Let's play devil's advocate, talbot didn't do there due diligence on the player, did the player go wait a minute I have already played in this competition or did he say nothing because of the honour of playing for Auchinleck, when Talbot went to the sfa for the emergency loan and told them the players name did they not say no you can't play him he's cup tied as iam sure it would flag up on their player tracking system what he had already played in. Just my opinion might be away off the mark.