QUOTE (DumfriesBear @ Aug 12 2008, 12:30)

Weir is past it but as I said we have several decent players who can play in that position, we need to strengthen midfield more than anywhere else as we are clearly lacking any flair
I agree we desperately need a creative midfielder but these are my reasons for the need of a new CB:
A) Weir is toooooooo old and although he has great positional sense he wont have the luxury of Cuellar behind him to make up for his lack of pace and none of those players listed are good enough to make up for this.

Cuellar had the one thing that all great defenders need and that is the ability to read a game. I cant see Broadfoot or any of the other defenders being in the right place at the right time as often as Cuellar(the jury is out on Bougherra but we havent seen enough of him to make that decision yet!)
C) I think Weir was going to be be phased out by the end of the season by which time we would have a fully fledged Cuellar Bougherra partnership that was rock solid.
These thought are just my opinion.