Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Dundee V Dunfermline
The Pie Shop > SPL and SFL Football > 1st Division General Chatter
Pages: 1, 2
Grant228
Is Nicky Phinn back for this game?
Socks
It's a bit confusing looking at the suspensions lists - he was on it as an immediate 1 game suspension 2 weeks ago which obviously he served against Livingston, but somehow it also shows up as a 1 game suspension to be served on last week's list. I'm pretty sure it's just an error on last week's list though and that he shouldn't have been on it, meaning he'll be OK for Saturday.

I'm looking forward to this one. We have a good record at Dens over the last 15 years and indeed I think I've only seen us lose once there, which was the day Lee Wilkie broke his leg, Darren Young scored a peach for us, Dundee equalised with a penalty given after a shot hit Scott Thomson in the middle of the chest, then Brett Sancho scored the winner. Why is my memory annoyingly good for games I really don't want to remember?

I like going up to Dens, loads of good games there in recent years, notably our 2 comeback in successsive seasons in midweek games for a 2-2 draw and a 3-2 win5 or 6 years ago, as well as a 4-2 win and 4-4 draw in the mid 90s. Even last season, the two draws there were both quite decent games, with the 0-0 in the second away game there possibly the best game I saw all season. Also, for all the crap that gets chucked round on here about Dundee fans, I've always found them fine, both in the pub before the game and walking up the road back to the car afterwards.
Grant228
If Phinn is avalible McIntyre will pick
-----------------------Galacher-------------------
--Woods/Shileds--Wilson--Thomson--McCann
-----Wiles--------Bell------Phinn-----Burke---
---------------------Bayne---Kirk--------------

Looking at that reminds me of how we have no decent Left Midfilders...although if im being honest i thought Muirhead done ok when he came on against Livi..
DeeJay35
Well, we are well overdue for the team to play well this season. Colin Cameron has too make a difference if he does play or its going to be a long hard season and the possibility that Craig McKeown will make his home debut as well should be another reason to be positive. This wont be a game for passengers, so maybe AR will leave out Daquin again, although he did score against the pars last season and the only game we have lost this season is when he was dropped!

I think the first goal will be important in this game as I dont see many goals being scored in this one.

Hopefully, the Pars should bring a decent enough support and get a good atmosphere for the players.
EastFootball
I'm hoping and praying that Colin Cameron and Craig McKeown are fit for this game.

I also think Gilhaney and O'Brien should start on the wings, because Paton did very little at RM against Queens, except for a couple of crosses (which he could just as easily have sent in from RB).

So, a very optimistic line-up would be...

Douglas
Paton McKenzie McKeown Malone
O'Brien Cameron McHale Gilhaney
Antoine-Curier McMenamin

Subs: Roy, Cowan, Pozniak, Deasley, Davidson


Actually, thinking about it, isn't is strange how in the first league game after dropping Freddie, we still played shit but actually lost? unsure.gif
Grant228
QUOTE (DeeJay35 @ Sep 8 2008, 18:21) *
Hopefully, the Pars should bring a decent enough support and get a good atmosphere for the players.


As far as i know we sold out 1 bus about a week ago don't know if we have put on 2 busses..although it is close and easy enough to get there by car and train.
Btw how much does your pies etc cost?
EastFootball
QUOTE (Grant228 @ Sep 8 2008, 18:28) *
As far as i know we sold out 1 bus about a week ago don't know if we have put on 2 busses..although it is close and easy enough to get there by car and train.
Btw how much does your pies etc cost?

Put it this way: a 3-course lunch at La Gavroche is probably cheaper, and that includes the cost of getting there and back.
Juan Sara
Paper says McKeown and Cameron are looking to make a comeback for this game.

I'll go for 1-0 to the Pars.
DeeJay35
QUOTE (Grant228 @ Sep 8 2008, 18:28) *
As far as i know we sold out 1 bus about a week ago don't know if we have put on 2 busses..although it is close and easy enough to get there by car and train.
Btw how much does your pies etc cost?



My advice - eat and drink before you go in m8. Im sure you will get something more satisfying and cheaper outside of the ground. If you cant go 90 mins without something to eat, then go and see your doctor laugh.gif

Have a look at this It will put you off hopefully. I have not bought food a Dens for quite a few seasons now.
gingapar
QUOTE (Grant228 @ Sep 8 2008, 17:51) *
If Phinn is avalible McIntyre will pick
-----------------------Galacher-------------------
--Woods/Shileds--Wilson--Thomson--McCann
-----Wiles--------Bell------Phinn-----Burke---
---------------------Bayne---Kirk--------------

Looking at that reminds me of how we have no decent Left Midfilders...although if im being honest i thought Muirhead done ok when he came on against Livi..


we are Lacking in good left wingers, Burke has been playing well but is playing a more inside left role with Mcann given total permission to bomb forward at every occasion and do the work of a left winger. In that respect, JM quite intellegently has us playing to our strengths although it can leave us susceptable to counter attacks. would be good if we could bring an exciting, pacey left winger in on loan to give us the option though because, of the players already at the club, McBride isn't ready for the first team and Muirhead is a a white, left footed Freddie Daquin.

looking forward to a proper tastey encounter here with both teams really looking to make a statement of intent for the season, my dad can't make it, unfortunately. He has a wedding to attend so i'll be dragging the wife along to make up the numbers (she's a rovers fan, but she doesn't really know any better, not yet anyway!).
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 8 2008, 18:46) *
Paper says McKeown and Cameron are looking to make a comeback for this game.

