen                          Keep.

20        Cody Cooke                            Keep.

22        Greg Tansey                           Punt. Although I guess we're now lumbered with him for a while.

28        Cameron MacPherson           Punt. To be honest, not good enough

35        Anton Ferdinand                     Punt. Carthorse.

39        Ethan Erhahon                        Keep. But MUST play in the middle. Getting torn up for arse paper as a left back.

Loans;

9          Duckens Nazon (on loan from Sint-Truiden)                          Punt.

10        Anders Dreyer (on loan from Brighton & Hove Albion)          Punt.

14        Brad Lyons (on loan from Blackburn Rovers)                        Punt.

16        Mihai Popescu (on loan from Dinamo Bucharest)                 Keep. We need to do all we can to sign this guy. A superb player.

21        Lee Hodson (on loan from Rangers)                                      Keep. Hopefully offer him a deal at the end of the season. I believe his Rangers contract is up.

23        Kyle McAllister (on loan from Derby County)                         Punt.

25        Danny Rogers (on loan from Aberdeen)                                Punt.

26        Jordan Holmes (on loan from Bournemouth)                         Punt.

33        Laurențiu Corbu (on loan from Dinamo Bucharest)               Punt.

Punt Paul McGinn ? He's has been fairly solid this season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bachmann - Keep if at all possible, but sadly I doubt it.

MacDonald - Undecided. Has been fantastic for us, but probably not quite up to being a number 1 at the level we're currently playing at. If he's happy to stay as a number 2 then keep him.

Mackay - Undecided. Never seen him play.

 

O'Donnell - Keep.

Taylor - Keep.

Broadfoot - Keep.

Findlay - Keep.

Boyd - Keep.

Bruce - Undecided. No idea how good he is.

Millen - Punt. Not up to being a top six Premiership player and never will be.

Waters - Keep. Looks solid enough and still has a half-chance of making it.

Higgins - Punt. Don't think he's up to it.

 

Power - Keep.

Dicker - Keep.

Mulumbu - Keep, but probably unlikely.

Wilson - Keep. Definitely has something about him, but has obviously struggled for game time.

Tshibola - Keep. If we could get him permanently I think it would be worth doing. There's definitely something there, even if he can be a bit ponderous at times.

McKenzie - Keep.

Burke - Keep forever.

Jones - Punt. Already away.

Frizzell - Undecided. Looked a player before Clarke came in but has had limited chances and hasn't exactly dazzled when he's been on loan.

Kiltie - Undecided. Was magic before his injury but has struggled under Clarke. Would love to see it going well for him.

Thomas - Punt. Probably a good Championship level player but I don't think he's up to where we want to be.

 

Boyd - Undecided. Has been poor this year, but I thought there were signs of him looking more like last season's Boyd on Saturday. We've written him off before and he's come back.

Brophy - Keep.

McAleny - Undecided. Definitely has some talent but has a tendency to disappear and doesn't really influence games much. Doubt he'd get double figures across a full season.

Ndjoli - Punt. Not a footballer.

Millar - Keep. If we could get him another year that would be good - you can see he has some talent.

Cameron - Keep. I think he could be on the fringes next year.

 

Clarke - Punt. Bottled the title race, get John Hughes in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, craigkillie said:

 

Tshibola - Keep. If we could get him permanently I think it would be worth doing. There's definitely something there, even if he can be a bit ponderous at times.

 

Image result for really gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...