Jump to content

Junior football, what is the future?


Burnie_man

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, GordonS said:

And that would be relevant if they were setting up a South West Scotland League. But it's a West of Scotland League, which means it doesn't cover Kirkcudbright any more than it covers Fort William.

Besides, I wouldn't say Moffat, Lockerbie, Lochmaben, Dumfries of New Abbey are in the South West of Scotland anyway. Dumfries is further east than Falkirk while Lockerbie is as far east as Edinburgh airport.

You're not wrong mate  but then Liverpool is further east than Edinburgh but you'd hardly count Edinburgh as being West would you? It's all fairly academic anyway as many have pointed out this is a debate for another time.  Personally I think we need two feeders to the (LL) East and West but at the moment we'll have three which is a first world problem at best.   Others are free to disagree with my opinion as they have.  I'm looking forward to seeing the new WOS league up and running (god knows when) and i'm interested to see how the SJC evolves through the transition period.  It'll also be interesting to see how many licenced clubs we have in the next few years.  I missed our trip to Linlithgow Rose but would love an away day to some of the former Juniors.  I hope the remaining East Juniors decide to join the pyramid but it has to be their decision no one should be forced.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hopefully, in years to come the Junior Cup can become a cup for all teams in the pyramid outside the Professional* Game: i.e. Tier 6 and below. Similar to the FA Trophy in England.


*I know junior clubs and EoS clubs are paying wages but Tier 5 and above is what the SFA call "Professional".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Doonhamer1969 said:

I entirely agree .

As I said , SoS geography shouldn't go against it .

I apologise if it seems I was having a go at the  NCL.

The main points were that if it can be at Tier 6 for geographical reasons , which I have absolutely no objection to , so can the SoS, and that the rush that some on here advocate to demote the  SoS appears hypocritical  given the relative strengths of the SoS and NCL.

Apology accepted, thank you.

The NCL was formed in 1896, and has survived despite adverse weather conditions, and its geographic remoteness, which has not been helped historically, by poor roads.   The league has had a close affinity with the Highland League, as the "Reserve XI's" of the three Inverness clubs (Caley, Thistle, & Clach), plus Fort William,  Nairn Co, Lossiemouth, and several others, have all played in the North Caledonian League from time to time, although there haven't been any in recent seasons.

After a few difficult years when membership was lower, the NCL is now on the up, with 9 league clubs in 2019/20, plus Lewis & Harris FC and Nairn County's Development XI, participating in some of its league cup competitions.  In addition, 4 new clubs have applied to join the league for 2020/21 (see article in the Inverness Courier).

The NCL's territory covers the north & west Highlands, the city of Inverness, and the islands of Orkney and the Western Isles (+ occasionally the Shetland Isles for cup competitions). There is no 'boundary' overlap problems with the North Region's Junior clubs, as none of them are located in these areas, thereby facilitating geographical integrity.

If the NCL and also the NRJFA Juniors, join the pyramid, there would need to be two separate  'feeder' leagues, with a play-off, if the 2 champion clubs were both licensed.

PS :  there are highlights of the  Football Times Cup Final (played on 18th January 2020), on the NCL website  :  Golspie Sutherland 2  St Duthus (Tain) 3.        A very competitive match, and some very good goals. Worth a look.

.

Edited by Robert James
typo error
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, San Starko Rover said:

You're not wrong mate  but then Liverpool is further east than Edinburgh but you'd hardly count Edinburgh as being West would you?

Edinburgh is west of Valencia too, but we're talking about Scotland.

The South of Scotland isn't really part of the east or west of Scotland, culturally or geographically. The NCL is a good analogy, because you wouldn't say Helmsdale is part of the east or west of Scotland, though it's technically on the east coast. It's just the north.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Mission of the SoSFL is "To Develop, Foster, Co-Ordinate and Sustain Association Football at the Club and League level throughout South West Scotland". One of its objectives is "To play and promote Association Football in the South of Scotland." There is no mention of Dumfries or Galloway in its constitution. The constitution doesn’t define either "south" or "south west." However, any common sense definition clearly extends beyond Galloway and Dumfries.

