Big Fifer 1,225 Report post Posted May 16 18 minutes ago, sirscottyoung said: Yeah sitting with GK’s Brett Def Dunsmore Dunlop Pat Mid Hunter Davidson Agnew Bell Watt Denholm Att Smith Wallace Dowds 13 signed. Hopefully a new keeper. Hope Watson and sparky re sign A new CB Another striker And then our team is perfect and ready to go Going into the season with just two signed centre halves would be suicidal. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sirscottyoung 658 Report post Posted May 16 Going into the season with just two signed centre halves would be suicidal. Not fancy getting a loan in at CB like when we had big Jason Kerr 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DDLL 21 Report post Posted May 16 Watson will be doing pre season, so another signing and I think Higgins will be back 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bayviewboy 222 Report post Posted May 16 Looks like we’ve lost out on bringing Fash back to Bayview. Need another striker to add competition up front. Do we go for a young loan striker similar to Rory Currie or do we try to sign one on a permanent deal ? A few that may be available - Michael Moffat (Ayr) Craig Moore (Ayr) Blair Henderson (Edinburgh City) Dylan Mackin (Stirling Albion) Chris Duggan (Raith Rovers) Kris Doolan (Patrick Thistle) Greig Spence (Arbroath) Leighton McIntosh (Airdrie) Andy Jackson (Brechin City)Moffat - always been a big fan, especially when played just behind the striker/s. Maybe coming towards the end of his career, but a clever player who could still do a job at our level.Moore - small, mobile with an eye for goal, probably will want to stay full time but maybe worth an enquiry.Henderson - had a fantastic season and probably looking for full time.Mackin - a realistic target I would think. Big and powerful. If fully fit I think he could be a great addition.Duggan - would love to see a fully fit Chris back at Bayview. Question marks over his injury issues but maybe part time as opposed to full time may help resolve these issues.Dolan - would be a great addition but highly unlikely as he will no doubt be looking for full time - we can dream !Spence - a couple of years ago, I would have been delighted to have him at Bayview but he seems to have lost his way after returning to Starks Park and has struggled to make an impact at Gayfield.McIntosh - always been impressed by him, especially his work rate and pace. Been offered full time at Airdrie I believe but depending on his job away from football, he may want to stay part time.Jackson - another who seems to have lost his way a bit, but maybe just that he wasn’t getting decent service in a poor Brechin team. Knows his way to goal. Maybe just needing a new challenge.To be honest, any of the above would be good additions to our squad and would signal a real intent to get to at least the play offs next season in what looks likely to be an even tougher challenge next season.In terms of a goalkeeper to challenge Brett Long, we could do worse than trying to get Ben McKenzie who we had on loan from St Johnstone, before he went to Airdrie last season. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sirscottyoung 658 Report post Posted May 17 I felt that Ben McKenzie was absolutely shit at us, and not any better at Airdrie. I don’t feel that he would push Brett any more than Terry and McDowell did. If he strikers Duggan and Mackin surely the only likely targets from that. Jackson will stay at an Angus team I think. Rest would be an unreal coup and great show of intent if we got one as you say! 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sammytroot 177 Report post Posted May 17 With Kane and Meggat definitely away ,and Watson,Higgins,and Docherty out of contract whilst Murdoch's loan has expired, surely defenders MUST be the priority. i do not consider Dunsmore to be a right- back , more of a wing-back or right mid-fielder, and consequently I feel we have only Dunlop and Slattery as defenders. If Watson was to return that would be fantastic news as he gives us pace and height in defence, whilst his presence brings out the best in Dunsmore further up the field. Personally I would have no problems with Higgins, Docherty, and Murdoch re-signing. The main problem towards the end of last season was the defensive midfielders in front of them. Irrespective, we do need a big, strong centre half with aerial ability to defend and attack at corners. A few years ago Gary Naysmith tried to sign Ryan Mc Geever from at the time Queen's Park. He has just been released by Brechin. With regard to the second keeper, I must admit that I was not impressed with Ben McKenzie . A few years ago we had a local keeper Jordan Millar , who eventually played for Montrose . No idea where he is, but my recollection was that he was tall and liked to come out for corners. The nucleus of a good squad is there at the moment- a few defenders and hopefully we will hit the ground running. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lichtie78 1,520 Report post Posted May 17 With Kane and Meggat definitely away ,and Watson,Higgins,and Docherty out of contract whilst Murdoch's loan has expired, surely defenders MUST be the priority. i do not consider Dunsmore to be a right- back , more of a wing-back or right mid-fielder, and consequently I feel we have only Dunlop and Slattery as defenders. If Watson was to return that would be fantastic news as he gives us pace and height in defence, whilst his presence brings out the best in Dunsmore further up the field. Personally I would have no problems with Higgins, Docherty, and Murdoch re-signing. The main problem towards the end of last season was the defensive midfielders in front of them. Irrespective, we do need a big, strong centre half with aerial ability to defend and attack at corners. A few years ago Gary Naysmith tried to sign Ryan Mc Geever from at the time Queen's Park. He has just been released by Brechin. With regard to the second keeper, I must admit that I was not impressed with Ben McKenzie . A few years ago we had a local keeper Jordan Millar , who eventually played for Montrose . No idea where he is, but my recollection was that he was tall and liked to come out for corners. The nucleus of a good squad is there at the moment- a few defenders and hopefully we will hit the ground running.Sure Jordan Millar is at Lochee United 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Big Fifer 1,225 Report post Posted May 17 Agree with the above about the defence, but I'd rather Higgins wasn't signed. If he's the answer I'm not sure what the question was. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
GableEnder21 179 Report post Posted May 17 (edited) 36 minutes ago, Lichtie78 said: Sure Jordan Millar is at Lochee United Correct, that's where he went in Jan. Edited May 17 by GableEnder21 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sirscottyoung 658 Report post Posted May 17 Scott Fox released by Ross County. Surely going to one of top 7? 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
smuggfifer 467 Report post Posted May 17 Gary Naysmith also tried to sign "Corrie" McCormack from Bowhill, but he had the chance of international football with the Scotland amateur team. Big strong CB and good organiser as well. Wonder if he is still playing at that level? 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
grumswall 1,473 Report post Posted May 17 Gary Naysmith also tried to sign "Corrie" McCormack from Bowhill, but he had the chance of international football with the Scotland amateur team. Big strong CB and good organiser as well. Wonder if he is still playing at that level?He went junior after he had the trial with you but I'm sure he ended up back at Bowhill. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Angusfifer 1,078 Report post Posted May 17 Bowhill supplied us with our best ever centre-half... 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
McBrian 6 Report post Posted May 17 6 minutes ago, Angusfifer said: Bowhill supplied us with our best ever centre-half... I would dispute that and maybe Leven Royals would too :-) 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ewan_fife 627 Report post Posted May 17 Bowhill supplied us with our best ever centre-half...Big Julen from bowhill? 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sirscottyoung 658 Report post Posted May 17 Bowhill supplied us with our best ever centre-half... Was it not Rowantree that did that? 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Gordon EF 3,609 Report post Posted May 17 (edited) 1 hour ago, sirscottyoung said: Was it not Rowantree that did that? Frew T'Pastille was one of Willie Atchison's best signings. Edited May 17 by Gordon EF 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bayviewboy 222 Report post Posted May 17 McGeever was excellent at Queens Park - a real no nonsense Centre Half who would add height to our team. He’s struggled at Brechin with a few injuries I believe. If fully fit, he’d be a good addition.Not sure what is happening with Andy Ryan at Dunfermline. He has struggled to get game time. Maybe better suited to being part time. Don’t see why we shouldn’t aim high as after all Fash was prepared to drop from the Championship to come to us before allegedly dropping further down the leagues. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Passionate 60 Report post Posted May 17 13 hours ago, sirscottyoung said: I felt that Ben McKenzie was absolutely shit at us, and not any better at Airdrie. I don’t feel that he would push Brett any more than Terry and McDowell did. If he strikers Duggan and Mackin surely the only likely targets from that. Jackson will stay at an Angus team I think. Rest would be an unreal coup and great show of intent if we got one as you say! To be fair Ben McKenzie did fine at Airdrie, Came to the club when Scott Gallagher blew his knee in the first league game, his replacement David Hutton came in and did ok, then he got injured and Ben played a good number of games and was arguably better than the two before him, The one notable mistake was a poor kick out against yourselves, and the rest of the season was spent riding the pine.. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sirscottyoung 658 Report post Posted May 17 To be fair Ben McKenzie did fine at Airdrie, Came to the club when Scott Gallagher blew his knee in the first league game, his replacement David Hutton came in and did ok, then he got injured and Ben played a good number of games and was arguably better than the two before him, The one notable mistake was a poor kick out against yourselves, and the rest of the season was spent riding the pine..A poor kick out? We used to sit and count how many times he DIDNT kick it out the park 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
