buddie06smfc

Agreed on Hemming, he’s been fine but nothing special. Recently, he’s been a disaster waiting to happen at corners flying out clattering into anyone in hope of a foul. He’s done a job but I wouldn't consider him long term, even if we could afford it, and definitely can improve on him. Nowhere near player of the season, Gogic and Kiltie are the front runners IMO. I would probably plump for Kiltie at that, I think he’s been great this season.

He was blowing out his arse after 20 minutes against Motherwell, which is a new record for him. Not sure I’d be rushing him back, unless Flynn is the alternative option at right back, given the importance of next few games. Certainly not against Maeda at Parkhead. No idea if he is injured again but I wouldn’t count on him again for the remainder of the season. As good as he is he’s no use if blowing for the majority of the game.

Hatate is class. Can see why Celtic were desperate to rush him back into the team.

Muir bottled it from giving Sibbick a second yellow for the foul on the halfway line. Game was pretty rubbish, not helped by the wind.

No sign of Bierith getting back into the Motherwell team? Milking it a bit now.

Does this MacDonald guy just retreat to his own goal line every time the ball crosses the half way line? Hopeless.

It’s bad enough when there’s a smattering of us across the top tier, open the full thing give people the leg room they deserve. Or make it safe standing because it sure as heck isn’t safe sitting.

Good to see McGrath was in the right frame of mind to play a game of football finally. Attempting to scuff the penalty just about the only thing he could muster up. p***k.

Will every outfield player score? Probably.

I thought elvis got banned from here last week?

Curtis Main too. If we were being reactionary and basing decisions off tonight, majority of the team would have their contract torn up before getting on the bus. Tanser in particular.

Would be a no brainer IMO. We wouldn’t be able to afford a player of his quality outright so why not take advantage of a loan when as you say he improves us as a team.

Oh, it is. Or was it that Dutch mob you bring along who were responsible? Won’t do much for the friendship if they’re getting the blame.

Quite the brass neck for Motherwell fans to be bemoaning stadium damage.

PTSD from dealing with Rae every day for 3 months. Took around 6 months to recover from.

Tanser’s was a shot for the 2nd fortunately deflected off a St Johnstone player as it was going approx 6 miles wide.

St Johnstone similar to Livi I’d say, little redeeming features about their play and team. Worryingly for them though it looks like Livi might be able to muster up a couple of meaningful attacks in game. Kwon robbed by the ref and whatever idiot in the VAR booth. Mandron got the Curtis Main treatment from the ref today, was getting manhandled every header and got very little all game. It was mostly against Liam Gordon who gave us a timely reminder of how rotten he is. A modern day John Potter.

If Mandron is dropped from the team, particularly for Ayunga which would be madness, we’ll lose. Or Olusanya for that matter. The only one of the front 3 who stands to drop out would be Scott most likely for Jamieson. Baccus and Bolton should probably be in line for getting back in the team.

He does go down too easily and frequently. Probably has a reputation that proceeds him already. Sangare did similar in the first half in an attempt to get Elvis sent off when he wasn’t touched. It seems to be the way these days unfortunately.

Bit of an overreaction to today. Was a disaster of a result but we weren't all that bad and still created chances, would be more worrying if we just passed it about with no purpose. I think Jamieson made an impact when he came on, albeit against a pretty poor side. I just hope this won't restart striker roulette, I think the right wing position is up for grabs but the other two we haven't better options than Kiltie and Mandron. Could've added 37 mins on as injury time today and we wouldn't have scored. It was just one of those days.

He gave every 50/50 Dundee’s way. There were 2 clear bookings for Shaughnessy, one before the Bolton challenge. I think his reluctance to give Shaughnessy a deserved booking compared to couldn’t get the card out quick enough for Bolton was half the frustration. His stubbornness when it came to the red card summed up his performance. He was atrocious all night and not helped by the linesman on either side as well. If only referees had a league table as well and could get relegated. McLean would be the Brechin equivalent. Plummet through the tables in consecutive seasons.

Routine win against diddies as expected. Dundee did well to get rid of Cammy Kerr only to replace him with someone just as bad in No.3. James Scott had the beating of him everytime. Wasn’t the worst on the pitch though - Steven McLean comfortably the worst. Shockingly poor performance. Should’ve won by more. Two games in a row Hemming has had 0 saves to make. He must be bored out his mind.

Needs more still images.