Personally I think the best outcome would be to incorporate the SoSL into the new West, with probably most of the South teams eventually finding their place towards the bottom of the structure, and probably in regionalised leagues that stretch NS rather than EW, given longer east-west travel times. But no one can doubt given the SoSL constitution that that league could have insisted that most aspiring WoSL teams wanting access to the pyramid should have joined them. They are making a sacrifice for the greater good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The current list of 50 clubs that propose to join the WoSFL:


1. Lugar Boswell Thistle (SJFA West League Two)

2. Clydebank (SJFA West Region Premiership)

3. Kilwinning Rangers (SJFA West Region Premiership)

4. Rutherglen Glencairn (SJFA West Region Premiership)

5. Bellshill Athletic (SJFA West League One)

6. Drumchapel United (Central Scottish Amateur Premier Division)

7. Neilston Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

8. Maryhill (SJFA West League One)

9. Kello Rovers (SJFA West League One)

10. Blantyre Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

11. Kirkintilloch Rob Roy (SJFA West Region Premiership)

12. Vale of Clyde (SJFA West League Two)

13. Renfrew (SJFA West Region Championship)

14. Royal Albert (SJFA West League One)

15. Arthurlie (SJFA West Region Championship)

16. Newmains United (SJFA West League Two)

17. Kilsyth Rangers (SJFA West Region Championship)

18. Whitletts Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

19. Gartcairn Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

20. Cambuslang Rangers  (SJFA West Region Championship)

21. Cumbernauld United (SJFA West Region Championship)

22. Glasgow Perthshire (SJFA West League One)

23. Ashfield (SJFA West League Two)

24. Petershill (SJFA West Region Championship)

25. Greenock Juniors (SJFA West League One)

26. Larkhall Thistle (SJFA West League One)

27. Port Glasgow Juniors (SJFA West League One)

28. Pollok (SJFA West Region Premiership)

29. Darvel Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

30. Vale of Leven (SJFA West League Two)

31. Glenafton Athletic (SJFA West Region Premiership)

32. Johnstone Burgh (SJFA West League Two)

33. Auchinleck Talbot (SJFA West Region Premiership)

34. Largs Thistle (SJFA West Region Premiership)

35. Kilbirnie Ladeside (SJFA West Region Premiership)

36. Troon (SJFA West Region Premiership)

37. Irvine Meadow XI (SJFA West Region Premiership)

38. Beith Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership) 

39. Shotts Bon Accord (SJFA West Region Championship)

40.  Forth Wanderers (SJFA West League Two)

41. Muirkirk Juniors (SJFA West League Two)

42. Benburb (SJFA West Region Premiership)  

43. Shettleston (SJFA West League One)

44. Irvine Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

45. Dalry Thistle (SJFA West Region Championship)

46. Cumnock Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership)

47. Girvan (SJFA West League One)

48. Wishaw Juniors (SJFA West League One)

49. Rossvale (SJFA West Region Premiership)

50. East Kilbride Thistle (SJFA West League One)


SJFA West Region Premiership (15 clubs)

Auchinleck Talbot; Beith Juniors; Benburb; Clydebank; Cumnock Juniors; Glenafton Athletic; Hurlford United; Irvine Meadow; Kilbirnie Ladeside; Kilwinning Rangers; Kirkintilloch Rob Roy; Largs Thistle; Pollok; Rossvale; Rutherglen Glencairn; Troon

SJFA West Region Championship (14 clubs)

Arthurlie; Blantyre Victoria; Cambuslang Rangers; Craigmark Burntonians; Cumbernauld United; Dalry Thistle; Darvel Juniors; Gartcairn Juniors; Irvine Victoria; Kilsyth Rangers; Neilston Juniors; Petershill; Renfrew; Shotts Bon Accord; St Roch's; Whitletts Victoria

SJFA West Region League One (12 clubs)

Ardrossan Winton Rovers; Bellshill Athletic; Carluke Rovers; East Kilbride Thistle; Girvan; Glasgow Perthshire; Greenock Juniors; Kello Rovers; Lanark United; Larkhall Thistle; Lesmahagow; Maryhill; Port Glasgow; Royal Albert; Shettleston; Wishaw Juniors

SJFA West Region League Two (8 clubs)

Annbank United; Ardeer Thistle; Ashfield; Forth Wanderers; Johnstone Burgh; Lugar Boswell Thistle; Maybole Juniors; Muirkirk Juniors; Newmains United; Saltcoats Victoria; St Anthony's; Thorniewood United; Vale of Clyde; Vale of Leven; Yoker Athletic

