[wuffster]

Berwick Rangers v Ayr United

Highlights Now Showing

Ayr United Television (AUTV)

Edited to fix link (Thanks!)

This post has been edited by wuffster: 04 November 2007 - 21:10

[berwick-the-unbeatable]

Your link isn't working mate.

Good idea taking it to away games though!!

[berwick-the-unbeatable]

Them highlights are absolute class, well worth downloading the player for it, as well as Itunes

[Monster]

My highlight was leaving at the end.

[BerwickMad]

What do people think about the Gemmill 'dive' and the pass back?

It looks to me like Gemmill was stumbling and then helped over by the defender. Very hardsh booking for a dive.

[Cowans a Square Heed]

BerwickMad, on Nov 5 2007, 12:13, said:

What do people think about the Gemmill 'dive' and the pass back?

It looks to me like Gemmill was stumbling and then helped over by the defender. Very hardsh booking for a dive.

Yeah very harsh to be booked

[onegaryteale]

BerwickMad, on Nov 5 2007, 12:13, said:

What do people think about the Gemmill 'dive' and the pass back?

It looks to me like Gemmill was stumbling and then helped over by the defender. Very hardsh booking for a dive.

I didn't think it merited a booking, but at the same time I don't think it was a penalty, he seems to cut across Forrest (I think) and then go down.

As for the passback, I don't think the goalkeeper was the intended target, but I can see exactly why it was given, don't think there was really a wrong or right decision there.

[davidkennedyshand]

Personally having just watched both incidents i think it was a dive.He was off balance at the edge of the box after trying to cut across Robbo then made it look worse than it was..If he had kept going rather than cut across and flopping over he would have had his shot on goal.
I hate it when strikers do that.

The pass back was a strange one..looked like it was a miscontrol rather than a pass back.However if in doubt McGeown had ages to kick it away.Sometimes you get away with it sometimes you don't.This time we didn't.

[berwick-the-unbeatable]

Not a dive nor a pen. Another day it may have been given. If it was outside it prob woulb be a free-kick though.

[Iain]

davidkennedyshand, on Nov 5 2007, 13:56, said:

Personally having just watched both incidents i think it was a dive.He was off balance at the edge of the box after trying to cut across Robbo then made it look worse than it was..If he had kept going rather than cut across and flopping over he would have had his shot on goal.
I hate it when strikers do that.

The pass back was a strange one..looked like it was a miscontrol rather than a pass back.However if in doubt McGeown had ages to kick it away.Sometimes you get away with it sometimes you don't.This time we didn't.

There's no way he's trying to pass to McGeown there, not in a million years.

[Gareth]

Iain, on Nov 5 2007, 21:53, said:

There's no way he's trying to pass to McGeown there, not in a million years.

Agree, crazy decision.
But I think the penalty decision could just as easily have gone the other way.
Evens out over the season I guess.