I'll go for 1-0 to the Pars.



With a pessimistic attitude, you'd be better not turning up. ph34r.gif
EastFootball
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 8 2008, 20:28) *
With a pessimistic attitude, you'd be better not turning up. ph34r.gif

Ref: *FIRST WHISTLE*
'Juan Sara': BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Muggy
QUOTE (EastFootball @ Sep 8 2008, 20:49) *
Ref: *FIRST WHISTLE*
'Juan Sara': BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



laugh.gif laugh.gif

Class.
Muggy
Anyway, back on topic.

I actually expect us to win this one, but it won't be easy. Dunfermline caused us a lot of problems last year at Dens.

Both teams will definitely get chances, so I think it's a case of whoever takes their chances will win.

I'm going for a 1-0 win to Dundee.
Juan Sara
So thinking we'll get beat makes me a boo boy. Great conclusion.
Superswally
Cant see beyond a score draw for this,
G_Man1985
Dundee to win 4-3

dorsetdee
QUOTE (G_Man1985 @ Sep 8 2008, 22:23) *
Dundee to win 4-3


Now thats the kind of score line I would like to see . I am travelling up to Dundee from Bournemouth for this game. I cant wait to get back in the Derry. Its been a while as I tend to do my support of the club through the club shop. Last Dens game was a 1-1 against celtic. The cup final was a day to remember also. Anyways as I am a bit out of touch ...wheres the best pub pre match for a couple of pints and good banter????.....looking forward to being back inside Dens... f**k I am excited!!
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 8 2008, 22:11) *
So thinking we'll get beat makes me a boo boy. Great conclusion.



No, but you seem to think we'll be lucky to get 9 points out of the next 5 games, which is very very possible, but it would be refreshing to see some more optimism from a fellow Dundee fan. Everything connected with Dundee, you show a pessimistic attitude.

Booooooooooooooo.
thommohawk
QUOTE (dorsetdee @ Sep 8 2008, 21:42) *
Now thats the kind of score line I would like to see . I am travelling up to Dundee from Bournemouth for this game. I cant wait to get back in the Derry. Its been a while as I tend to do my support of the club through the club shop. Last Dens game was a 1-1 against celtic. The cup final was a day to remember also. Anyways as I am a bit out of touch ...wheres the best pub pre match for a couple of pints and good banter????.....looking forward to being back inside Dens... f**k I am excited!!


It's gonna be my first g ame in ages too, looking forward to it smile.gif
DAFC
2-0 dundee.
Juan Sara
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 8 2008, 23:13) *
No, but you seem to think we'll be lucky to get 9 points out of the next 5 games, which is very very possible, but it would be refreshing to see some more optimism from a fellow Dundee fan. Everything connected with Dundee, you show a pessimistic attitude.

Booooooooooooooo.



No a realistic attitude, you even just said it was very, very possible.
EastFootball
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:22) *
No a realistic attitude, you even just said it was very, very possible.

Serious question: are you Bubble Head?
Juan Sara
QUOTE (EastFootball @ Sep 9 2008, 17:26) *
Serious question: are you Bubble Head?



Aye completely oh and was it not the both of you who constantly have a go at Freddie Daquin ? BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:22) *
No a realistic attitude, you even just said it was very, very possible.



It is possible, but what's not?

I think our fans can do with looking on the bright side a little more often, and showing some optimism.

There's as much chance as Dundee winning (I would actually argue, more) 1-0 than Dunfermline, so why not tip your beloved team in favour of a victory, rather than the opposition?

Your entitled to an opinion, and if that means predicting negativity, then cool.
Juan Sara
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 9 2008, 17:30) *
It is possible, but what's not?

I think our fans can do with looking on the bright side a little more often, and showing some optimism.

There's as much chance as Dundee winning (I would actually argue, more) 1-0 than Dunfermline, so why not tip your beloved team in favour of a victory, rather than the opposition?

Your entitled to an opinion, and if that means predicting negativity, then cool.


Is that not what you were complaining about?
Web
settle down girls, handbags away. 5-0 Dundee, There's some optimism for you we owe these inbred cunts.
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:29) *
Aye completely oh and was it not the both of you who constantly have a go at Freddie Daquin ? BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



Erm, that doesn't back your argument at all. How can you adopt an optimistic attitude towards Freddie Daquin?
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:34) *
Is that not what you were complaining about?



