Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Team Qos

Under contract Marshall, Pickard, Thomson, Atkinson

 

Loan returns Harris, Murdoch

 

Keep: Dowie, Higgins, Kidd, Lyle, Russell, Hutton, Brownlie, Smith, Oliver, Hilson, Brownlie, 

 

Release: Millar, Conroy, Rutherford, Hooper

 

Undecided on Tapping and Jacobs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 77
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Raith Rovers

Under Contract: McGurn, Thomson, Davo, Bene, Toshney, Bates, Robertson, Callachan, Matthews, Vaughan, Stewart

Pre-contracts: Bobby Barr( From Morton) ; Jimmy Craigen( To Falkirk)

Loan returns: Panayiotou, Longridge, Hardie

Keep: Connolly, Barr, Mckeown

Punt: Petrie, McCord, Anderson, Thomas

Undecided: Cuthbert

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really ???

I'm not as much of a fan as everyone else is. He's easily replaced. He makes cracking saves all the time. But minutes later looks hesitant when coming out to collect a ball. I wouldn't be disappointed to see him stay. I just feel that there is better out there.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Under contract- Gaston, Tidser and Russell.

Keep: Pepper, Forbes, McKee, O'Ware, McCluskey (as back up), Scullion.

Punt: Miller, Lamie, Kilday, McNeil, MacDonald.

Loans returning: McManus, Johnstone, Gasparotto, Samuel and McMullan. Would keep all if possible, possibly keep Denny over McManus though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Qos

Under contract Marshall, Pickard, Thomson, Atkinson

 

Loan returns Harris, Murdoch

 

Keep: Dowie, Higgins, Kidd, Lyle, Russell, Hutton, Brownlie, Smith, Oliver, Hilson, Brownlie, 

 

Release: Millar, Conroy, Rutherford, Hooper

 

Undecided on Tapping and Jacobs

Some observers wouldn't even keep Brownlie the once.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Under contract- Gaston, Tidser and Russell.

Keep: Pepper, Forbes, McKee, O'Ware, McCluskey (as back up), Scullion.

Punt: Miller, Lamie, Kilday, McNeil, MacDonald.

Loans returning: McManus, Johnstone, Gasparotto, Samuel and McMullan. Would keep all if possible, possibly keep Denny over McManus though.

Would agree with this with maybe the exception of Kilday, hes decent enough at centre half, right back no way

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Going with my personal opinion without considering who will want to stay or go.

Keep:

Scott Gallacher

Davie Crawford

Andrew Wilson

Mark Williams

Jason Marr

Lewis Wilson

Ryan Hoggan

Holmes

Steven Hetherington

Aron Lynas

Scott Hynd

Release:

Kyle Mcausland

Burton Obrien

Liam Caddis

Eddie Fearns

Undecided:

Dougie Hill

Flannigan

Isaac Layne

Mitch Megginson

Loans ended:

Michael Duffy

Conor Mcmanus

Robbie Crawford

After a poor season it's maybe a weird one that I'd like to keep at least 11 of this year's squad but I feel we have a strong enough squad to bounce back up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Under contract- Gaston, Tidser and Russell.

Keep: Pepper, Forbes, McKee, O'Ware, McCluskey (as back up), Scullion.

Punt: Miller, Lamie, Kilday, McNeil, MacDonald.

Loans returning: McManus, Johnstone, Gasparotto, Samuel and McMullan. Would keep all if possible, possibly keep Denny over McManus though.

 

 

You've got five loans?

 

Not so much Morton as an SPFL Select.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dumbarton

Under contract: Brown (I think)

Loan returns: Lindsay, Waters, Heh, Walsh

Keep: Routledge (Probably away), Docherty, Buchanan, Fleming (If he can stay fit), Mc'Callum (maybe to loan out), Nade, Barr

Rid: Brown (hopefully we can reach an agreement), Taggart, Kirkpatrick

Undecided: Ewings, Saunders, Wright (Not sure if his legs have another year), Gallagher, Cawley. Would only Keep Cawley for centre attacking midfielder and Gallagher as a box to box mid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keep: Barr, Buchanan, Docherty, Wright (wouldn't be against a coaching role), Ewings (preferably as backup), Lindsay (if we are able to loan back), Routledge, Fleming, Nade.

