This transfer window has thrown up more questions than answers.
Have we improved the team and have we improved the squad?
It was as Tommy said 1 out 1 in.
Vihmann out McCart in, McCart has to be an improvement in the squad. Will he improve the team? He will have to be better than Kerr or Gordon to do that. Tommy may play 3 at the back and that may improve the team. But if it was his intention to do that why sign a winger when we already have 4. We are now back to 5 wingers and Tommy will now play a team without wingers, if he does it is a strange signing.
Callachan out Butcher in. This is a wait and see Butcher in on the mend from injury it so may take him some time to get up to speed.
Kennedy out Jones in, I cannot see Jones being an improvement on Kennedy.
The squad may be slightly better but the team is poorer for the loss of Kennedy.