QUOTE (xbl @ Aug 3 2008, 01:17)

Why not go support East Fife if its that easy?
I have some sympathy for the guy. My wee brother is from Arbroath like me, but his dad is a Celtic fan, and so my wee brother grew up a die hard hoop. He's 15 and has a Celtic season ticket. Although he comes to some Arbroath games with me, theres nothing that will make him change his club. He supports Celtic, same as I support Arbroath. And I wouldnt turn round and suddenly decide to support Stirling instead of Arbroath, even though they are my local team now.
Give the guy a break!
I agree with you. Surely for just about all of us, the football team we support is something that is unlikely to change, whatever the circumstances. Of course for some people who move away they might start to watch the new local team, but surely it's pretty much impossible for most folk to just completely forget the team you grew up supporting? I know it does happen in some instances and I play 5s with someone who used to support Killie but got into watching the Pars when he moved to Fife because of work - it is the exception though.
If you analysed it closely enough, I bet you'd find that quite a number of fans of all teams have little or no direct connection to the town of the team that they support - I'm sure I mind a while ago reading on these forums of one of the Arbroath fans who was from somewhere around Dundee and randomly went to an Arbroath game, taking it up from there - I don't think many folk were critical of that, and nor should they have been. Similarly I used to get the pish ripped out of me for being a Pars fan growing up in Kirkcaldy while the Rovers were having their wee glory spell between 92 and 96, but that was just too bad because it was already established that the Pars were my team. As long as the person has a genuine feeling for their club and can say honestly that their allegiance wouldn't change to another club regardless of how bad their chosen team became, I don't really see why anyone should be criticised for it.