Jump to content

Should OF buy-out SPFL1 clubs as feeders?


Recommended Posts

Alex Smith - current Falkirk assistant, chair of the Scottish League Managers Association, recent inductee to the Scottish Football Hall of Fame - is calling for OF to buy-out 2 clubs as feeders.

He envisages clubs like Airdrie, Clyde or Livingston being taken-over by Rangers and Celtic. Argues this would enhance youth development and give OF fans a home game to watch every week.

He says this would transform and improve Scottish football's fortunes.


http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/rangers-celtic-should-buy-over-9258820

By Gavin Berry

ALEX SMITH wants Scotland’s major clubs to take over lower-league sides and use them as feeder outfits in a radical proposal to help develop our country’s youngsters. Scottish football’s godfather and Falkirk technical director insists a solution must be found to help produce talent that can help the nation get back onto the major stage.

 

ADVERTISING

inRead invented by Teads

The idea of the Old Firm fielding Colt sides in the lower leagues has been discussed before with the SFA also considering a proposal for an NFL-style draft system as part of a major shake-up. It is aimed at getting kids more competitive football and Smith’s idea takes it a step further by claiming Rangers and Celtic and the rest of the top clubs could buy out the likes of Airdrie and Clyde as a route into the lower leagues.

 

He believes it would help their top talent develop by playing in tougher leagues in front of bigger crowds before returning to their parent clubs ready for top level action. Smith – a former manager of the Bully Wee – said: “I don’t agree with a lot of people who say we don’t have good young footballers. We have a lot of good young footballers – I want this message to get over.

 

“It is not the kids that are the problem. The biggest problem for Scottish football is the blockage at the top of the academies. We have the development league there. They can get in there, it is a good pathway, then they get so many games, but some managers won’t play them in their first teams because the pressures are so heavy to get results.

 

“They work hard within the academy, they work hard to get into teams, they work hard to come through the system. They are all bursting to do that - so enthusiastic. The problem is that they go from the years of ambition – say nine-years-old to 18 – to the age of frustration and unfulfilment. They get disillusioned. And they drop a bit off it because they can’t get in the first team.

 

“We have tried the loan system but it only works for a few. Sometimes they go out on loan and don’t do well, people forget about them then it becomes worse for them. I don’t see the reason – and I know there are reasons but I don’t see them as being strong enough – to deny the big clubs being able to buy over some of the provincial, community clubs.

 

“If Rangers for instance were to buy over Airdrie and the brand new stadium which is sitting there and play in the Championship league, and likewise Celtic with Clyde at Broadwood or Livingston, they can get their young players and play them in a competitive environment. It means they and their staff are kind of in charge of it and can try to give them first team experience so that when they bring boys back - like Liam Henderson for example who went to Hibs before returning to Celtic - they are almost ready for their first team.

 

“The Spanish clubs do that all the time but whenever you mention it in Scotland you get told that you can’t do it, the constitution doesn’t allow one club to own another club. But think of the benefits of getting young players playing. Celtic played at Pittodrie recently and had maximum 8000 fans up there. But you have 60,000 at Parkhead every second week so that’s 52,000 empty seats.

 

“The same goes for Rangers. So where are those fans? They could be going to see these clubs, watching these players. All the clubs would benefit from the financial push they got.

 


Thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 64
  • Created
  • Last Reply

When was the last time Alex Smith said anything which wasn't utterly risible bollocks? He is the embodiment of everything wrong with Scottish football, a truly awful individual with absolutely nothing worthwhile to contribute.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Dunning1874 said:

He is the embodiment of everything wrong with Scottish football, a truly awful individual with absolutely nothing worthwhile to contribute.

:o

Scottish football’s godfather

described as "the nearest thing the Scottish game has to a father figure"


'the Don Corleone of Falkirk FC'

Alex Smith has one of the most decorated managerial careers in Scottish football. At the age of 75 he is as active as ever and puts in a phenomenal amount of work

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, RandomGuy. said:

Not to worry, hes nearing the age where a case of mild constipation might kill him.

We should just hide the cups and ply him with copious amounts of fibre then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Sloop John B said:

P&B's fave journo Gavin Berry behind this cracker of a story

 

There is only ever one gif that is appropriate when yet another geriatric loon says something incredibly stupid.

 

  Hide contents

Michael-Scott-Closes-The-Door-Awkwardly-

 

Gavin Berry says it's the only way, if Scotland ever want to compete at the top level in the boat race or The Arc de Triomphe again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Colts teams will be the death of football.

It doesnt matter how small a team is. Teams have history, community ties and add to the culture of the game. Theres certainly a case to be made that smaller teams would potentially offer a good option to send kids out on loan to play meaningful football. If the criteria for improvement is playing meaningful football then the idea of colts teams is actually the antithesis. How can it be meaningful for kids to play for teams who have absolutely no purpose but to give them games? No drive for promotion or fight against relegation? Give me a struggling club fighting to be part of it's local community and playing for league survival over a bland, pointless, directionless reserve side any day.

Colt teams are absolutely barmy and should be nowhere near Scottish football.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...