Jump to content

North Caledonian League Expansion


Robert James

Recommended Posts

On 12/02/2020 at 07:43, Cyclizine said:

Loch Ness currently one of the many clubs to play on the Bught. Not sure where they'd play in the NCL.

 

On 12/02/2020 at 07:43, Cyclizine said:

Loch Ness currently one of the many clubs to play on the Bught. Not sure where they'd play in the NCL.

If Loch Ness join the NCL, the club may/may not be able to use the Bught during the winter season ?

If not, what about the ground at Farr ? I never understood why Inverness Athletic moved to an alternative venue, part way through their first season.

Other possibilities include the Northern Meeting Park or North Kessock, both of which have been used for NCL football in the past.

And there is also Kirkhill, but is this venue suitable for NCL football ?  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 04/02/2020 at 12:18, Robert James said:

I hope that your post about Alness United returning to the North Caley next season, comes true. They have been missed.  Also, their Under 17 team is taking the Highland youth league (north) by storm this season.  

I am told that Alness wants to return, but the loss of their ground at Dalmore Park,  has been the problem. 

Nothing confirmed as yet, apparently. 

The club has retained its NCL Membership, and their Under 17 team has been excellent in the HFL youth league, this season.

Also, it will also be interesting to see if Shetland FC enters one (or more ?) of the NCL cup competitions next season, after a 2 year absence.  Like fellow NCL member club, Lewis & Harris FC, they cannot participate in the League itself.  Unless of course there is a very rich benefactor waiting to fly in !

(If you haven't been to the Shetland Isles, it is well worth a visit).

Edited by Robert James
additional question added
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, FairWeatherFan said:

Checking FN looks like Orkney have organised two games on the same day to deal with their fixture congestion.

The rough weather has  meant that ferries have been cancelled in recent weeks, and the NCL's official (revised) fixture list does show Orkney playing 2 matches on Sat 14th March :  Bunillidh Thistle (away) & Bonar Bridge (home).

Very unusual, although Orkney does have sufficient playing resources to play 2 separate fixtures on the same day. However if the bad weather continues, one or other (or both) of the games could be postponed . 

 

On 12/02/2020 at 07:43, Cyclizine said:

Loch Ness currently one of the many clubs to play on the Bught. Not sure where they'd play in the NCL.

Canal Street (in Inverness) has been suggested as a possible home ground for Loch Ness, if they join the NCL next season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Robert James said:

Canal Street (in Inverness) has been suggested as a possible home ground for Loch Ness, if they join the NCL next season.

I don't think there is a Canal Street in Inverness, Robert. Do you mean Canal Park? That's unlikely to happen, given the number of teams Highland RFC have using it. Are you "suggesting" this yourself, again?

 

On 20/02/2020 at 20:34, Robert James said:

 

If Loch Ness join the NCL, the club may/may not be able to use the Bught during the winter season ?

If not, what about the ground at Farr ? I never understood why Inverness Athletic moved to an alternative venue, part way through their first season.

Other possibilities include the Northern Meeting Park or North Kessock, both of which have been used for NCL football in the past.

And there is also Kirkhill, but is this venue suitable for NCL football ?  

Did you just copy my previous post, there?

Farr isn't a particularly handy ground for an Inverness-based club and the facilities at the IRA are much better. Same as Kirkhill, really.

Edited by Cyclizine
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Cyclizine said:

I don't think there is a Canal Street in Inverness, Robert. Do you mean Canal Park? That's unlikely to happen, given the number of teams Highland RFC have using it. Are you "suggesting" this yourself, again?

Did you just copy my previous post, there?

Farr isn't a particularly handy ground for an Inverness-based club and the facilities at the IRA are much better. Same as Kirkhill, really.

Noted. From my days as a lad, I supported the Jags at Kingsmills, but I don't live in Inverness now.

FYI Canal Park apparently isn't used to capacity. Football has been played there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is an excellent article and link (today), on the Future of the Juniors forum. Balanced, in depth, and well researched, in my opinion.

In addition to debating the pyramid 'conundrum' in the West and the East Regions, it also covers the current situation in the North Caledonian League & in the North Juniors.

The link is :              https://purefitbaw.com/2020/02/26/the-pyramid-conundrum/

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Robert James said:

Noted. From my days as a lad, I supported the Jags at Kingsmills, but I don't live in Inverness now.

FYI Canal Park apparently isn't used to capacity. Football has been played there.

Are you suggesting permanent Friday night games? Or Sunday afternoons? Canal Park is used extensively by the rugby club for matches and training for all ages. It has been used by Clach a couple of times due to their fire. As has been pointed out, there are multiple other options available.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, Cyclizine said:

Are you suggesting permanent Friday night games? Or Sunday afternoons? Canal Park is used extensively by the rugby club for matches and training for all ages. It has been used by Clach a couple of times due to their fire. As has been pointed out, there are multiple other options available.

Options yes.  But Loch Ness have not yet confirmed where they will play NCL matches, if they join (as rumoured on this forum), as the " 2nd applicant, believed to be from Inverness".

Unless of course, you have further information. If so, please share it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 20/02/2020 at 20:34, Robert James said:

 

If Loch Ness join the NCL, the club may/may not be able to use the Bught during the winter season ?

If not, what about the ground at Farr ? I never understood why Inverness Athletic moved to an alternative venue, part way through their first season.

Other possibilities include the Northern Meeting Park or North Kessock, both of which have been used for NCL football in the past.

And there is also Kirkhill, but is this venue suitable for NCL football ?  

 

1 hour ago, Cyclizine said:

 As has been pointed out, there are multiple other options available.

