T_S_A_R, on 16 March 2010 - 15:28, said:
is the gripe of st mirren fans not gus has a complete aversion to flair and a crap record at bringing on young players?
The accusation that Gus has a crap record of bringing on young players is regularly made by Saints fans - but its completely without foundation.
There isn't a single young player who has been freed by St. Mirren since Gus became manager who has gone on to be a success. The fact is there has been very little coming through the youth system - which is run completely seperately from the first team for which Gus has control.
However, in saying that, the side that won the First Division had 3 players who were all teenagers at the start of the season - Kirk Broadfoot, Charlie Adam & Chris Smith. Other than McGowne, Millen, Reilly & Maxwell, all the players in that squad were under 25.
Quote
no one would deny the improvement off the park over the past ten years but on the park it seems as if it has been the same stifling football since they came up with little improvement. i can remember quite a few st mirren fans expecting to push on this year (especially with accies, falkirk and motherwell in dissaray) but it seems to be the same old story with the least shots and the 2nd least shots on target (hearts have 110, saints 111).
St. Mirren's expectations for what should happen on the park have been completely unrealistic. When Gus became manager we were in our third successive fight against relegation to the Second Division. Now bearing in mind that we have the second lowest gates, second lowest turnover and second lowest wage budget, bearing in mind that Gus has had hardly any decent young players coming through and that he's regularly lost his best players for peanuts / nothing (eg Broadfoot, Sutton, Lappin, McGinn, etc) and he's had to deal in the bargain basement transfer market, I'll list his achievements in another "What have the Romans ever done for us" style:
1) Saved us from relegation to the Second Division in 03/04
2) Took us to First Division Runners Up in 04/05
3) Won the First Division in 05/06
4) Won the Challenge Cup in 05/06 - first time we've ever won 2 national trophies in 1 season
5) Kept us in the SPL in 06/07
6) Finished in 10th spot in 07/08 - our highest finish in 20 years

Reached the Scottish Cup Final in 08/09 for the first time in 22 years
9) Although our league position was only 11th in 08/09, the relegated team went down with a record number of points. St. Mirren were 8 pts behind the top 6 at the split, the nearest we have been to the top 6 in 2 decades.
10) Beat both of the Old Firm for the first time in a couple of decades in 08/09
11) Reached our first major final in 23 years in 09/10 and our first League Cup Final in 55 years
Yes he's achieved this with anti-football - but he's had to do it on a relative shoetring whilst losing his best players and having no decent youth. When Gus Macpherson became manager I went to places like Palmerston Parl expecting to get humped - and we usually got humped. We are now in our 4th season in the top flight and in a major cup final - I'd much rather be where we are today than where we were before Gus became manager.
Too many Saints fans can't see the bigger picture.