Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ex-players You'd Want Back?
The Pie Shop > SPL and SFL Football > 1st Division General Chatter
Pages: 1, 2
finnersaintee
Any players that once played for your club that wou would still like to re-sign (if money wasn't an issue), I think I'd take Paul Hartley back - still playing internationally and a player that would do well in amongst the current side.

Can't choose folk who have retired smile.gif
Deeboy
Kevin McDonald laugh.gif
Dee-funked
QUOTE (Deeboy @ Jun 26 2008, 06:54) *
Kevin McDonald laugh.gif


laugh.gif As soon as I saw the title of this thread, that's exactly what I thought. laugh.gif
O'Rourke
Dyron Daal obviously.
Skyline Drifter
If we're allowed to count loan players then Robbie Neilson.

If it has to be someone who was once actually our player then Jamie McAllister might be the best still playing but we don't need a left back. David Lilley maybe?
Lambo1885
Barry Nicholson and/or Jackie McNamarra
Gypsy till I die
Craig McKeown, Craig Bryson, Eddie Malone and Stephen O'Donnell. Bryson and O'Donnell were always a threat from midfield and Eddie's delivery used to be a useful weapon. McKeown for the fact he's turning into a great defender and IMO will be in the SPL sooner rather than later whether with Dundee or not.
Fifes Elite Force
Simmons thumbup2.gif
KingC
Most of the Caley team.
Deeboy
QUOTE (Dee-funked @ Jun 26 2008, 08:19) *
laugh.gif As soon as I saw the title of this thread, that's exactly what I thought. laugh.gif

I'd have said Morten Weighorst, but he's retired.
Whistle Blower
Stevie Crawford & Colin Cameron


Nizzy
In their prime or in their current physical condition?

We're in desperate need of strikers, but I can't think of any who are still playing at a decent level.

The only plyer that instantly jumps to mind is Martin Hardie. Oh, how I wish Del and Gerry had taken a gamble on him.
Diamonds 666
Alan Gow
Gofor
Don Cowie and John Rankin. They would be great with the type of football we are now playing.
irvineTON
Paul Hartley, Kevin Thomas (Is he still playing?), Robert Earnshaw, Sean O'Connor
Stevie Aitken's Love Child
I can't really think of many that are still playing. Robert Earnshaw and Paul Hartley are the obvious ones, but they were only loan deals.

QUOTE (irvineTON @ Jun 26 2008, 10:29) *
Kevin Thomas (Is he still playing?)

Last I heard of Thomas was a few years back when he was at Bo'ness Juniors.
Rodgers
jason scotland
supersaint44
Jason Scotland, Stephen Dobbie, Kenny Deuchar, Darren Dods, Eddie Malone, Matt Glennon
strathbrock
David Fernandez, Burton O'Brien, Neil Alexander, Marvin Andrews
Jacobite_Dundee
Caniggia, Ravanelli, Nemsadze, Caballero, Novo, Khizanishvili, Sara, Ketsbaia.
campbell must go
laugh.gif
QUOTE (KingC @ Jun 26 2008, 09:08) *
Most of the Caley team.

Cracker!
The Rebel Piper
cowie, rankin, bayne, barrowman....notice how they all play for the same team...
SuperTommy
Gav Rae, our current starting eleven with him added and we'd walk this league.
strathbrock
QUOTE (The Rebel Piper @ Jun 26 2008, 11:32) *
cowie, rankin, bayne, barrowman....notice how they all play for the same team...


One thing I've noticed is that nothing stays the same for ever in football. One day I expect this trend to be reversed. Keep the faith son.
AndoAndo
QUOTE (SuperTommy @ Jun 26 2008, 11:35) *
Gav Rae, our current starting eleven with him added and we'd walk this league.

To be fair, most teams would walk this league with 12 players...
Grievzie
Can we give Broadfoot back to St Mirren please? biggrin.gif

(Theyre worse than most first division teams anyway) wink.gif
The Rebel Piper
QUOTE (strathbrock @ Jun 26 2008, 11:53) *
One thing I've noticed is that nothing stays the same for ever in football. One day I expect this trend to be reversed. Keep the faith son.


perhaps, but hopefully so. but in no way do i want ICT to plummit, it's good having a reasonably successful Highland team, i'd obviously rather that County one day manage to make it to SPL, but either way i think both teams miss the regular derby's
SuperTommy
QUOTE (AndoAndo @ Jun 26 2008, 11:57) *
To be fair, most teams would walk this league with 12 players...


As soon as i read it back i was going to edit it cause i knew someone would say that.

Everyone knew what i meant, Gav Rae in our team would walk this league.
The Arch
Hard one, but would probably be one of the players that left around the end of our first season in the SPL.

Probably between Hardie, Lilley and Craigan. I would actually have picked Rowson, if he wasn't already here, because I loved him first time around.

If we were playing 3-5-2, all three of those players would be perfect. If Paton's as good as McCall thinks, then I'd rule out Lilley.

Now Hardie or Craigan. We're quite strong in midfield, and in defence, so I'm not sure. I loved Hardie, so probably him wub.gif
washsacks
ADAM HAMMILL,Jim O'brien,Rossi, Skerla,Barry Nic,Noel Hunt.....
staggy4life
QUOTE (The Rebel Piper @ Jun 26 2008, 11:32) *
cowie, rankin, bayne, barrowman....notice how they all play for the same team...

