A_dee4life
Jun 18 2008, 18:54
Who would you say has the loudest set of home/away fans?
yangus
Jun 18 2008, 19:06
Livingstone
QUOTE (yangus @ Jun 18 2008, 20:06)

Livingstone

They make more noise than St Johnstone's librarians, that's for sure.
Dougie Mills
Jun 18 2008, 19:17
it is all relative to how a team are performing and who their opposition are. I'm sure Clyde fans for example would be noisier if they were playing Thistle and 3-0 up than when watching a snore 0-0 against Ross County
EdinburghLivi
Jun 18 2008, 19:18
*groans*
Why do we need two separate threads for topics which are basically the same?
Yangus, I think you've forgotten the Livi fans that were thrown out of YOUR ground for making too much noise on the last day of the season. If that isn't a sign of a quiet club, I don't know what is.
The ghost of Jim Morton
Jun 18 2008, 19:43
QUOTE (Nizzy @ Jun 18 2008, 20:07)

They make more noise than St Johnstone's librarians, that's for sure.
Shut it nancy boy...
I,m the loudest cnut in this league and you know it!!!!!
Sao Paulo
Jun 18 2008, 19:46
This thread is going to be every bit as inconsequential as the 'most passionate' effort.
Pre-season is bursting me. Hurry up July 12th!
gypoarmy
Jun 18 2008, 19:46
QUOTE (The ghost of Jim Morton @ Jun 18 2008, 20:43)

Shut it nancy boy...
I,m the loudest cnut in this league and you know it!!!!!

sorry i missed that
revolvingduck
Jun 18 2008, 19:48
Another pointless thread from a Dundee fan. This is getting tiresome
I saw the title for this thread on the home page and knew it was a Dundee fan that must have started it.
Maybe the plan is to win this vote and lobby the SPL to base promotion on the volume of your support?
robosaintee
Jun 19 2008, 08:44
Livingston have a drum.
WendyWho?
Jun 19 2008, 09:23
I find the silence that eminates from the Derry at Dens when Dundee go a goal down to be absolutely deafening.
Jacobite_Dundee
Jun 19 2008, 09:56
QUOTE (WendyWho? @ Jun 19 2008, 10:23)

I find the silence that eminates from the Derry at Dens when Dundee go a goal down to be absolutely deafening.
How does it compare to the noise eminating from the Derry when McMenamin scores a last minute winner?

I've just had a wee look, and if you discount Kelvin Jack own goals, St Johnstone last beat Dundee at Dens Park in 1999. That's a long time, innit?
WendyWho?
Jun 19 2008, 10:23
That's like saying, "if you discount the last time St. Johnstone won at Dens, St. Johnstone haven't won at Dens since 1999". Dundee's record at McDiarmid isn't markedly better really. If you discount the last win (in 2002) it's 2001 since Dundee last fluked the 3 points at McD.
As for the last minute winner I couldn't tell you because at that precise moment I was rolling around on the floor with my hands over my ears shrieking and vomiting bile out of every orifice.
Lambie's Pigeon Feed
Jun 19 2008, 10:28
QUOTE (WendyWho? @ Jun 19 2008, 11:23)

That's like saying, "if you discount the last time St. Johnstone won at Dens, St. Johnstone haven't won at Dens since 1999". Dundee's record at McDiarmid isn't markedly better really. If you discount the last win (in 2002) it's 2001 since Dundee last fluked the 3 points at McD.
As for the last minute winner I couldn't tell you because at that precise moment I was rolling around on the floor with my hands over my ears shrieking and vomiting bile out of every orifice.
Just to clarify you are claiming that you vomitted bile out of your arse? Interesting.
Jacobite_Dundee
Jun 19 2008, 11:10
QUOTE (WendyWho? @ Jun 19 2008, 11:23)

That's like saying, "if you discount the last time St. Johnstone won at Dens, St. Johnstone haven't won at Dens since 1999". Dundee's record at McDiarmid isn't markedly better really. If you discount the last win (in 2002) it's 2001 since Dundee last fluked the 3 points at McD.
I should really have put a smiley after that bit of my post, but glad to see the bait's taken. At least we scored in our last away win at McDiarmid!
ClydeNewcomer
Jun 19 2008, 11:30
QUOTE (Dougie Mills @ Jun 18 2008, 20:17)

it is all relative to how a team are performing and who their opposition are.
I'm sure Clyde fans for example would be noisier if they were playing Thistle and 3-0 up than when watching a snore 0-0 against Ross County 
Spot on my friend.
Exactly it depends on what team you are playing and how well your team are doing in the league
QUOTE (ClydeNewcomer @ Jun 19 2008, 12:30)

Exactly it depends on what team you are playing and how well your team are doing in the league
Hence why we didn't hear a peep out of your lot last season.
WendyWho?
Jun 19 2008, 11:50
QUOTE (Lambie's Pigeon Feed @ Jun 19 2008, 11:28)

Just to clarify you are claiming that you vomitted bile out of your arse? Interesting.
Yes. I am claiming that I vomited bile out of my arse.
Miles Brookeson
Jun 19 2008, 12:31
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.