Get rid: Brown (under contract unfortunately), Gallagher, Kirkpatrick, Heh (loan return).

Undecided: Taggart (haven't seen enough of him this season), Waters (decent enough option I feel but not had a great run of games), Walsh (not seen enough of him to judge), Cawley, Heffernan.

Wouldn't be against keeping McCallum and Hopkins to loan them out but I fear our initial excitement over McCallum was premature. He may only be 19 but at that age I'd be expecting him to make more of an impact, he's not a youth anymore. If you look across the leagues you will see plenty of 19 year olds progressing far better than Donald is. I keep reading 'he's not ready yet', if he's not ready then when will he be? Like I said at 19 I'd expect him to be close to being 'ready' but he looks a fair distance off it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keep: Barr, Buchanan, Docherty, Wright (wouldn't be against a coaching role), Ewings (preferably as backup), Lindsay (if we are able to loan back), Routledge, Fleming, Nade.

Get rid: Brown (under contract unfortunately), Gallagher, Kirkpatrick, Heh (loan return).

Undecided: Taggart (haven't seen enough of him this season), Waters (decent enough option I feel but not had a great run of games), Walsh (not seen enough of him to judge), Cawley, Heffernan.

Wouldn't be against keeping McCallum and Hopkins to loan them out but I fear our initial excitement over McCallum was premature. He may only be 19 but at that age I'd be expecting him to make more of an impact, he's not a youth anymore. If you look across the leagues you will see plenty of 19 year olds progressing far better than Donald is. I keep reading 'he's not ready yet', if he's not ready then when will he be? Like I said at 19 I'd expect him to be close to being 'ready' but he looks a fair distance off it.

Agree with your keeps except routledge who seems to be going anyway. I would keep tags and also Donald .

Donald hasn't been given proper chance but maybe managers see nothing in him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Raith Rovers

Under Contract: McGurn, Thomson, Davo, Bene, Toshney, Bates, Robertson, Callachan, Matthews, Vaughan, Stewart

Pre-contracts: Bobby Barr( From Morton) ; Jimmy Craigen( To Falkirk)

Loan returns: Panayiotou, Longridge, Hardie

Keep: Connolly, Barr, Mckeown

Punt: Petrie, McCord, Anderson, Thomas

Undecided: Cuthbert

What's happening with mccord? He seemed to start the season well and isn't featuring at all now. I'd happily take him at cappielow. Seems like the type of player our midfield is crying out for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Keep: Darren Barr, Gregor Buchanan, Mark Docherty, Scott Taggart, Frazer Wright, Jamie Ewings, Jon Routledge, Garry Fleming, Christian Nade

 

Punt: Grant Gallagher (very, very far), Steven Saunders, Mark Brown (2yr deal  :blink: ), Jordan Kirkpatrick, Kevin Cawley

 

Undecided: Donald McCallum (he's only a year younger than Jason Cummings for example, and I don't think he's progressed at all), Mikey Hopkins (never seen him play), Paul Heffernan (played about 3 games)

 

Loans:

 

Jamie Lindsay - Keep - Have no chance though

Calum Waters - Keep -Could be a handy player

Tom Walsh - Punt - Not done much

Kler Heh - Punt - Oh yeh, him. Forgot he existed tbh.

 

I might seem harsh on some, but I'd have Taggart at RB over the Mantis every single day - doubt he's on as big a wage either, Cawley's looked good in the middle, but if we aren't going to play him there then it's pointless keeping him.

 

This is all subject to change over the next 5 games or whatever. I'm very fickle. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...