Jump to content

Recommended Posts

33 minutes ago, D TOTAL said:

Personally I’m usually a supporter of Hamilton, but my god it’s getting harder and harder doesn’t help much we’ve got that absolute nightmare in Forster and Meekings as well has totally regressed im sure he’s not even played 50 games for us in I’m not sure how many seasons he’s been here

Think we’re goosed until January with our centrehalfs and keeper. That was 2 tamely hit shots that beat Hamilton for the 2nd and 3rd. Gowser got tore into him after the 3rd. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right, so since we are almost at the half way point, who's your player of the season so far?

For me, it comes down to:

Jordan Marshall

Jordan McGhee

Danny Johnson 

Kane Hemmings

Declan McDaid

Graham Dorrans

Paul McGowan

Reckon it'd be hard to make a case for anyone else.

I'll personally rule Dorrans out purely because he's not had as much of an impact as I'd hoped. That's maybe more on me than it is on him, I just thought he'd tear it up. He's clearly made a difference for us but I think there's still much, much more to come.

Hemmings has hit a bit of form of late and when he scores, he makes it look incredibly simple. Today's header was laid on a plate for him but it looked like he was almost taking the piss out of Dunfermline with the finish. Not enough service to win my vote so far.

Johnson is the same as above except I'm even more impressed with his excellent hold up play at times considering his frame.

Gowser is gowser. He'd be a sentimentalist pick. He's been the best he's been in several years for us but still goes anonymous too frequently.

McDaid - On his day, he's able to destroy teams but there's also days where you think he's a heartless shitebag. Typical winger, very infuriating but adds a lot to us.

Therefore, it's a dead heat between Marshall and McGhee for me. I was really underwhelmed when we signed Marshall due to the QotS opinion of him but he's our best LB since Lockwood IMO. Not the best defensively and he's likely to be tore apart by better teams - but f**k me, I've watched too much of Mackie.

McGhee - Mr consistent. Mr 7 out of 10 every week. He's holding our piss poor defense together. As much as I said Marshall is up there too, he's not great defensively and neither is Cammy. The less said of our other CH's and indeed, keeper, the better. Really like McGhee and I'd plump for him tbh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Last 20 minutes was infuriating - 4-1 up and they get a player red carded - we then proceed to fanny about with this slow as pish play.

Fucking stop doing it!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Ludo*1 said:

Right, so since we are almost at the half way point, who's your player of the season so far?

For me, it comes down to:

Jordan Marshall

Jordan McGhee

Danny Johnson 

Kane Hemmings

Declan McDaid

Graham Dorrans

Paul McGowan

Reckon it'd be hard to make a case for anyone else.

I'll personally rule Dorrans out purely because he's not had as much of an impact as I'd hoped. That's maybe more on me than it is on him, I just thought he'd tear it up. He's clearly made a difference for us but I think there's still much, much more to come.

Hemmings has hit a bit of form of late and when he scores, he makes it look incredibly simple. Today's header was laid on a plate for him but it looked like he was almost taking the piss out of Dunfermline with the finish. Not enough service to win my vote so far.

Johnson is the same as above except I'm even more impressed with his excellent hold up play at times considering his frame.

Gowser is gowser. He'd be a sentimentalist pick. He's been the best he's been in several years for us but still goes anonymous too frequently.

McDaid - On his day, he's able to destroy teams but there's also days where you think he's a heartless shitebag. Typical winger, very infuriating but adds a lot to us.

Therefore, it's a dead heat between Marshall and McGhee for me. I was really underwhelmed when we signed Marshall due to the QotS opinion of him but he's our best LB since Lockwood IMO. Not the best defensively and he's likely to be tore apart by better teams - but f**k me, I've watched too much of Mackie.

McGhee - Mr consistent. Mr 7 out of 10 every week. He's holding our piss poor defense together. As much as I said Marshall is up there too, he's not great defensively and neither is Cammy. The less said of our other CH's and indeed, keeper, the better. Really like McGhee and I'd plump for him tbh.

For me it's between McGhee, Marshall and Gowser, with Hemmings and Johnson with plenty of room to gain ground on them. Cammy might have a shout too, some good performances under him this season, but basic errors mar his record.

I struggle to think what McGhee has done wrong so far this season. Consistency is a rare jewel we get to experience, and Jordo's just that. Marshall also remarkably consistent this season.

For me the pick is Gowser so far though. You call it a sentimentalist pick, yet he's never won the award. All these years of disappointment and he's up for it every week. Very positive player on the pitch and we lose our fight whenever we're without him. He's found his form once more this season which was desperately needed to counteract our largely defensive MF.

Of course it'll be Alan Forrest once he signs here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Ludo*1 said:

Right, so since we are almost at the half way point, who's your player of the season so far?

For me, it comes down to:

Jordan Marshall

Jordan McGhee

Danny Johnson 

Kane Hemmings

Declan McDaid

Graham Dorrans

Paul McGowan

Reckon it'd be hard to make a case for anyone else.

I'll personally rule Dorrans out purely because he's not had as much of an impact as I'd hoped. That's maybe more on me than it is on him, I just thought he'd tear it up. He's clearly made a difference for us but I think there's still much, much more to come.

Hemmings has hit a bit of form of late and when he scores, he makes it look incredibly simple. Today's header was laid on a plate for him but it looked like he was almost taking the piss out of Dunfermline with the finish. Not enough service to win my vote so far.

