To settle an argument between me and BluebirdTon, don't let me down p&b, Football Manager is obviously better!

This is like doing a survey of all the religions on the planet to see which is the most popular, and holding the survey in a mosque.

Farce written all over it.

I refuse to accept the results no matter what.

They can't be compared. Two completely different types of games. Pro evo and Fifa can be compared or champ man and FM can but you can't mix and match.

FOOTBALL MANAGER!!
Fifa is pish.

They're football games, but both just come from different perspectives, of course you can compare them.

Even Fifa is better than Pro evo.

From what I remember from the msn converstion five minutes ago, I was arguing that Fifa is more popular than Fm - and I gathered that the purpose of this thread would be to see that.

But as I said, this isn't a justified place to hold such a vote.

ones a strategy game which takes alot of time to get into whereas the other one is a game you can just pick up and play. their is virtually no similarities.
and also Fifa is not better than Pro Evo.

YER BARRED !

In which case i agree with you. FM will be more popular on here as the vast majority of people like football but for people with little knowledge of it Fifa is obviously going to be their preferred choice.

Exactly.

Thread closed - please.

Because one person agrees with you it doesn't mean you win!

FM is better, i'll still buy Fifa 09 for PS2, but only because Accies are in it this year, the same reason I'm buying the pannini sticket book

as much as i love fifa, fm just makes it for me most addictive game on the planet

I'm not claiming victory in this debate.

I'm claiming victory in the fact that this a totally facial place to hold such a contest.

You just can't handle the truth

I resent that comment on the fact that I look nothing like that! For a start that diagram clearly doesn't have a double chin!

Fifa is better in my opinion. Simply because if your having a load of folk round it's great to sit down and play Fifa where as with FM you need to have quiet time in my opinion and think like a real manager would.

Will buy both games though.

well if you want to be picky then fifa far outsells FM but Ithink its not a very good comparison ... I mean what exactley are you compring them on?

Football Manager is for wanky wee Premiership loving fanboys.

FACT.

Fifa Manager is vastly underrated.

Especially given they have unofficial coders with some fantastic 3D patches.

You going to buy the town because they're in it every year?

Do you have stats ?

...like Accies1 requested when I said that !

Fifa is the more popular game however anyone who plays both would clearly see that for good gaming FM is better.

On regards, to the Fifa vs Pro Evo argument I have felt that Pro Evo has simply outclassed Fifa in every department apart from perhaps graphics or the fact Fifa has real team names & badges, until Fifa 08 however. Fifa took it up a level and Pro Evo just slid along there usual standard if not dropping there standards a notch or two.

EDIT TO ADD:

http://www.videogamer.com/news/23-10-2007-6730.html

Please take into consideration that Fifa is more of a console game yet still snatches 2nd place on Football Manager's predominantary platform.

Pro evo should be included in this as it kicks fifas buttocks but im not sure if its better than football manager.

You're talking our your arse! Pre evo is shit, don't see why everyone likes it so much!

seeing as 'everyone likes it so much' do you not think you might be the one talking out their arse?


pro evo >>> Fifa.

I'm confused. Are you talking about Fifa Manager or Fifa?

Have to agree