South of Scotland League (0 clubs)

Abbey Vale; Bonnyton Thistle; Caledonian Braves Res; Creetown; Heston Rovers; Lochar Thistle; Lochmaben; Mid-Annandale; Newton Stewart; Nithsdale Wanderers; St Cuthbert Wanderers; Stranraer Res; Threave Rovers; Upper Annandale; Wigtown & Bladnoch

Amateurs (1 club)

Drumchapel United PYM; Glasgow University; Oban Saints; Strathclyde University

More applicants to follow to be added to the growing list!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The current list of 50 clubs that propose to join the WoSFL:


1. Lugar Boswell Thistle (SJFA West League Two)

2. Clydebank (SJFA West Region Premiership)

3. Kilwinning Rangers (SJFA West Region Premiership)

4. Rutherglen Glencairn (SJFA West Region Premiership)

5. Bellshill Athletic (SJFA West League One)

6. Drumchapel United (Central Scottish Amateur Premier Division)

7. Neilston Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

8. Maryhill (SJFA West League One)

9. Kello Rovers (SJFA West League One)

10. Blantyre Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

11. Kirkintilloch Rob Roy (SJFA West Region Premiership)

12. Vale of Clyde (SJFA West League Two)

13. Renfrew (SJFA West Region Championship)

14. Royal Albert (SJFA West League One)

15. Arthurlie (SJFA West Region Championship)

16. Newmains United (SJFA West League Two)

17. Kilsyth Rangers (SJFA West Region Championship)

18. Whitletts Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

19. Gartcairn Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

20. Cambuslang Rangers  (SJFA West Region Championship)

21. Cumbernauld United (SJFA West Region Championship)

22. Glasgow Perthshire (SJFA West League One)

23. Ashfield (SJFA West League Two)

24. Petershill (SJFA West Region Championship)

25. Greenock Juniors (SJFA West League One)

26. Larkhall Thistle (SJFA West League One)

27. Port Glasgow Juniors (SJFA West League One)

28. Pollok (SJFA West Region Premiership)

29. Darvel Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

30. Vale of Leven (SJFA West League Two)

31. Glenafton Athletic (SJFA West Region Premiership)

32. Johnstone Burgh (SJFA West League Two)

33. Auchinleck Talbot (SJFA West Region Premiership)

34. Largs Thistle (SJFA West Region Premiership)

35. Kilbirnie Ladeside (SJFA West Region Premiership)
36. Troon (SJFA West Region Premiership)
37. Irvine Meadow XI (SJFA West Region Premiership)
38. Beith Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership) 
39. Shotts Bon Accord (SJFA West Region Championship)
40.  Forth Wanderers (SJFA West League Two)
41. Muirkirk Juniors (SJFA West League Two)
42. Benburb (SJFA West Region Premiership)  
43. Shettleston (SJFA West League One)
44. Irvine Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)
45. Dalry Thistle (SJFA West Region Championship)
46. Cumnock Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership)
47. Girvan (SJFA West League One)
48. Wishaw Juniors (SJFA West League One)
49. Rossvale (SJFA West Region Premiership)
50. East Kilbride Thistle (SJFA West League One)

SJFA West Region Premiership (15 clubs)
Auchinleck Talbot; Beith Juniors; Benburb; Clydebank; Cumnock Juniors; Glenafton Athletic; Hurlford United; Irvine Meadow; Kilbirnie Ladeside; Kilwinning Rangers; Kirkintilloch Rob Roy; Largs Thistle; Pollok; Rossvale; Rutherglen Glencairn; Troon
SJFA West Region Championship (14 clubs)
Arthurlie; Blantyre Victoria; Cambuslang Rangers; Craigmark Burntonians; Cumbernauld United; Dalry Thistle; Darvel Juniors; Gartcairn Juniors; Irvine Victoria; Kilsyth Rangers; Neilston Juniors; Petershill; Renfrew; Shotts Bon Accord; St Roch's; Whitletts Victoria
SJFA West Region League One (12 clubs)
Ardrossan Winton Rovers; Bellshill Athletic; Carluke Rovers; East Kilbride Thistle; Girvan; Glasgow Perthshire; Greenock Juniors; Kello Rovers; Lanark United; Larkhall Thistle; Lesmahagow; Maryhill; Port Glasgow; Royal Albert; Shettleston; Wishaw Juniors
SJFA West Region League Two (8 clubs)
Annbank United; Ardeer Thistle; Ashfield; Forth Wanderers; Johnstone Burgh; Lugar Boswell Thistle; Maybole Juniors; Muirkirk Juniors; Newmains United; Saltcoats Victoria; St Anthony's; Thorniewood United; Vale of Clyde; Vale of Leven; Yoker Athletic
South of Scotland League (0 clubs)
Abbey Vale; Bonnyton Thistle; Caledonian Braves Res; Creetown; Heston Rovers; Lochar Thistle; Lochmaben; Mid-Annandale; Newton Stewart; Nithsdale Wanderers; St Cuthbert Wanderers; Stranraer Res; Threave Rovers; Upper Annandale; Wigtown & Bladnoch
Amateurs (1 club)
Drumchapel United PYM; Glasgow University; Oban Saints; Strathclyde University
More applicants to follow to be added to the growing list!
Can you list those WRJFA clubs who havent yet publicly declared?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, BMan said:
46 minutes ago, Pyramidic said:

The current list of 50 clubs that propose to join the WoSFL:


1. Lugar Boswell Thistle (SJFA West League Two)

2. Clydebank (SJFA West Region Premiership)

3. Kilwinning Rangers (SJFA West Region Premiership)

4. Rutherglen Glencairn (SJFA West Region Premiership)

5. Bellshill Athletic (SJFA West League One)

6. Drumchapel United (Central Scottish Amateur Premier Division)

7. Neilston Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

8. Maryhill (SJFA West League One)

9. Kello Rovers (SJFA West League One)

10. Blantyre Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

11. Kirkintilloch Rob Roy (SJFA West Region Premiership)

12. Vale of Clyde (SJFA West League Two)

13. Renfrew (SJFA West Region Championship)

14. Royal Albert (SJFA West League One)

15. Arthurlie (SJFA West Region Championship)

16. Newmains United (SJFA West League Two)

17. Kilsyth Rangers (SJFA West Region Championship)

18. Whitletts Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)

19. Gartcairn Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

20. Cambuslang Rangers  (SJFA West Region Championship)

21. Cumbernauld United (SJFA West Region Championship)

22. Glasgow Perthshire (SJFA West League One)

23. Ashfield (SJFA West League Two)

24. Petershill (SJFA West Region Championship)

25. Greenock Juniors (SJFA West League One)

26. Larkhall Thistle (SJFA West League One)

27. Port Glasgow Juniors (SJFA West League One)

28. Pollok (SJFA West Region Premiership)

29. Darvel Juniors (SJFA West Region Championship)

30. Vale of Leven (SJFA West League Two)

31. Glenafton Athletic (SJFA West Region Premiership)

32. Johnstone Burgh (SJFA West League Two)

33. Auchinleck Talbot (SJFA West Region Premiership)

34. Largs Thistle (SJFA West Region Premiership)

35. Kilbirnie Ladeside (SJFA West Region Premiership)
36. Troon (SJFA West Region Premiership)
37. Irvine Meadow XI (SJFA West Region Premiership)
38. Beith Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership) 
39. Shotts Bon Accord (SJFA West Region Championship)
40.  Forth Wanderers (SJFA West League Two)
41. Muirkirk Juniors (SJFA West League Two)
42. Benburb (SJFA West Region Premiership)  
43. Shettleston (SJFA West League One)
44. Irvine Victoria (SJFA West Region Championship)
45. Dalry Thistle (SJFA West Region Championship)
46. Cumnock Juniors (SJFA West Region Premiership)
47. Girvan (SJFA West League One)
48. Wishaw Juniors (SJFA West League One)
49. Rossvale (SJFA West Region Premiership)
50. East Kilbride Thistle (SJFA West League One)