Rankin plays for Hibs now. wink.gif

For me it would be Canning, Cowie, Rankin and Barrowman
The Rebel Piper
QUOTE (staggy4life @ Jun 26 2008, 12:17) *
Rankin plays for Hibs now. wink.gif



my bad. he was always better than caley, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yea thats right, i said it!
Lambie's Pigeon Feed
Adam Strachan blink.gif
DeeJay35
QUOTE (SuperTommy @ Jun 26 2008, 12:08) *
As soon as i read it back i was going to edit it cause i knew someone would say that.

Everyone knew what i meant, Gav Rae in our team would walk this league.



You trying to tell us something Tommy? tongue.gif



Anyway........Rab Douglas ( cool.gif ), Keith Wright, Tommy Coyne, Dusan Vrto, John Broon, Boab Glennie, CC, Nemsadze
SuperTommy
QUOTE (DeeJay35 @ Jun 26 2008, 12:54) *
You trying to tell us something Tommy? tongue.gif


I wish mate. I'd think Gav is worth a couple of million now. Thats about a couple of million more than we can afford. laugh.gif
Skyline Drifter
QUOTE (DeeJay35 @ Jun 26 2008, 12:54) *
You trying to tell us something Tommy? tongue.gif



Anyway........Rab Douglas ( cool.gif ), Keith Wright, Tommy Coyne, Dusan Vrto, John Broon, Boab Glennie, CC, Nemsadze

Did the bit in the first post where we were limited to players who are still actually playing pass you by? rolleyes.gif The only one still playing is Douglas and he's yours anyway.
palmy_cammy
Jamie Macdonald and Robbie Neilson would both improve our current squad, as would Jamie McAlistair who was a Playoff Final defeat away from being a Premiership player this coming season.

Stevie Mallan wouldn't improve our squad at his age now, but I'd love to have him back because he is a bit of a cult hero of mine. He could show Tosher how to fight properly as well!
FREDDYFRY
QUOTE (Gypsy till I die @ Jun 26 2008, 08:53) *
Craig McKeown, Craig Bryson, Eddie Malone and Stephen O'Donnell. Bryson and O'Donnell were always a threat from midfield and Eddie's delivery used to be a useful weapon. McKeown for the fact he's turning into a great defender and IMO will be in the SPL sooner rather than later whether with Dundee or not.


Would also add Jack Ross, John Potter & Mark McLaughlin to that list with an interested fit Tam Brighton. Kareem Kerkar for entertainment value.
FC_1919
Agree that Neilson and McDonald would be the main two for us.

Noticed I had this photo on Bebo, few legends in it!

Exuberant
QUOTE (Nizzy @ Jun 26 2008, 10:13) *
In their prime or in their current physical condition?

We're in desperate need of strikers, but I can't think of any who are still playing at a decent level.

The only plyer that instantly jumps to mind is Martin Hardie. Oh, how I wish Del and Gerry had taken a gamble on him.



Word for word agreement.

I would also have said "Rowson" this time last year, as The Arch says.
Glesga Frm
Kenny Arthur.....cant beleive no thistle fan has mentioned him yet. biggrin.gif
ryangordon86
Jason Scotland & Callum Davidson (would sort our left back slot out perfectly)

Scotchie
none! Very rarely does it work when player returns to a club they left. Think it must be something in their mentality that tells them they're bigger than the club.
Dunning1874
It would appear that none of our old fullbacks who were any good are still playing, which shows you how shit we've been for years.

We obviously all want Chris Millar back. sad.gif

Anyway, as has been said before, Paul Hartley and Robert Earnshaw are the obvious ones.

Jani Uotinen. biggrin.gif

I'm surprised the bloody bring back Alex Williams brigade hasn't got on here yet.

CK
Miguel Angel Espinola Jiminez cool.gif
Glesga Frm
Juan Ramon Escalas...biggrin.gif biggrin.gif biggrin.gif

Quinton Jacobs, Scot Paterson, Alex Burns
jagtastic
QUOTE (Glesga Frm @ Jun 26 2008, 13:40) *
Kenny Arthur.....cant beleive no thistle fan has mentioned him yet. biggrin.gif


Cos we've got Johnny Tuffey now! wink.gif I liked Kenny but it was the right time for him to move on and I think Tuffey has more potential than the King had at the same age. Is Scott Patterson still playing for some highland league team? I thought i heard that during last season anyway. I know he's not playing senior anymore but he's definitely one of the guys that would probably never have played for Thistle if it wasn't for the bad injury problems that hampered his career.
Glesga Frm
I thought he had hung up his boots, he was a class player, he reminded me of a Bobo Balde type player, only less clumsy...biggrin.gif

remember his goal up at the Caledonian Stadium??? wink.gif
Exuberant
QUOTE (Glesga Frm @ Jun 26 2008, 13:40) *
Kenny Arthur.....cant beleive no thistle fan has mentioned him yet. biggrin.gif



But he couldn't kick for shit.


Great service to the Club, but Tuffey was a revelation last season and will go on to even greater things.
jagtastic
QUOTE (Glesga Frm @ Jun 26 2008, 15:32) *
I thought he had hung up his boots, he was a class player, he reminded me of a Bobo Balde type player, only less clumsy... biggrin.gif

remember his goal up at the Caledonian Stadium??? wink.gif


Brilliant! standing in the pishing rain behind the goal and just seeing the ball come over the wall and smack the net net right in front of us.... that's one of my favourite away games (and goals!) thumbup2.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.