Sadly Inverness City didn't find it so easy. Inverness Athletic had to play in Muir of Ord till they found a friendly school in Inverness to let them borrow their pitch. I assume NCL rules are similar to the Superleague, and the cost of of getting Kirkhill up to scratch, including the drainage, would have been far more than City could afford after blowing any kind of budget they had from donations and loans on developing and then tearing apart Lister Park, thanks to the cricket rugby and golf mad Highland Council.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, welshbairn said:

 

Sadly Inverness City didn't find it so easy. Inverness Athletic had to play in Muir of Ord till they found a friendly school in Inverness to let them borrow their pitch. I assume NCL rules are similar to the Superleague, and the cost of of getting Kirkhill up to scratch, including the drainage, would have been far more than City could afford after blowing any kind of budget they had from donations and loans on developing and then tearing apart Lister Park, thanks to the cricket rugby and golf mad Highland Council.

Yes, I followed the ground problems that Inverness City experienced, and realised that it was an uphill battle with the Authorities.  Once Clachnacuddin also said  "no" their demise was probably  inevitable.

  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were other behind the scenes issues with Inverness City, notwithstanding the ground. It was not incumbent on the council to provide them with a ready made facility. There were and are issues regarding a legal covenant on the Bught with issues over access rights.

Cityhad five years to sort an alternative ground, the Bught was always a temporary arrangement. City chose to develop Lister Park knowing this.

It pains me to say, but I don't see why the council should have prioritised what was a new club over long established clubs in alternative sports, namely cricket and rugby; especially when there are two senior clubs in ICT and Clach, plus a very active amateur league.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 hours ago, Cyclizine said:

There were other behind the scenes issues with Inverness City, notwithstanding the ground. It was not incumbent on the council to provide them with a ready made facility. There were and are issues regarding a legal covenant on the Bught with issues over access rights.

Cityhad five years to sort an alternative ground, the Bught was always a temporary arrangement. City chose to develop Lister Park knowing this.

It pains me to say, but I don't see why the council should have prioritised what was a new club over long established clubs in alternative sports, namely cricket and rugby; especially when there are two senior clubs in ICT and Clach, plus a very active amateur league.

I agree entirely. City were over ambitious.

My interest now however, is where will Loch Ness or A N Other Inverness club, play their home games, if they are elected as Members of the North Caley for 2020/21 ?. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Highland Capital said:

I kind of mentioned this in passing but would the shinty ground in Drum be a possible home for Loch Ness? You’d imagine it’d be up to the regulations.

Not been there for years, so my question is whether or not shinty is still being played at this venue  ?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Snafu said:

Not sure what's wrong with wanting to play at the highest level in the North Juniors is being regarded as over ambitious?

People fail to believe that there are very few suitable places where football above amateur league can be played within Inverness and that there is a lot of competition to get priority on these pitches.

Absolutely nothing wrong with club's being ambitious. 

However Cyclizine  above has explained that City (sadly) ignored warnings from the Authorities, that the lease on the Bught would not be extended (although there was a brief extension as the club were holding talks with Clach, which later failed to materialise).  Also, Kirkhill became a non-starter.

Perhaps "over ambitious"was a bit unfair on my part, but the reality is that the club closed down . No suitable alternative venue in Inverness, was found. This is the reason why the rumour that Loch Ness AFC is ;looking to join the NCL, throws up the question, where will their ground be ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, Robert James said:

However Cyclizine  above has explained that City (sadly) ignored warnings from the Authorities, that the lease on the Bught would not be extended

They didn't ignore the warnings, they looked absolutely  everywhere for an alternative and the cost of sorting out the drainage especially at Kirkhill proved unsurmountable. The council was stubborn to the point of pettiness, having previously forced them out of the barely used Northern Meeting Ground but for the odd pipers get together and a handful of cricket games in the summer. The £3.5 million spent on new rugby facilities connected to the bypass could have easily had facilities for junior level football attached.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, welshbairn said:

They didn't ignore the warnings, they looked absolutely  everywhere for an alternative and the cost of sorting out the drainage especially at Kirkhill proved unsurmountable. The council was stubborn to the point of pettiness, having previously forced them out of the barely used Northern Meeting Ground but for the odd pipers get together and a handful of cricket games in the summer. The £3.5 million spent on new rugby facilities connected to the bypass could have easily had facilities for junior level football attached.  

What do you have against other sports? It's not just about football. 

Canal Park didn't just get funding from the council: There was significant input from the SRU and Sport Scotland too. Highland RFC run multiple adult teams and loads of age group teams with hundreds of kids playing.

There are and were extensive amateur football facilities in Inverness plus two senior grounds. Inverness City came in as a new club, it was only the requirements of the Superleague that meant they had to improve the facilities. They could've come up with a sustainable plan staying in the NCL or even First Division of the NRJFA, but they chased promotion without a plan for where they'd play.

They knew from the start the Bught was temporary. I know it sounds harsh, but the council didn't owe them a ground, any more than they owe Fort William or Thurso new pitches. The chairman then had the gall to accuse them of favouritism over the Dalneigh pitches, where Clach have trained and run kids football for years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Snafu said:

People fail to believe that there are very few suitable places where football above amateur league can be played within Inverness and that there is a lot of competition to get priority on these pitches.

 

1 hour ago, Snafu said:

There was no other option at the time Lister Park was constructed and wasn't until the possibility opened to ground share with Clach

As a club you have to be sustainable! City knew the requirements for the Superleague before they applied, if they didn't they did poor due diligence. They chose to put money into Lister Park knowing that it was only ever temporary.

They had other options, they could've stayed in the NCL, like Athletic, or even in the lower junior tiers until they had a workable plan.

I know this seems harsh, but this is looking at the big picture.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...