Manwithnoball

I would go different Dabrowski Logan Brydon East Hendrie Wilson Cochrane Gibson Connelly Todd Paton If no Wilson then McGrory if no Connelly then Kabia

What would your starting 11 be if everyone was fit?

Agreed but he is definitely better holding in midfield but Wilson is better option. Both have poor injury records though so worth keeping both.

I think he will be out the door this month tbh.

Have to say our fans were excellent last night the signing and the goading of Accies fans was brilliant. Please bring this atmosphere to Palmerston as that is like a library just now

In your opinion did he deserve that 5 mins before half time he was not doing anything that merited that.

Can you tell me in you opinion what Todd and Paton done well. In my opinion Todd holds onto the ball for far to long and lost possession countless times and so many misplaced passes. Paton was bullied for mist of the game and did not give us anything on the night. Cochrane held our midfield together as Todd and Murray were all over the place. Wilson has to get back asap. Gibson has to play further up the park and take the defensive responsibilities away from the young lad and he will thrive. On the night we had a great goalkeeping performance to keep us in it. We lacked any invention in the final third at all. Irving works hard and got his goal but he is not really the answer for us upfront. Ruth obviously now is not in Bartley's eyes after straying him for last 3 games. I think our best option would be to play Connelly, Gibson and Paton as a front 3. As for the defence Brydon and Logan will come into the side. Would like to see a new left back as well but getting greedy now.

Hooked. Did not think he was doing that bad but that is one to destroy a young lads confidence.

Totally agree with this but Todd really has to up his game he must have gave away possession so many times last night. Holding onto the ball and getting it taken off him.

I totally read it wrong

Brydon played for Hibs B, Logan played for Hearts B and Kabia played for Morton in the earlier rounds so unavailable to play on Tuesday.

I would expect that as well. But well within their rights to sit tight rather than go part time. Reilly still has another year on his contract. I take it Bartley knows him really well from Livingston so that helped make up his mind. Rico has been a little bit unlucky don't think there is much between him and Hendrie. McKenna has to be replaced to many mistakes he needs to go and play his proper CB position.

Murray should have been aware of his surroundings and even put his body across the defender to even possibly get a foul out of it at worst if not score but done neither.

100 per cent agree Connelly is a better attacking option than McGrory. I just think Murray is not a better option than him. It is a game of opinions and that is mine. When Connelly and Wilson come back I don't see McGrory or Murray in the starting 11 going by the way the manager is setting up his team. But wil have to be kept in case of injuries to Wilson or Cochrane.

Bartley has obviously made to decision to let the 3 guys go and the fact he said in the interview let's everyone know. He is obviously working with the other guys who are all mostly playing for their futures. As he sees something he can work with. The signings of Dabrowski and Brydon have made us stronger defensively and hopefully Logan also hits the ground running. Kabia has to up his work rate for me. Bartley is ruthless as McGrory found out yesterday by being hooked at half time unfortunately he put Murray on for me is any empty shirt. When we get Wilson and Connelly back we will definitely be stronger and the fact we are only 6 points of the play offs and a semi final in the cup on Tuesday. Keep the momentum going into the Kelty game in a fortnight before a tough game against Dunfermline.

Here is our highlights

100 per cent looked fitter.

Have to agre best game of the season for him. Impressed by Brydon.

He gives us actually nothing lazy in attack lazy in defence. Bartley gets frustrated on the side. I like his approach he will improve us without a doubt. He took McGrory off despite us controlling first half and replaced him with Murray. I like the fact he changes things but he must surt see that he offers nothing. I have to ask myself what he sees in Ruth that he does not see in Reilly.

Bartley has identified all our issues very quickly. His next objective is to get shot of Murray. Total waste of a jersey. The sooner we get Wilson and Connelly back the better

Think the good thing is Bartley has identified our problem areas. We have not had a right back and McKenna has been poor in not his proper position. New GK new right back new centre back and work with what we have till end of season as most are out of contract. Don't see many changes tomorrow except maybe Logan replacing McKechnie and Kabia replacing Ruth. Wilson will still be out but when fit it will be him and another in centre midfield. Glad East is back and Brydon and only one McKay in the team.

Who is going to take them?

Don't really remember him from Kelty games. But a proper right back

Who played well for us today?