QUOTE (cityred @ Sep 22 2008, 15:01)

[quote name='BrechinCityFC' date='Sep 22 2008, 12:47' post='2794514']
Yeah you were probably more impressed by our inept manager taking King off and bringing on Calum Smith. Can't believe we have Michael Paton on loan from Aberdeen again as he never impressed me during his time here last year and didn't again yesterday. He walked straight into the team ahead of a lad that tried his hardest last week and succeeded in turning a game to win us 2 points). I must admit I was totally shocked to turn up at the ground on Sunday and see Micahel Paton there, and even more shocked to see him starting. Especially considering all the comments from our Manager about the lad being in contention for a start. What sort of message does that send out to our player?
I find the above post must be put on from someone that was at a different game from me. Paton was exceptional, particularly in the first half. And to be honest, Calum Smith made little impression when he came on against two huge defenders, as he can't handle the physical side of the game well.
Your description of Paton is well wide of the mark, especially when you consider he has been handed a long-term club from an SPL club, and is a regulat at under-age level for the international team. Your ramblings are either those of someone who is a nut case, but certainly some one who knows SFA abouot the game.
I meant to say I thoroughly agree with Steve's earlier post. An excellent game and you only had to look at teh way Scott Walker struggled to get near Paton in the first half, to see how good his contribution was.
As for our manager being inept, he's so inept, we're two points off the top of the league and competing against sides with much biiger budgets and much bigger fan bases.
Get a grip FFS!
Okay he is at an SPL club but can't get a game for a team that can't score goals..so is on loan to us. Doesn't have a good goals scoring record, compare that with games started against C. Smith record for us. Yeah Scott walker was having a torrid time against him...only made one bad challenge on him and Paton was never seen again for the rest of the match, so he didn't exactly cope too well, also in the first half when Scott Walker managed to out sprint him. FACT. To say C. Smith can't handle the physical side of the game..maybe thats because as soon as we put him on we lumped the ball up to him to challenge for 50-50 headers, instead if playing from the back. Paton neve challenged for a header all day..but then people will argue that thats not his game.
Maybe the fact he is an international at youth level, which next point is a problem in general with this country, the spl youth players get picked reguarly against other youngsters playing week in week out for their club outside the SPL. Therefore not a valid argument.
Sorry idept was probably a strong word. Maybe a bit strange is the correct term. He makes some interesting tactical choices. In fact I think that in spite of the Manager we are top and not because of him. I don't expect him to get every decision right but I believe a few better placed decisions and we would be top. I think we have the squad to win the league.