SJFA West Region Premiership (15 clubs)
Auchinleck Talbot; Beith Juniors; Benburb; Clydebank; Cumnock Juniors; Glenafton Athletic; Hurlford United; Irvine Meadow; Kilbirnie Ladeside; Kilwinning Rangers; Kirkintilloch Rob Roy; Largs Thistle; Pollok; Rossvale; Rutherglen Glencairn; Troon
SJFA West Region Championship (14 clubs)
Arthurlie; Blantyre Victoria; Cambuslang Rangers; Craigmark Burntonians; Cumbernauld United; Dalry Thistle; Darvel Juniors; Gartcairn Juniors; Irvine Victoria; Kilsyth Rangers; Neilston Juniors; Petershill; Renfrew; Shotts Bon Accord; St Roch's; Whitletts Victoria
SJFA West Region League One (12 clubs)
Ardrossan Winton Rovers; Bellshill Athletic; Carluke Rovers; East Kilbride Thistle; Girvan; Glasgow Perthshire; Greenock Juniors; Kello Rovers; Lanark United; Larkhall Thistle; Lesmahagow; Maryhill; Port Glasgow; Royal Albert; Shettleston; Wishaw Juniors
SJFA West Region League Two (8 clubs)
Annbank United; Ardeer Thistle; Ashfield; Forth Wanderers; Johnstone Burgh; Lugar Boswell Thistle; Maybole Juniors; Muirkirk Juniors; Newmains United; Saltcoats Victoria; St Anthony's; Thorniewood United; Vale of Clyde; Vale of Leven; Yoker Athletic
South of Scotland League (0 clubs)
Abbey Vale; Bonnyton Thistle; Caledonian Braves Res; Creetown; Heston Rovers; Lochar Thistle; Lochmaben; Mid-Annandale; Newton Stewart; Nithsdale Wanderers; St Cuthbert Wanderers; Stranraer Res; Threave Rovers; Upper Annandale; Wigtown & Bladnoch
Amateurs (1 club)
Drumchapel United PYM; Glasgow University; Oban Saints; Strathclyde University
More applicants to follow to be added to the growing list!

Can you list those WRJFA clubs who havent yet publicly declared?

Jeezo, the guy has gone to the trouble of collating a list of teams who have declared and given the list of teams in each division. Do a bit of leg work yourself and work it out.

Well done Pyramidic you're doing a sterling job. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, BMan said:

Can you list those WRJFA clubs who havent yet publicly declared?

The following 14 WRJFA clubs have yet to make a public declaration to join the WoSFL:

SJFA West Region Premiership (1 club)
- Hurlford United

SJFA West Region Championship (2 clubs)
- Craigmark Burntonians
- St Roch's

SJFA West Region League One (4 clubs)
- Ardrossan Winton Rovers
- Carluke Rovers
- Lanark United
- Lesmahagow

SJFA West Region League Two (7 clubs)
- Annbank United
- Ardeer Thistle
- Maybole Juniors
- Saltcoats Victoria
- St Anthony's
- Thorniewood United
- Yoker Athletic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So given there are almost certainly some undeclared applicants (it's hard to believe that Hurlford and St Roch's won't apply, for example) and there are only 7 Ayrshire and 7 Central clubs left, it's difficult to see how a viable rump WRSJFA or old school Ayrshire and Central setup could emerge at this point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, Pyramidic said:

The following 14 WRJFA clubs have yet to make a public declaration to join the WoSFL:

SJFA West Region Premiership (1 club)
- Hurlford United

SJFA West Region Championship (2 clubs)
- Craigmark Burntonians
- St Roch's

SJFA West Region League One (4 clubs)
- Ardrossan Winton Rovers
- Carluke Rovers
- Lanark United
- Lesmahagow

SJFA West Region League Two (7 clubs)
- Annbank United
- Ardeer Thistle
- Maybole Juniors
- Saltcoats Victoria
- St Anthony's
- Thorniewood United
- Yoker Athletic

Can you now list all the amateur clubs that haven't publicly applied

In alphabetical order please

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Marshmallo said:

Jeezo, the guy has gone to the trouble of collating a list of teams who have declared and given the list of teams in each division. Do a bit of leg work yourself and work it out.

Well done Pyramidic you're doing a sterling job. Thank you.

You’re an absolute walloper. GTF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, AsimButtHitsASix said:

Can you now list all the amateur clubs that haven't publicly applied

In alphabetical order please

Looking in my crystal ball I would say that we are on firmly on course for 67 clubs in the 2020/21 WoSFL:

 

Our 63 WRJFA clubs

plus

- Drumchapel United (Central Scottish Amateur League Premier Division)

- Glasgow University (Caledonian League Premier Division)

- Bonnyton Thistle (South of Scotland League)

- Newton Stewart (South of Scotland League)


There again I could be completely off the mark!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...