Yes, but now I see it's pointless discussing this.
Juan Sara
Good I bid you farewell.
Muggy
QUOTE (Web @ Sep 9 2008, 17:34) *
settle down girls, handbags away. 5-0 Dundee, There's some optimism for you we owe these inbred c***s.



laugh.gif That's the spirit!
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:37) *
Good I bid you farewell.



BOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooo ph34r.gif
Juan Sara
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 9 2008, 17:41) *
BOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooo ph34r.gif



I bet Peter Kay will shit himself if he reads that joke.
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:44) *
I bet Peter Kay will shit himself if he reads that joke.



What joke? huh.gif
Juan Sara
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 9 2008, 17:50) *
What joke? huh.gif



Exactly huh.gif See the terrorists have won.
Muggy
QUOTE (Juan Sara @ Sep 9 2008, 17:54) *
Exactly huh.gif See the terrorists have won.



Pessimism again, rolleyes.gif .
Captain Tash
Pars have good record up there and I expect a 2-1 victory up in the rectum of Scotland.

Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (Muggy @ Sep 9 2008, 17:59) *
Pessimism again, rolleyes.gif .


Dundee 0-3 Dunfermline
darkblue1893
QUOTE (Captain Tash @ Sep 9 2008, 19:15) *
Pars have good record up there and I expect a 2-1 victory up in the rectum of Scotland.


2-1 to the Dee. MAC and mac with the goals. tongue.gif
Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (Captain Tash @ Sep 9 2008, 19:15) *
I expect a 2-1 victory up in the rectum of Scotland.


huh.gif

The game isn't being played in Glenrothes.
parslad
QUOTE (Web @ Sep 9 2008, 17:34) *
settle down girls, handbags away. 5-0 Dundee, There's some optimism for you we owe these inbred c***s.

Inbred c***s?Thats rich coming from an inhabitant of a godforsaken toilet like Dundee.Anyway as usual we wont lose to Pikey Dundee.Two one Pars.
The ghost of Jim Morton
1-0 to Dunfermline me thinks wink.gif Alex Rae sent to the stand for taking a paddy and more demonstrations outside Dense Park after the game biggrin.gif
Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (parslad @ Sep 9 2008, 19:50) *
Inbred c***s?Thats rich coming from an inhabitant of a godforsaken toilet like Dundee.Anyway as usual we wont lose to Pikey Dundee.Two one Pars.


ohmy.gif

The beloved City of Discovery? Vibrant, flourishing and in a loving dual embrace with popular culture and its rich and glorious past. A more fitting description I reckon, Fife peasant boy.
Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (The ghost of Jim Morton @ Sep 9 2008, 20:21) *
1-0 to Dunfermline me thinks wink.gif Alex Rae sent to the stand for taking a paddy and more demonstrations outside Dense Park after the game biggrin.gif


More? Maybe my recent memory is failing me. When was the last one TGOJM?
parslad
QUOTE (Stainrod's Fedora @ Sep 9 2008, 20:22) *
ohmy.gif

The beloved City of Discovery? Vibrant, flourishing and in a loving dual embrace with popular culture and its rich and glorious past. A more fitting description I reckon, Fife peasant boy.


Dundees only popular for teenage pregnancies and socially deprived areas like The Hiltoun!Unlike the ancient capital of Scotland.Never mind Jute Boy at least you've got Oor Wullie and The Broons.
Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (parslad @ Sep 9 2008, 20:52) *
Dundees only popular for teenage pregnancies and socially deprived areas like The Hiltoun!Unlike the ancient capital of Scotland.Never mind Jute Boy at least you've got Oor Wullie and The Broons.


The banter up the Hulltoon is priceless. Adds to the city's unique allure.

I have to say, I do enjoy a pint in Fife's grandest town. I look forward to my next visit.
The ghost of Jim Morton
QUOTE (Stainrod's Fedora @ Sep 9 2008, 20:24) *
More? Maybe my recent memory is failing me. When was the last one TGOJM?



Here.http://www.pieandbovril.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=90831. Aledgedly
Stainrod's Fedora
QUOTE (The ghost of Jim Morton @ Sep 9 2008, 21:06) *
Here.http://www.pieandbovril.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=90831. Aledgedly


You fucked that up. Try again.
Juan Sara
QUOTE (parslad @ Sep 9 2008, 19:50) *
Inbred c***s?Thats rich coming from an inhabitant of a godforsaken toilet like Dundee.Anyway as usual we wont lose to Pikey Dundee.Two one Pars.



Just cause you only have 10 fingers! cool.gif
Web
QUOTE (parslad @ Sep 9 2008, 19:50) *
Inbred c***s?Thats rich coming from an inhabitant of a godforsaken toilet like Dundee.Anyway as usual we wont lose to Pikey Dundee.Two one Pars.


You are from Fife, we win.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.