QUOTE (Stevie Aitken's Love Child @ Jan 14 2008, 11:04)

Can any Livi fans give opinions on how he's played for you on loan? I notice that he hasn't started too many games recently, and hasn't been all the prolific, although he scored in the rout against us. Seems too similar in style to Iain Russell and would be, IMO, a bit of a waste of time signing.
He scored against us but was generally anonymous and disinterested. His goal came from a set piece when he screwed a header into the ground and it bounced up and over Alan Main. Said the same the to Dundee fans, he scored so many goals for Gretna because Gretna were head-and-shoulders above the other sides for the first half of last season. When Gretna started struggling and we beat them at Perth - the day they had Barrau on the bench and Mileson didn't know who he was - he only scored another couple of goals from open play.
The McMenamin at Livi has been far more like the guy that struggled on loan at Falkirk in this league.
Jenkins will do well for you though IMO!