QUOTE (ShedruleFTD83 @ Aug 5 2008, 22:41)

We've played 17 times actually, dundee won 6, united 4 with the rest draws, hardly anything to shout about, overall record stands as dundee wins 45 united wins 71.
The last two dundee victories were hardly impressive btw, the first two in 04/05, one at tannadice you were awarded a penalty for nothing,
the 2nd one at dens united were down to 9 men for over half the game and still the better side before jarvie threw one in the net
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aug5cRwdahA *Edit you dees should watch this as it could well be your last memory of a derby win for a long time to come...
The more i think about it, you were also given a penalty in the relegation derby when Lovell fouled Ritchie though we still won but it could have been important, and in 2001/02 at dens with United leading 1-0 you were awarded a penalty for a foul 6 yards outside the box to get a draw, its a conspiracy
Actually im being unfair, it wasnt all one way, we were awarded a soft penalty in 03/04(dee boycott game), dodds took a tumble and we got a pen to get a draw aswell, but generall the dee have benefitted more this deacde from decisions in derbies

Scottish Premier - KO 15:00
Dundee 1 (0) - 0(0) Dundee Utd
Sutton 86
At Dens Park on 06-11-2004
Dundee: Jack (Soutar ,30 ) ,McNally ,Sancho ,Hutchinson ,Robb (Brady ,44 ) ,MacDonald ,Smith ,Fotheringham ,Anderson ,Lovell ,Caballero (Sutton ,79)
Subs not used: Mann,Larsen,Jablonski,Hegarty,
Dundee Utd: Jarvie ,Wilson
(sent off 59),Innes
(sent off 55),Ritchie ,Archibald ,Kerkar (McCracken ,57 ) ,McInnes ,Brebner ,Robson ,Scotland (Grady ,77 ) ,Samuel (Duff ,65)
Subs not used Hirschfeld,McIntyre,Robertson,Cameron,
Bookings: Jack ,Lovell (Dundee) Brebner ,McInnes ,Ritchie (Dundee Utd)
Attendance: 9845
Referee: Alan Freeland (Scotland)
That's some warped memoty you've got there. Surely you remember Wilson waving towards the same end Jarvie had the ground swallow him??