Johnson is the same as above except I'm even more impressed with his excellent hold up play at times considering his frame.

Gowser is gowser. He'd be a sentimentalist pick. He's been the best he's been in several years for us but still goes anonymous too frequently.

McDaid - On his day, he's able to destroy teams but there's also days where you think he's a heartless shitebag. Typical winger, very infuriating but adds a lot to us.

Therefore, it's a dead heat between Marshall and McGhee for me. I was really underwhelmed when we signed Marshall due to the QotS opinion of him but he's our best LB since Lockwood IMO. Not the best defensively and he's likely to be tore apart by better teams - but f**k me, I've watched too much of Mackie.

McGhee - Mr consistent. Mr 7 out of 10 every week. He's holding our piss poor defense together. As much as I said Marshall is up there too, he's not great defensively and neither is Cammy. The less said of our other CH's and indeed, keeper, the better. Really like McGhee and I'd plump for him tbh.

I’ll go for McGhee although Marshall has been a huge loss to the side when he was out injured. Defo out of those 2 imo.
 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gowser easily. Funny seeing as I am his biggest boo boy up until this season. Him and his non existent hairline would be in my starting XI for the rest of the season. 

We really missed him when he was out. Only one that makes any positive movement in midfield and goes for every throw in.

Edited by Crawford
Bowser 😂

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Granny Danger said:

I’m assuming today’s result will lead to a huge demand for away tickets for the derby.

there will be more demand than there was when you c***s were in the shit and bailed out pronto.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Meeniedee said:

there will be more demand than there was when you c***s were in the shit and bailed out pronto.

So you’re agreeing with me.  Good to know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
there will be more demand than there was when you c***s were in the shit and bailed out pronto.
Be lucky to flog 1000+ for the Up Derby IMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Granny Danger said:

So you’re agreeing with me.  Good to know.

no not really...boys will be there regardless on how shit we've been unlike you and your mob who only turn out in derbies when you smell blood....doon derby is proof o that ane.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Broke our 7-game (and nearly decade long) winless streak against the Pars today, which can only be good. Also the second team in the league we've defeated this season that doesn't start with an 'A'.

Progress.

Edited by RossBFaeDundee

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Imagine if we could punt Forster, Hamilton and Byrne...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Hamilton get some rough treatment and don’t think he’s nearly as bad as made out to be. Scott Bain used to throw goal in regularly (did he ever save a free kick to his left?) but some fans still think he’s the greatest thing since sliced bread. Hamilton has made a lot of big saves in games which have saved us points. He still makes mistakes, but for a keeper he’s still young.

There are more important areas of the field we need to be concentrating on replacing before the goalkeeper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Ludo*1 said:

Right, so since we are almost at the half way point, who's your player of the season so far?

For me, it comes down to:

Jordan Marshall

Jordan McGhee

Danny Johnson 

Kane Hemmings

Declan McDaid

Graham Dorrans

Paul McGowan

Reckon it'd be hard to make a case for anyone else.

I'll personally rule Dorrans out purely because he's not had as much of an impact as I'd hoped. That's maybe more on me than it is on him, I just thought he'd tear it up. He's clearly made a difference for us but I think there's still much, much more to come.

Hemmings has hit a bit of form of late and when he scores, he makes it look incredibly simple. Today's header was laid on a plate for him but it looked like he was almost taking the piss out of Dunfermline with the finish. Not enough service to win my vote so far.

Johnson is the same as above except I'm even more impressed with his excellent hold up play at times considering his frame.

Gowser is gowser. He'd be a sentimentalist pick. He's been the best he's been in several years for us but still goes anonymous too frequently.

McDaid - On his day, he's able to destroy teams but there's also days where you think he's a heartless shitebag. Typical winger, very infuriating but adds a lot to us.

Therefore, it's a dead heat between Marshall and McGhee for me. I was really underwhelmed when we signed Marshall due to the QotS opinion of him but he's our best LB since Lockwood IMO. Not the best defensively and he's likely to be tore apart by better teams - but f**k me, I've watched too much of Mackie.

McGhee - Mr consistent. Mr 7 out of 10 every week. He's holding our piss poor defense together. As much as I said Marshall is up there too, he's not great defensively and neither is Cammy. The less said of our other CH's and indeed, keeper, the better. Really like McGhee and I'd plump for him tbh.

It’s Forster for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, RossBFaeDundee said:

Broke our 7-game (and nearly decade long) winless streak against the Pars today, which can only be good. Also the second team in the league we've defeated this season that doesn't start with an 'A'.

Progress.

You couldn’t beat a team that started with an ‘A’ last week though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scott Bain is still revered as he was a fucking excellent goalkeeper. Once he downed tools his performances dropped but he won us far more points - at a higher level. 

Jack Hamilton is the epitome of a footballer nowadays. Stature you would dream of having in your goalkeeper but he fails in almost every single basic aspect of goalkeeping. 

He's made a few good saves? Good for Jack. Shame he's thrown in about quadruple that. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Player of the season so far ?
Sitting in 5th
Really shit keeper
Defence is awful.
Midfield in general is poor
Strikers so far this season have been non existent. ( yesterday was a yay from me , however I didn't witness it :-( )

Marshall has been missing and we miss him when we have to rely on other shite in his position. So on that basis I will go for him.
Left backs in recent times I reckon have been alright.

Partick next:-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...