Jump to content
Guest

Offence, Goodwin's Law and forum admin

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Isabel Goudie said:

Isabel Goudie has been on this forum under the nom de plume for 9 years, despite accusation to the contrary Isabel doesn’t use foul or abusive language or indulge in vitriolic comment. Under this Pseudonym, or any other previous, and despite some forth right views and no doubt an inherent ability to irritate, Isabel has never been banned. However, that record has is now no longer intact and last week received a three day ban for the use of inappropriate language.

Over the piece there has been a lot of inaccurate accusation. Two or three posters referred to the comparison to animals and have accused me of calling them an animal, not so much taking offence when none was intended as taking offence for something that was not implied. I was not calling folk monkeys in that sense, rather I was suggesting they were “dancing to a tune”. So please, if you are of a mind to take offence do so for the reason intended. Calling people animals is not my style, is lazy rancorous and clichéd.  

Then we have Godwin’s Law and the reason I was banned. Goodwin’s Law states that if and when someone makes reference to Hitler during an online debate they, by default, lose the debate. However it also stated that should the reference be accurate then of course this doesn’t apply. Firstly, I made no reference to Hitler, secondly my reference was one of ultimate treachery, which I consider to be appropriate in the debate.

I therefore maintain that I should not have been banned and suggest that some of the comments, and outright sustained anti Junior opinion, was more serious given the fact that it was perpetrated from within a forum dedicated to Junior Football.

Sevco-esque in its statementness.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, santheman said:

Welcome back Isa

I like a poster that compares people to Nazis

FTFY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Isabel Goudie said:

Well let me tell you something brother!

Isabel Goudie has been on this forum under the nom de plume for 9 years jack, despite accusation to the contrary Isabel doesn’t use foul or abusive language or indulge in vitriolic comment brother! Under this Pseudonym, or any other previous, and despite some forth right views and no doubt an inherent ability to irritate, Isabel has never been banned dude! However, that record has is now no longer intact jack, and last week finally...... received a three day ban for the use of inappropriate language.  Dig it!

WHAT?!

Over the piece there has been a lot of inaccurate accusation. Two or three jabronis referred to the comparison to animals and have accused me of calling them an animal, not so much taking offence when none was intended as taking offence for something that was not implied. I was not calling folk candy ass monkeys in that sense, rather I was suggesting they were “stylin' and profilin'”. So please, if you are of a mind to take offence do so for the reason intended. Calling people animals is not my style, is lazy rancorous and clichéd. Ooohhh yeeeaaaahhh!

WHAT?!

Then we have Godwin’s Law and the reason I was banned. Goodwin’s Law states that if and when someone makes reference to Hitler during an online debate they, by default, lose the debate. However it also stated that should the reference be accurate then of course this doesn’t apply. Firstly, I made no reference to Hitler, secondly my reference was one of ultimate warrior, which I consider to be appropriate in the debate. Everyone has their price.

WHAT?!

I therefore maintain that I should not have been banned and suggest that some of the comments, and outright sustained anti Junior opinion, was more serious given the fact that it was perpetrated from within a forum dedicated to Junior Football 4 life! Too sweeeeeeeet!

And that's the bottom line cos Isabel said so!

FTFY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, gogsy said:

FTFY

You missed out your bit about orange lodges Goggsy

No like you at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At least he's not turning into a bormann.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, santheman said:

You missed out your bit about orange lodges Goggsy

No like you at all.

Poor attempt at deflection from you there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not just a 3 day ban he was kicked out

So what happened to said poster he was baiting him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He called someone a snidey wee p***k he didn’t hide who it was who he was speaking about he thinks the person himself came on here and reported him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
And let this be a lesson to all the mealy-mouthed long-winded pretentious gobshite’s in the world

I’ve seen a lot worse on here pmsl

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Isabel Goudie said:

Isabel Goudie has been on this forum under the nom de plume for 9 years, despite accusation to the contrary Isabel doesn’t use foul or abusive language or indulge in vitriolic comment. Under this Pseudonym, or any other previous, and despite some forth right views and no doubt an inherent ability to irritate, Isabel has never been banned. However, that record has is now no longer intact and last week received a three day ban for the use of inappropriate language.

Over the piece there has been a lot of inaccurate accusation. Two or three posters referred to the comparison to animals and have accused me of calling them an animal, not so much taking offence when none was intended as taking offence for something that was not implied. I was not calling folk monkeys in that sense, rather I was suggesting they were “dancing to a tune”. So please, if you are of a mind to take offence do so for the reason intended. Calling people animals is not my style, is lazy rancorous and clichéd.  

Then we have Godwin’s Law and the reason I was banned. Goodwin’s Law states that if and when someone makes reference to Hitler during an online debate they, by default, lose the debate. However it also stated that should the reference be accurate then of course this doesn’t apply. Firstly, I made no reference to Hitler, secondly my reference was one of ultimate treachery, which I consider to be appropriate in the debate.

I therefore maintain that I should not have been banned and suggest that some of the comments, and outright sustained anti Junior opinion, was more serious given the fact that it was perpetrated from within a forum dedicated to Junior Football.

Well, look on the bright side at least Talbot should find winning the Scottish Junior Cup easier and easier over the next few years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Isabel Goudie said:

Isabel Goudie has been on this forum under the nom de plume for 9 years, despite accusation to the contrary Isabel doesn’t use foul or abusive language or indulge in vitriolic comment. Under this Pseudonym, or any other previous, and despite some forth right views and no doubt an inherent ability to irritate, Isabel has never been banned. However, that record has is now no longer intact and last week received a three day ban for the use of inappropriate language.

Over the piece there has been a lot of inaccurate accusation. Two or three posters referred to the comparison to animals and have accused me of calling them an animal, not so much taking offence when none was intended as taking offence for something that was not implied. I was not calling folk monkeys in that sense, rather I was suggesting they were “dancing to a tune”. So please, if you are of a mind to take offence do so for the reason intended. Calling people animals is not my style, is lazy rancorous and clichéd.  

Then we have Godwin’s Law and the reason I was banned. Goodwin’s Law states that if and when someone makes reference to Hitler during an online debate they, by default, lose the debate. However it also stated that should the reference be accurate then of course this doesn’t apply. Firstly, I made no reference to Hitler, secondly my reference was one of ultimate treachery, which I consider to be appropriate in the debate.

I therefore maintain that I should not have been banned and suggest that some of the comments, and outright sustained anti Junior opinion, was more serious given the fact that it was perpetrated from within a forum dedicated to Junior Football.

Worst 3 days of my life, welcome back :wub: and remember, don’t let the b*****ds grind you down buddy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×