Who has been your best players in this seasons West Region Super Premier Division?

[fan of the juniors]

Longmuir is an excellent goalkeeper but he hasn't been the best this season. Andy Leishman still the best for me. All round game is excellent. Least goals conceded and probably most clean sheets in the league.

No doubt that Andy is a quality keeper but I felt the last few times I've seen him he hasn't been at his best . Just my personal opinion

[maicoman]

5 hours ago, Quantum Leap said:

 

I concur.
There is no better keeper in the Juniors than Leishman.

 

Have to agree with that

[kenny131]

Cue Leishman to have an absolute horror show in the final after all the praise

[Oscar Wilder]

Leishman is a great keeper, his 'no 2" isny far behind him tho! [emoji3]

[Nugent4nil]

Not reading but over 350 votes in..... poll closes on Wednesday results announced Thursday night on the radio...

[Nugent4nil]

Voting closes tomorrow night, results announced Thursday, over 500 people have now voted.

[Nugent4nil]

Final Results

 

Management picks awarded 5 points

Twitter and committee picks 2 points

Online votes 1 point

 

The following players just missed out but deserve a mention,

Goalkeepers

Brian McGarrity Glenafton Athletic, Grant Hay Arthurlie, and Stephen Grindlay of Beith

Defenders

Mark McLaughlin Beith, Gordon Pope Talbot, and Daniel Boyle Rob Roy

Midfielders

Paul Frize and Jamie Wilson Beith and Chris Duff Rob Roy

Forwards

Del Hepburn Pollok, Scott Anson Cumnock, Graham Wilson Talbot

 

Team 4-4-2

Jordan Longmuir                 Pollok (172)

 

Craig Menzies                      Glenafton (111)

Conner McGlinchey                        Beith (84)

Paul Gallacher                     Pollok (71)

Kevin Green                         Rob Roy (52)

 

David Anderson                   Kilbirnie (125)

Ally Park                                Glenafton (67)

David Gray                            Glenafton (53)

Gary McCann                       Pollok (50)

 

Adam Forde                          Kilbirnie (154)

Darren Christie                     Beith (16)

 

Subs

Andrew Leishman               Auchinleck Talbot (GK)

Martin McGoldrick                Auchinleck Talbot (Def)

Nicky Docherty                     Beith (Def)

Del Esplin                             Cumnock (Mid)

Bryan Young                        Talbot (Mid)

Joe Andrew                           Glenafton (Fwd)

Willie Sawyers                      Rob Roy (Fwd)

[Troon Portland]

Final Results
 
Team 4-4-2
Jordan Longmuir                 Pollok (172)
 
Craig Menzies                      Glenafton (111)
Conner McGlinchey                        Beith (84)
Paul Gallacher                     Pollok (71)
Kevin Green                         Rob Roy (52)
 
David Anderson                   Kilbirnie (125)
Ally Park                                Glenafton (67)
David Gray                            Glenafton (53)
Gary McCann                       Pollok (50)
 
Adam Forde                          Kilbirnie (154)
Darren Christie                     Beith (16)

Don't think many would argue with that. Well done to those named!

[fan of the juniors]

A good spread of players from the teams & kinda rules out the notion that fans voted for their own teams players . As I do the Ladeside twitter I got a pick & glad to see that I know a thing or 2 as all my picks are mentioned [emoji106][emoji106]

[ex-german exile]

Interesting that the second best forward only got 16 votes.

[Glens lad]

Nice to see big Marko of Beith getting a mention. Getting on a bit now. But obviously still has it [emoji122]

[Nugent4nil]

9 hours ago, ex-german exile said:

Interesting that the second best forward only got 16 votes.

Thats another typo Daz got 88 top ten forwards were as follows,

[CC1987]

I appreciate the effort that has gone into this and well done to you Sir for that.

However I do find it a bit pointless as in one or maybe two performances against a certain team can get you nominated.  I could probably name the teams who nominated our players.  

I would say that the players nominated at my club are very unlikely to be involved in our own player of the year awards.

[Nugent4nil]

OK how would you suggest it could be done better and fairer? As for players being judged on two games against your club surely thats x 11 as its eleven opponents views against your club? Also the original nominations were made by management who will have seen your team more than just twice over the season I have no doubt.

[rednblack]

I would say that team is near enough spot on.

[Glens lad]

Please note this is 100% unofficial[/url]

Therefore to be taken with a pinch of salt.

[rednblack]

If you actually go to games every week and watch the vast majority of games and take into account it got hundreds of votes and management suggestion the team is near enough spot on even the subs are.

 

It's a very good credible team and squad to say pinch of salt is ridiculous.

 

 

[Glens lad]

If you actually go to games every week and watch the vast majority of games and take into account it got hundreds of votes and management suggestion the team is near enough spot on even the subs are.
 
It's a very good credible team and squad to say pinch of salt is ridiculous.
 
 

Not questioning the team. The concept was mean as a bit of fun was in not ? If not I apologise [emoji5]

[Glens lad]

It did say " not 100% official " to me that = bit of fun [emoji6]

[Glens lad]

And no I don't go to games every week. I follow one team and one team only. Wish I had the time to do so. But unfortunately not so make do with what I can attend [emoji851]

I'll shut up now [emoji23]