I'd be disappointed if we let Keating's go, there's not been many performances where I've been genuinely unhappy with him, normally gives it his best shot. Could probably put Carrick in this bracket, not reliable enough to be the 'guaranteed' goalscorer that we need but definitely good enough to be used if we go for 2 up top/as an impact sub.
Fair enough that we've been up front about his playing time next season though.