David W

I see Livingston have released Carlo Pignatiello, who is one of the two Dumbarton players from last season that I would have been interested in. If you have him and Cuddihy then you have two players who can play at this level and cover three or four positions to a good standard.

Somebody get DL back from his holiday pronto.

Do ICT often play a back three? They don't look like they know what they're doing.

He's speaking like a man who has the experience of winning 5 Champions League titles.

I'd keep Livingstone as he played well for chunks of last season and is a player with some technical ability and pace. I think it would also benefit him to stay and get another 30-40 games under his belt as he's already lost a season at Cove. However, the fact is, he's a left-back that is awful at left-back. In terms of actual defending, the difference between him and Docherty was night and day.

Fair play to QP, whatever you say it was rubbish for you lot missing the celebrations last year. Well deserved over the two games.

And Jay Cantley. Don't forget Jay Cantley.

If I were Dumbarton and I'd just signed Ally Love, then I'd play him up front. He'll work hard off a main striker and score some goals. No doubt he's good around a dressing room as well and he'll engage with your support. If he's being played out wide then he'll contribute absolutely nothing on the pitch.

These two will now be frantically trying to work out if Inverness can bring more players on for the shoot-out.

Bits of quality in the match were the Edinburgh goalkeeper, the Edinburgh goal and Owen Moxon. Annan will regret not going for the kill in the second part of the first half I reckon, Edinburgh were all over the place.

Edinburgh 'keeper has more than made up for his error at the second goal, a couple of tremendous saves.

Since going to 2-2, Annan have probably still been the better team but have proceeded to end almost every attack with a big punt straight to the goalkeeper, or straight out of play. Edinburgh have been absolutely shocking so far.

It's safe to say a second goal for Annan has been coming. The Edinburgh goalkeeper, who I think has had a decent season, has had a nightmare there.

There you go, exactly what the game needed. A very soft penalty kick award.

No, we won 2-0. I'm sure we scored the second really late on and there was chaos with the crowd getting in. My abiding memory of the game was that we had moved to a 442 after starting the season playing a back three. The Adam handball was when Roberts was in charge.