OK, everyone has their own ideas. Who would you select for the game?

I would have Boyd and Fletcher up front with Faddy playing behind them.

Assuming Miller and Alexander don't make it....

Gordon

Broadfoot
Caldwell
McManus
Naysmith

Maloney
Fletcher
Hartley
Robson
McFadden

Boyd

451 pushing up to a 433 when possible.

I'm not really sure who will be fit enough to play or not but assuming everyone is fit I'd go:

Craig Gordon

Graham Alexander
Gary Caldwell
Stephen McManus
Gary Naysmith

Paul Hartley
Barry Robson/Darren Fletcher

Kenny Miller/Shaun Maloney
Darren Fletcher/Barry Robson
Kris Commons

Kris Boyd

With Maloney playing if Miller isn't fit and not too sure who would be better where with Robson and Fletcher.

I reckon thats far too attacking. Id go with McFadden up front on his tod with Maloney and Morrison on the wings. This means a three man midfield of Fletcher,Robson and Hartley.

People often complain about Scotland not being attacking enough but we were winning games playing more defensively. That team on Saturday just wasnt balanced.