[Ludo *1]

Rumours are circulating that Klimp has agreed a deal with us & will be unveiled tomorrow. Watched him on youtube & he looked like a monster, which is exactly what we need in our team at the moment.

Can anyone tell me what he was like?

[Mr. Brightside]

Decent player, would be a good signing for you's if true.

[Scotty Tunbridge]

Doubt it to be true (Although now I've typed this I await it to be quoted to when he does sign.)

[Ric]

I'd be surprised if he ended up at Dundee. He played well enough (if being overly physical) to earn him a move to a better club, and a better wage than he'll get in the 1st.

[Ludo *1]

inc0nseq, on Aug 30 2009, 22:59, said:

I'd be surprised if he ended up at Dundee. He played well enough (if being overly physical) to earn him a move to a better club, and a better wage than he'll get in the 1st.

Seemingly it was between us & Aberdeen vying for his signature. He chose us but at the last minute decided to stay in Denmark but the rumours circulating are stating he has done a u-turn. This makes it all sound quite far fetched but all we can do is wait & see.

[Bigmouth Strikes Again]

inc0nseq, on Aug 30 2009, 22:59, said:

I'd be surprised if he ended up at Dundee. He played well enough (if being overly physical) to earn him a move to a better club, and a better wage than he'll get in the 1st.

We're probably paying a lot more than the SPL diddy sides (no offence)

[Nizzy]

inc0nseq, on Aug 30 2009, 21:59, said:

I'd be surprised if he ended up at Dundee. He played well enough (if being overly physical) to earn him a move to a better club, and a better wage than he'll get in the 1st.

A better wage than Calum Melville can afford to pay while financing his plaything?

[Ric]

Bigmouth Strikes Again, on Aug 30 2009, 23:02, said:

We're probably paying a lot more than the SPL diddy sides (no offence)

Heh.. I don't doubt that, but then that's what a sugar daddy can give you..

Seriously though, a player that could easily play in the English Championship and I doubt Dundee could match those wages.

[Dunc]

Why is he no longer at Motherwell?

[Nizzy]

Dunc, on Aug 30 2009, 22:11, said:

Why is he no longer at Motherwell?

His loan spell's finished.

[Fife Saint]

Panic Signing. If it isn't working, throw some money at it.

[Dunc]

Nizzy, on Aug 30 2009, 23:11, said:

His loan spell's finished.

Thanks

Didn't realise he was on loan.

In that case, are Motherwell not interested in having him back because they can't afford him, or because Gannon just doesn't want him?

[Nizzy]

Fife Saint, on Aug 30 2009, 22:12, said:

Panic Signing. If it isn't working, throw some money at it.

Fantastic approach. I suggest Calum Melville throws one of his gold bullion bars at Jocky Scott's head. His subsequent death would remove a major barrier in Dundee's quest for promotion.

[Nizzy]

Dunc, on Aug 30 2009, 22:13, said:

In that case, are Motherwell not interested in having him back because they can't afford him, or because Gannon just doesn't want him?

I was under the impression Motherwell didn't have enough in the pot to bring him back and one of his other suitors - Aberdeen - were scared off when Dundee started flexing their financial muscles.

Hence my comments regarding Calum Melville's ludicrous claims regarding wages at Dundee on the First Division forum.

[Ludo *1]

Dunc, on Aug 30 2009, 23:13, said:

Thanks

Didn't realise he was on loan.

In that case, are Motherwell not interested in having him back because they can't afford him, or because Gannon just doesn't want him?

I'm pretty sure them & Aberdeen were. Klimpl went on trial with Cardiff but failed to win a contract & that is about as much as anyone knows really.

EDIT: Niz beat me too it. Although, I'm not sure Aberdeen or Motherwell offered a deal.

This post has been edited by Ludo *1: 30 August 2009 - 23:17

[Fife Saint]

Nizzy, on Aug 30 2009, 23:14, said:

Fantastic approach. I suggest Calum Melville throws one of his gold bullion bars at Jocky Scott's head. His subsequent death would remove a major barrier in Dundee's quest for promotion.

That won't be necessary. Dropping points at Airdrie and Raith will prove a far deadlier weapon against Jocky than the spoils of Die Hard: With A vengeance.

[Merkin]

Dunc, on Aug 30 2009, 23:13, said:

In that case, are Motherwell not interested in having him back because they can't afford him, or because Gannon just doesn't want him?

I'm actually surprised McGhee hasn't gone for him at Aberdeen. He's a free agent and even if wasn't going to walk into their first team, he proved he could play well at this level and McGhee seemed to take a shine to him.

Gannon seems to have his own ideas about the team and seems to be going for youngsters and has brought in a fair few new mid-fielders already so I don't think he's interested.

If this is true then this could be an excellent signing. A good mid-fielder, the kind of player who stops other teams playing. Picked up one or two yellows if I remember . He signed as a centre back but only played one game there - had an absolute howler against Hamilton at New Douglas Park - and then found good form playing as a holding mid.

[MP_MFC]

He was after the same 5k pw he was on at Midjytland (sp) I believe which Aberdeen balked at. If Dundee are offering him anywhere near that, I would be stunned.

As for him as a player, he certainly puts himself about. Became a bit of a cult hero to begin with due to his no nonsese style but as time went on and the bookings mounted, I think he ended up with about 10 in half a seasons play, many realised him to be a liability, whether it be missing games via suspension, stupid bookings and needless challenges giving away dangerous free kicks, I think we are better off with Giles Coke in his role as he seems to be twice the player of Klimpl already.

I have no doubt he'd do a job with any SPL side outwith the top 2 and would be stunned to see him go to Dundee.

[port-ton]

MP_MFC, on Aug 31 2009, 00:11, said:

He was after the same 5k pw he was on at Midjytland (sp) I believe which Aberdeen balked at. If Dundee are offering him anywhere near that, I would be stunned.

As for him as a player, he certainly puts himself about. Became a bit of a cult hero to begin with due to his no nonsese style but as time went on and the bookings mounted, I think he ended up with about 10 in half a seasons play, many realised him to be a liability, whether it be missing games via suspension, stupid bookings and needless challenges giving away dangerous free kicks, I think we are better off with Giles Coke in his role as he seems to be twice the player of Klimpl already.

I have no doubt he'd do a job with any SPL side outwith the top 2 and would be stunned to see him go to Dundee.

Im confused, are you saying he's a liability who would do a job for every team in the SPL except the Old Firm?

[Classy JL]

It's a done deal. He will be unveiled tomorrow.

[Reynard]

Nizzy, on Aug 30 2009, 23:14, said:

Fantastic approach. I suggest Calum Melville throws one of his gold bullion bars at Jocky Scott's head. His subsequent death would remove a major barrier in Dundee's quest for promotion.

[Reynard]

Why waste thousands of pounds a week on a guy that just kicks opponents? You could whistle at any junior ground and get a talentless thug from there for a fraction of the cost.

Klimpl was a big fucking stookie heid.

[MP_MFC]

port-ton, on Aug 31 2009, 00:32, said:

Im confused, are you saying he's a liability who would do a job for every team in the SPL except the Old Firm?

He has the potential to do a job if he can cut out the needless fouls I should have maybe said.

[madwullie]

Paying players 5k a week in the SFL is a sensible, sustainable business plan.

[Swello]

I think the main reason that 'Well fans (including me) took to Kilmpl was that he was the first guy we'd had in about 10 years that was prepared to get stuck in and was a whole-hearted player. A neutral or opposition fan probably just saw a dirty b*****d that couldn't tackle, pass or shoot very well. I'd imagine he'd be an excellent player in the first division.