Jump to content

YassinMoutaouakil

Gold Members
  • Posts

    11,719
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    9

Posts posted by YassinMoutaouakil

  1. Something I thought was very odd was the way we started pretty brightly- after about 10 minutes I thought we'd win comfortably- and then seemed to remember that we'd had two weeks off and suddenly the passes became slacker and everybody looked a bit off the pace. 

     

    I'm not saying Kettlewell is blameless but I think central defence right now is more of a personnel issue than a tactical one. I like Casey, Bevis, SOD and McGinn individually but hopefully next season we're only playing at most two of them at any given time. Tbf I was amazed Bevis didn't give away a penalty at any point in that second half as there were a few situations where that's the usual outcome.

  2. 19 minutes ago, Black_and_White_Stripes said:

    🤣 No wonder. One of my greatest recent footballing memories is that 4-4 draw in the Cup, where we won on penalties. We've pinched your manager and cherry-picked your best players and you've yet to score against us this season. I can see where you're coming from, pal. 

    Yes it's a shame what this season has done to my psyche. Most St Mirren fans on here will remember that until recently I had a big soft spot for the Buddies and spent a lot of time over on your thread but this three-game winless run has really soured all that.

  3. 1 minute ago, Desp said:

    Which is horrendous, and is the whole point at the centre of all this.  VAR is diminishing the enjoyment of fans at the game, i.e the c***s who put the money into it.

    Aye I'd rather no VAR. I just think putting the onus on teams to challenge individual decisions (within reason) would be a lot less intrusive and occasionally a bit of a laugh rather than the current setup where somebody sits in a room and looks for a reason to rule every goal out.

  4. Just now, Desp said:

    Pretty much every single goal would be challenged by the opposing team.  You say each team has two challenges per half, for example?  How often do teams lose four goals a game?  You'd challenge every goal against you and hopefully get lucky now and again.

    That'd be a great thing for the fans in the crowd...

    Feels like this basically happens now. I'm sure in the County 3-3 game all six goals got checked for something and obviously all stood.

  5. 2 minutes ago, VincentGuerin said:

    So, what happens when a team challenges a red card for a bad tackle.

    Whether it's a red or a yellow involves an element of subjectivity. So, the team challenging could be "right" and the referee could be "right".

    Say the referee sticks with his decision. Do the challenging team lose a challenge? What if they are then the victims of a horrendous injustice that they can't challenge (as they've used their challenges up), even though their first challenge was "right"?

    And if they don't lose a challenge if the referee sticks with his decision, then everyone just challenges everything.

    It doesn't work.

    I mean I'd be happy to do away with VAR generally and just let the referee decide on the pitch. But in this Challenge system I devised ten minutes ago I'd still just let the referee be God and whatever he decides is "right" and if you lose a YassinChallenge then tough shit.

×
×
  • Create New...