Jump to content

Another Hamilton youngster goes on ! Burnley 5 mil bid for Mccarth


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 115
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Let's look at it "scientifically"

See what youth systems have produced players called up for Scotland last season:

9 players:

Celtic (David Marshall, Charlie Mulgrew, Andrew Robertson, Barry Bannan, Chris Burke, Shaun Maloney, Scott Fox, Gary Caldwell, James Forrest)

7 players

Rangers RIP (Allan McGregor, Grant Hanley, Alan Hutton, Chris Burke, Ross McCormack, Steven Naismith, Charlie Adam)

5 players

Hibs (Steven Whittaker, Scott Brown, Leigh Griffiths, Kevin Thomson, Steven Fletcher)

4 players

Kilmarnock (Cammy Bell, Steven Naismith, Craig Samson, Kris Boyd)

3 players

Livingston (Leigh Griffiths, Graham Dorrans, Robert Snodgrass)

2 players

Clyde (Gordon Greer, Craig Bryson)

Dundee (Craig Forsyth, Charlie Adam)

Hearts (Christophe Berra, Lee Wallace)

Motherwell (Mark Reynolds, Steven Hammell)

Queen of the South (Cammy Bell, Grant Hanley)

1 player

Aberdeen (Peter Pawlett)

Annan Athletic (Cammy Bell)

Ayr Utd (Craig Conway)

Dundee Utd (Stuart Armstrong)

Falkirk (Leigh Griffiths)

Hamilton Accies (James McArthur)

ICT (Stuart Armstrong)

Queens Park (Andrew Robertson)

Ross County (Gary Mackay-Steven)

Well done Accies: on a par with Annan

Your list is bizarre. Bannan joined Aston Villa at 14, how does that make him a Celtic product?

You also include numerous players as being produced at more than one club, despite understanding why you've done that, its idiocy to suggest Robertson was both a Celtic and Queens Park product considering he left Celtic at 14 and spent his youth being coached at Queens Park. You've done it with quite a few players who clearly weren't "products" of clubs who had them for a couple of years in their early teens and released them before they'd turned 15

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's look at it "scientifically"

See what youth systems have produced players called up for Scotland last season:

9 players:

Celtic (David Marshall, Charlie Mulgrew, Andrew Robertson, Barry Bannan, Chris Burke, Shaun Maloney, Scott Fox, Gary Caldwell, James Forrest)

Yeah, I think it's stretching it if we make claim for some of they players

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...