Jump to content

Good or bad group for Scotland?


Dryhorce

Recommended Posts

Yeah that was a bit of an eye-opener. I know the rankings are to be taken with a pillar of salt, but I'd never have guessed Poland were 70th (I assumed they were 15th-25th)?

Remember the rankings are over a 4 year period and they didn't play competitively between October 2009 and June 2012, I think that's a bit of a false ranking, and it pretty much happens to every team that hosts a major tournament.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 205
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Current squad has Higginbotham...

He retired in January to concentrate on a media career...he actually comes over as not too bad...but will still be available for Gibraltar. That may be ok for a few friendly games against smaller nations but I can't see it being suitable when they get round to playing the qualifiers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I reckon Gibraltar will be better than Liechetenstein.

I think they'll be a San Marino

And fluke a late winner at home, no doubt.

Gibralter will be no mugs either. Look at the other teams on the Iberian peninsula (Spain, Portugal).

Andorra?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My first reaction was that the group was somewhere between bad and nightmarish. I've warmed to it a little, but it's not the best we could have had.

Germany - the nightmare draw. I know that most pot 1 sides would beat us easily, but if you're going to rank them, Germany would be top of the list. Still, will be good to see a side of that quality at Hampden. They will absolutely hose this group, and are extremely likely to get maximum points. That's not the worst thing that could happen for us, of course, and puts it down to the results against the other 5. Ideally, they beat us by 1 or 2, and then horse Ireland/Poland, but could go any way to be honest.

Poland - the big unknown. They're low in the rankings, but as has been said, that's because of their lack of Euro 2012 games. They are not a side that should be ranked 70, and are probably the ones we most need to fear besides Germany. We have to win the home game, and go out and get at least a point in the away game.

Ireland - similar to Poland, but are probably battling it out for a play-off place with us. We should be beating them, but then we should have beaten Wales. Doesn't always work that way.

Georgia - worrying. Macedonia embarrassed us at home by clearly being much better on the ball, and I can see the games against Georgia turning the same way. We play them at home first, don't we? We need to go out in that game positively, as if we lose that one, we'll be 0 for 2, and in an even worse position than in World Cup 2014 qualifying. Ireland and Poland are the games around our quality, but this is the banana skin.

Gibraltar - I don't see them being as bad as San Marino, but that's the thing - you just don't know. It's highly likely they'll be the whipping boys of the group, but we can't take them for granted. I'm not going to pretend they're Brazil, but I would have been much more comfortable drawing San Marino or Andorra, as at least they're known quantities. We should be getting six points from this, anything less is just not good enough for a pot 6 team.

Ideally, this turns into a mini-league between ourselves, Ireland and Poland for the 2nd and 3rd positions. One misses out, and I can see that being Ireland.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Georgia could end up being a key team in the group.

Germany should beat everybody and everybody should beat Gibraltar.

Now I don't think that Georgia are good enough to qualify but they can certainly take points off Scotland, Ireland and Poland

Gibraltar won't be as honking as San Marino. At least they boast a handful of professionals. San Marino's national team couldn't cut it in the highland league

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We should get a further idea about exactly how poor or otherwise Gibraltar are this week... They host the Faroe Isles at the Victoria Stadium on Saturday (albeit Britt of Southampton, Wiseman of Preston NE and Liam Walker are unavailable as it falls outside the window); then host Estonia next Wednesday.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I watched some highlights of Gibraltar and they were utterly dreadful. I wouldn't take the slovakia result too seriously, nor any of the unofficial games v UEFA teams. Proper stinking. Germany should break records against and even we should be picking a number.

I think we'll find Poland difficult. We should manage third ahead of Ireland but will need to match their motivation somehow. Georgia away won't be any easier than it was thon time, but Ireland will have as bad a time there as we do.

Would love to tan Gibraltar as it's a hole.

Incidentally, can we agree that anyone not pronouncing the second 'r' in Gibraltar should be euthanised? Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In 2011 they were placed 5th in the Island Games, Liam Walker etc. were includd in the squad. I mean no disrespect to the Island Games but...

Liam Walker was included in the squad but he was the only professional involved.

Wiseman Higginbotham and Priestley made their debuts in the Slovakia game and Artell Styche and Britt will probably do so this week.

It's also worth noting that the 2011 Island Games had a slightly unusual format. Gibraltar actually won all their games apart from a 3-2 defeat in the groupstage to hosts and eventual winners the Isle of Wight ( :lol:), scoring 18 goals in the process.

Earlier in 2011 they beat the Faroe Islands 3-0 in a surprise friendly result. That's their only previous match v a full UEFA/FIFA team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not normally a profit [sic] of doom but does anyone know how you qualify to play for Gibraltar? Is it possible that now that the glamorous fixtures are lined up that a cartload of not quite good enough to play for England types will suddenly emerge from the woodwork and they will actually be quite good? Have any of the players mentioned before actually have a link to the place?

After 24 hours to digest I am quite pleased with the draw. Ireland are not as good as us and Keane and MON will implode before Autumn. Poland look stronger than us but the only player worth fearing is the big striker. Will be good to see a magnificent German side in the flesh. Scotland have now got both the Fletchers back, an ever improving Snodgrass and excellent goalkeepers as well as some promising young guns coming through. Poland and Ireland will not be happy with their pot 4 draw. We will drop points to Georgia at some point but so will others.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not normally a profit [sic] of doom but does anyone know how you qualify to play for Gibraltar? Is it possible that now that the glamorous fixtures are lined up that a cartload of not quite good enough to play for England types will suddenly emerge from the woodwork and they will actually be quite good? Have any of the players mentioned before actually have a link to the place?

They're not able to use anyone with a British passport: there was a Caribbean overseas territory tried that back in the early 2000s, IIRC (was it the Cayman Islands possibly?), and they were told it wasn't possible. I don't know if Gibraltar are expected to "sign-up" to the Home Nations clauses or just use the normal clauses.

Of their overseas-based players Walker and Priestley were born in Gibraltar. Wiseman qualifies via his mother, Artell via his father, Higginbotham, Britt and Styche via grandparents.

Interestingly, with both Priestley and Artell's father, they were born there due to military stationing. (Priestley parents were on the Rock at the time as his father was in the RAF and Artell's grandparents were there as his grandard was serving in the Royal Navy).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I reckon Gibraltar will be better than Liechetenstein.

iI reckon too but we WILL still hump them home n away.

As for the group, I'll take it we're 4th pot ffs ,what else do you want, games are winnable, we have chance, late night watch your country up against similar teams, nothing beats it. I think we'll do it!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's the sort of attitude that has held us back for years.

There's a fine line between being brave/going all out for a win and tactical naivete.

A solid, defensively minded setup akin to the one we played in Croatia and Macedonia would be just fine. With that approach, we could be confident of holding roi and Poland to draws, denying them home pts, and be well placed to push for wins too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...