[THE SPORTSMAN]

who do think is best manager in league considering limited resorses money etc

[voice of reason 2]

Mike lawson
By a mile

[dillinger]

We had this couple of weeks ago and everyone fell out with each other over it. I mean we all know it's Stuart Rome at Gretna.

[THE SPORTSMAN]

voice of reason 2, on 26 January 2012 - 21:25, said:

Mike lawson
By a mile

I thought micky and sam where co managers like both of them but could they do as well like other managers with limited resorses or less or no money

[Grim O'Grady]

Sam Lynch
by a country mile.

Grim

[newcastle broon]

THE SPORTSMAN, on 26 January 2012 - 21:16, said:

who do think is best manager in league considering limited resorses money etc

the lad at Edin city considering they the only team with 2011/12 silverware in cabinet at present..

Couldve Also said the stirling lads but they fecked off ?

What aboot the duns lad ? Are they punching above their weight ?

[colinmc]

Gary at CSS ?? Don't have much cash !

[Grim O'Grady]

newcastle broon, on 26 January 2012 - 22:37, said:

the lad at Edin city considering they the only team with 2011/12 silverware in cabinet at present..

Couldve Also said the stirling lads but they fecked off ?

What aboot the duns lad ? Are they punching above their weight ?

Had we have been able I reckon we could have made the final (Scottish Cup)!

City played their socks off against WW in that final, I was there, great match. They'd have bottled it against us, mind .

Nah it's been good (in a way) that we've not dominated everything (for one reason or another).

Whilst I don't want to see us lose any games I'd still like to see it tighter at the top.

Look who we've lost over the last 3 seasons & look who we've brought in, then look at our league position?

Spartans are a great EoS team but only because of the vision of the Management & the backing of the Chairman & the Committee, to make that vision come true.



Grim

[open mind]

THE SPORTSMAN, on 26 January 2012 - 21:44, said:

I thought micky and sam where co managers like both of them but could they do as well like other managers with limited resorses or less or no money

totally agree, Has Micky ever worked for a club with no money...

[newcastle broon]

open mind, on 27 January 2012 - 00:44, said:

totally agree, Has Micky ever worked for a club with no money...

he has managed in the sfl lower leagues

[AllStars11]

Broon Stirling have silverware also this season, might not be the biggest cup this season but a cup is a cup and you want to win them all

[newcastle broon]

AllStars11, on 27 January 2012 - 10:41, said:

Broon Stirling have silverware also this season, might not be the biggest cup this season but a cup is a cup and you want to win them all

yes agreed and if you read my post in comparison to the asked question, stirling were mentioned

[tamthebam]

Sam Lynch and Mickey have won a lot of silverware in their time certainly but I'd like to big up Tam "What a bam" Steven and Shaun "I like Referees" Steven for this season's efforts- While they're not everyone's cup of tea, Tynecastle looked dead and buried at one stage and they've managed to haul them out of the muck rather successfully.

Of course the most successful manager is anyone who manages to last more than a season working for Sir Peter.....!

[THE GOBLIN OF LOS PALACIOS]

Outside the premier i would say the lad who took over from laurie at coldstream must be a good shout as he has them challenging at the top now and i would imagine he would have no budget at all and a far smaller catchment area for players as every other team?

[mickles 1981]

Grim O, on 26 January 2012 - 23:02, said:

Had we have been able I reckon we could have made the final (Scottish Cup)!

City played their socks off against WW in that final, I was there, great match. They'd have bottled it against us, mind .

Nah it's been good (in a way) that we've not dominated everything (for one reason or another).

Whilst I don't want to see us lose any games I'd still like to see it tighter at the top.

Look who we've lost over the last 3 seasons & look who we've brought in, then look at our league position?

Spartans are a great EoS team but only because of the vision of the Management & the backing of the Chairman & the Committee, to make that vision come true.



Grim

If the management is THAT good, why has no SFL Club come in for them ?

Genuine question.

[only an opinion]

Name me 1 SFL manager who has not played senior football. Ie professional.

(Genuine anwser)

[numba1goaly]

you do realise that Laurie Dunn is manager at Hawick RA not Coldstream anymare???

[heedthebaa]

THE GOBLIN OF LOS PALACIOS, on 27 January 2012 - 17:44, said:

Outside the premier i would say the lad who took over from laurie at coldstream must be a good shout as he has them challenging at the top now and i would imagine he would have no budget at all and a far smaller catchment area for players as every other team?

numba1goaly, on 27 January 2012 - 18:18, said:

you do realise that Laurie Dunn is manager at Hawick RA not Coldstream anymare???

am i missing something here ?

[THE GOBLIN OF LOS PALACIOS]

numba1goaly, on 27 January 2012 - 18:18, said:

you do realise that Laurie Dunn is manager at Hawick RA not Coldstream anymare???

Considering i said the lad who took over from laurie kind of gives it away that i know that laurie is no longer coldstream manager,bit complicated for you?

[tamthebam]

only an opinion, on 27 January 2012 - 18:08, said:

Name me 1 SFL manager who has not played senior football. Ie professional.

(Genuine anwser)

most players in the EOSL/Juniors are professional in that they get paid to play. Perhaps you meant to say "FULL TIME professional" as compared to semi-professional.

Yon Arsene Wenger didn't have much of a footballing career and he's done no bad for himself, compared to say, John Barnes.....

[newcastle broon]

only an opinion, on 27 January 2012 - 18:08, said:

Name me 1 SFL manager who has not played senior football. Ie professional.

(Genuine anwser)

have some English clubs not appointed physios.


Fairly sure adkins at southampton was scunthorpe physio or the tranmere manager as well ,mcdermott ? Reading ?

Obviously not sfl but can be done

[only an opinion]

My opinion is you could manage and coach for 20 years at EOS or Junior level but have less chance of a career I'n SFL management than somebody who has just retired from playing at a higher level and has a name which is recognised with supporters from his playing days.

[NE63 exile]

newcastle broon, on 28 January 2012 - 11:45, said:

have some English clubs not appointed physios.


Fairly sure adkins at southampton was scunthorpe physio or the tranmere manager as well ,mcdermott ? Reading ?

Obviously not sfl but can be done

Adkins played for Tranmere years ago while McDermott played for Arsenal and Cardiff to name but a few.

There are ex-physio's in charge at Tranmere and Hereford.
Two ex-SFL manager's that never played at that level was Allan Maitland and Dave Baikie.

[Grim O'Grady]

mickles 1981, on 27 January 2012 - 18:00, said:

If the management is THAT good, why has no SFL Club come in for them ?

Genuine question.

S'pose you'd need to ask them, but like some of our players maybe their day jobs at the time paid more than the clubs could pay?

Grim

[mickles 1981]

Grim O, on 29 January 2012 - 06:43, said:

but like some of our players maybe their day jobs at the time paid more than the clubs could pay?

Grim

I hear what you're saying Grim, but most SFL players and managers are part-time too , with day jobs.